QFT.
I'm not sure what I can and can't say due to fear of it being misconstrued as bashing. I'll try to word it nicely because the intent isn't negative, I am just making a comparison.
Madden 07 (PS2)- This game lived and breathed energy, IMO and is still the high point of the franchise. I still play it to this day. To me it was the pinnacle of everything leading up to it. Madden 01 all the way up to 07, and you felt and visibly saw the game improve year to year. Obviously the menu went through changes, the uniform selections became deeper, the graphics improved, but what really got me in love with that game was how much there was to do in it, and how occupied those things would keep you. You had a franchise mode that literally had almost everything in it, but all the little things to keep you coming back for more. You name it:
-Owner Mode
-Restricted Free Agency
-TWO UFA periods (I liked this better)
-In FA, the CPU would periodically update with offers so you didn't necessarily get first dibs at everyone until you sim a day
-The Draft had reactions for each pick, as limited as they were, it was huge
-Individual/National Newspapers..Fun to look around the league.
-CPU traded amongst themselves and made roster moves. It felt like a 32 team league rather than 16 field trips.
-On that note, seeing the EA Ticker come up when you played a game showing the scores of previous games or games going on currently.
-Player Morale/Player Roles: I've seen Sean Considine make it to 96 OVR, just as I've seen Reggie Bush get tagged "1st Round Bust".
-Tony Bruno Show: Cool for it's time, something I would want back in some capacity in a new form.
Training Camp/Position Battles...SO MUCH FUN. Especially seeing who may win what job.
I could go on and on, but I need to save space for the other things. Franchise as a whole felt like a real experience that took a long time to create, and it was very easy to appreciate the game because it felt as organic as it did.
If Franchise wasn't your thing, Superstar Mode had become a GREAT way to kill time. This mode was incredibly improved upon from the Madden 06 version, and again you could feel the time and effort enslaved into making the game respond as if it were real. You WANTED to spend all day playing this game because it made you enjoy the game of football that much more...at least I did.
One of my all time favorite additions to the Madden franchise did not make the jump to next-gen, which was Tournament Mode.
My little brother, now 13, and I used to go and randomly select teams to fill all 16 seeds and do a Double Elimination tournament. We'd guess the winners, and see who would get more picks right. Really didn't do anything as far as playing it, but it was fun to do that. Of course, it makes having Madden parties that much easier.
I guess all I'm saying is when you take a look at Madden 11, which is a good football game in it's own right, it just doesn't feel the same. When I flip on the game, I immediately notice the graphic updates and flashier appearance, but it feels like dating the girl based on purely looks. I don't feel that sense of living, breathing excitement going on anymore. Now, maybe part of it is because I'm not 16 anymore. However, being 20 seems to be average if not a little younger than most of the people who hardcore-frequent this place like I do, so obviously I'm not "too old". I miss the deep core of the Madden franchise and since the move to next-gen the game has appeared to look a little more frail each iteration. I still play nearly every day, but it feels like now it's because I'm hoping that I can force myself to enjoy it as I remember it like the old games. Ian has done a great job righting the ship since Madden 10...I truly believe in the direction of Madden if they are going away from In-Game Ads. My only fear is everyone else's fear.
-I already have to pay to keep a player out of retirement, something that has happened yearly with Favre and the three teams he has made pay
I can only hope the direction of M12 and beyond puts everything that is a natural part of the NFL game, lifestyle and business as a stock part of the disc I pay $60.00 for. All the extras, fine, charge all you want. If all that should be there is there, I'd be much more likely to purchase extra.
/endmassivewalloftext