If i had to choose one, im going with NCAA 12 by a close margin. Either way im getting both.

At first I was sure I was only going to buy NCAA 12 but as info on madden came out over the past couple weeks Im not so sure anymore. It looks like they will play very similar so it's going to come down to presentation for me. NCAA seems to have the edge graphic and lighting wise but Madden looks pretty freakin good too and what intrigues me most about madden is that the madden team has been working with cbs and other networks to mimic their presentation style. there hasn't been much talk about NCAA 12 using this stuff(im hoping they are too). NCCA has a way better pre-game presentation but im wondering about what in-game will be like, for me that's what will influence my decision most(after gameplay ofcourse). Im still leaning toward college but I don't think there is enough info to really say one over the other. I might just end up buying NCAA playin till madden comes out and if madden turns out better ill trade it.

NCAA, dynasty because you can switch teams after a few seasons and in maddens franchise you're stuck with that team. I like getting madden and
ncaa though, since i like to play 1 season on ncaa then import the draft class and then play a season on madden and just keep switching back.

In my case it has to be Madden, as they won't release NCAA in Europe. If they did, I'd probably alternate between the two each year...

Looks like it will be both this year...

I have a feeling gameplay is going to be pretty much the same either way. So for me, if I had to decide (I'll actually be getting both) I would probably go with Madden only because I am extremely excited about the CBS inspired camera work, especially after seeing the Vick scene running into the huddle. Now if NCAA has done this as well then I would choose NCAA 12 due college ball being a little more exciting to me.

If Madden 12 drastically changes its gameplay to make it feel like NCAA 11 then id go with Madden 12 this year. The thing that NCAA did so much better than Madden last year was how the game FELT. It just FELT like football and controlling the players in NCAA felt much more responsive than madden.

NCAA 12 every time. Let down by Madden time and time again.

NCAA > Madden there is a wider range of varity of team.. not everyone picks the same teams, and i dont have to pick the same teams as well

Its gotta be NCAA12 where else you gonna see a man on a horse throw a flaming spear into the ground to start a football game Madden doesnt even know whos gonna play for who this year.

I'm going for NCAA 12. The whole game looks absolutely stunning and very promising.

Have both and ncaa has way better graphics