Some more updates:
-Penalty time scaling increased to 3
-Shot power decreased to 45
-Slap shot power increased to 50
-Goalie cover frequency decreased to 60
-Goalie save reaction time decreased to 25
-CPU and teammate penalties increased to 30
-Tripping increased to 10
-High sticking increased to 50
Main focus here was to improve goalie play. I want who is in net to matter a bit more and the save reaction time slider works a bit like a seperate attribute effects slider for goalies. Decreased shot power to both increase goal variety and decrease misses a tad.
Increasing penalty time scaling improves PP percentages while not inflating shot totals too much. Special teams matters a bit more now.