Best Madden This Gen

[Clemsonpanther]

I am leaving for college this weekend, and I want to take one edition of madden bc i wont have room for the others. I dont play often, i play ncaa way more, but im a serious gamer who would play cfm.

Which should i take and why? (Im not buying 18).

[cable guy]

Madden 16 was good. 17 was better imo

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[Smallville102001]

16 by far. 15 you would get like 12 sacks a game no matter what you did and like 8 of them were just because the CPU would not get rid of the ball. It killed drives and would result in fumbles that should have never happened either. It was a game killer. 16 and 17 that was not a problem at all. The CPU QB would still not try to run but they would at least get rid of the ball and not take sacks. 17 though the game got worse with updates.

[Toupal]

Madden 17 obviously.

It is like 15 and 16, however they have more added to it.

Player editing is HUGE for me.

[xCoachDx]

Quote: Originally Posted by Smallville102001

16 by far. 15 you would get like 12 sacks a game no matter what you did and like 8 of them were just because the CPU would not get rid of the ball. It killed drives and would result in fumbles that should have never happened either. It was a game killer. 16 and 17 that was not a problem at all. The CPU QB would still not try to run but they would at least get rid of the ball and not take sacks. 17 though the game got worse with updates.

Really funny that in your description of 15 you basically described 18 as well. Absolutely comical.

[Unlucky 13]

The game has gotten slightly better each year on this gen, so 17 is the best. Thankfully, its been a while since we've had terrible regression in the game. Still digging themselves out of the hole that they created between the PS2 and PS3 versions, though.

[kwpit79]

17, but only when you find a good slider set.