[Rocky]

Quote: Originally Posted by LBzrule

The issue though is not whether you would put him over. The issue is would you put him in the same class or should I say tier? I'd say Thomas is a high silver that will be better than some gold players at things. As for Reed when I look at the rest of the WR's in the game he has to be a gold.

I disagree. Gold to me means you are the best of the best. You are among the best ever at your position. Thomas is not......great player, but he would NEVER come up in the same conversation of a Jim Brown, Walter Payton, or a Earl Campbell as all-time greats.