NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

[Steve_OS]

A few days ago, gameplay started being released for NHL 20 from various sites like IGN...

Written By: Ryan

Click here to view the article.

[RBUDD88]

It is so bad , pulled my pre order just sticking with 2K and The Show for Now

[Sportsgamefan]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

The AI gameplay is just atrocious. I can't understand why they can't make the AI put more pressure on the puck carrier. Offensive zone entry is way too easy, just skate it in. The defense always drops back and gives up premium shooting chances every shift. Positioning is unheard of. Everyone is chasing the puck. Then the powerplay. How is it they can't get the AI to play power play? Players, whoever they are, have zero awareness.

I've seen enough to leave this game alone.

[nddurst]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

The AI gameplay is just atrocious. I can't understand why they can't make the AI put more pressure on the puck carrier. Offensive zone entry is way too easy, just skate it in. The defense always drops back and gives up premium shooting chances every shift. Positioning is unheard of. Everyone is chasing the puck. Then the powerplay. How is it they can't get the AI to play power play? Players, whoever they are, have zero awareness.

I've seen enough to leave this game alone.

I don't post here often, but felt I should in this case. The problems you list above have been an issue in this franchise for, what, 8 or 10 years now? I can't remember a version of EA NHL on current or last gen where defensive pressure was anywhere near realistic. They just keep ignoring the AI. And the goalies. And the depth. This series is a laughable representation of its sport.

This will be eighth straight version I will be skipping. I used to be a rabid fan of the series, hungry and excited around this time of the year. Beginning with '13 me energy and enthusiasm for this (and most other EA Sports games) has faded to the point where it doesn't even register any longer. It's really a shame, and I don't see it changing until another developer steps in to make a good hockey game.

EA Sports just doesn't cut it.

[Peter_OS]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

In the first period video, there was a total of three goals scored. All of the goals were scored by the New Jersey Devils, and all of the goals were almost identical and basically the same kind of goal we’ve seen a million times over the past decade in this franchise.

THIS EXACTLY! All the goals seem to be the same all the time. Been like this for years!!! Skate down the wing and either shoot or pass for a goal. You might get the ocassional slapshot goal from the point. That's it folks! Breakaways are rare, and you wont see the CPU have many of them either. There's just no structure on how the CPU and Human CPU AI plays in this game.

Have the development team seen videos of actually NHL games and goals? Pucks bouncing off players, goals scored from the boards, pucks trickling in on shots from the point and near the goal net. Put back goals. Wrap around goals from behind the net. 2 on 1s, 3 on 1s, 1 on 1s. The goalie physics and animations suck too! We see it all the time in the real NHL and not in this game. EA you got any clue on how to make a hockey game?? Smh..

EA has made a big deal about signature shooting and more control and authenticity, yet you see none in the videos we have seen so far. Is EA ****ing with us? No signature shots, no new scoring setups like Ryan said. Unbelievable... We should all sue them for false advertisement, or even better boycott them and don't buy their game.

EA have turned this franchise into an arcade "ping pong" video hockey game and neglected the hardcore sim fans who want more realism. They just don't care anymore. I've had more fun playing NHL 93 and 94 on my Genesis (which came out 27 years ago) then this piece of horse **** over the last 10 years.

I'm passing on this game this year and saving my money. EA can suck it!

Ryan thanks for your impressions buddy! Thanks for calling out EA on their game. They have lied to us for years and are giving us the same BS every year.

[pslieber]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

Nice post and analysis.

The most glaring flaw, to me, is the AI's inability to adapt to a human opponent with little creativity. Board breakout -> Center of neutral zone -> Cross crease pass, over and over again. On D: Defenceman stepping up at the blue line for big hit over and over again. Rinse wash repeat.

SJ didn't adjust tactics to cut off cross crease passing lanes, it failed to rely on team speed on breakouts (versus overpassing between D men), and didn't capitalize on the physical gambles by human player hitting.

If the AI can't adjust, I hold little confidence in CHEL playing any differently due to strategic programming flaws.

Game does look/sound nice, however. Nice lifts in presentation quality, skating representation, additional bouncing on passes (versus flat, tape to tape). Personally: I couldn't take any more Emrick. His shtick is old after a decade plus in the game, on TV.

[pslieber]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

The AI gameplay is just atrocious. I can't understand why they can't make the AI put more pressure on the puck carrier. Offensive zone entry is way too easy, just skate it in. The defense always drops back and gives up premium shooting chances every shift. Positioning is unheard of. Everyone is chasing the puck. Then the powerplay. How is it they can't get the AI to play power play? Players, whoever they are, have zero awareness.

I've seen enough to leave this game alone.

This. You almost want to be shorthanded based on these elements.

[MizzouRah]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

Same game with a new coat of paint?



Definitely not paying $60 for it.

[Rufio2031]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

Good to hear. Sounds like they've made zero progress since...2011? 12? But it's about the 3rd change in commentary which doesn't really provide anything to the game play?

[soulsphere]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

Its soo hard to listen to. Why do they always sound like they’re yelling?

[Dolphins88]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

I hope 2K or Sony make a hockey game .. football too

[badazzleroybrown]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

I really liked nhl 18 so i skipped 19 so my next purchase will be 19 the new anouncer is terrible

[jake19ny]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

I’ve posted longer review in the beta impressions so this will be short.

Zero player separation

Zero difference between teams

Braindead A.I.

Arcade commentary and overlays

This game continues to take leaps away from anything resembling the league it represents and offers nothing to the offline season or franchise guy. This development team either doesn’t understand the sport in which they are creating a game for or simply don’t care to accurately represent it.

[nikethebike]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

My suggestion is for you guys to support DJNEO and 2KHS on PC as that is the closest we get to some competition to EA.

[Peter_OS]

Re: NHL 20: Gameplay Impressions From Videos Released Across the Web

They should fire the lead developer of gameplay at EA for NHL and hire DJ NEO. His mod for 2KHS on PC is amazing! Ultra-realistic, physics-based hockey simulation. Leaps and bounds better than the garbage we are getting from EA every year, and he's doing this all for free!

All the more reason to say **** YOU EA!!!