Well every archetype except lockdown denfender has the same defensive cap rating. Now size and weight might make a difference but not much. Shot creator is not very fast with the ball. And the speed without the ball doesn't max out for that build. Playmaker is the only one that gets max speed and acceleration and max playmaking skills. I wish they had one scoring badge. I made a slasher because of the badges. They have the second highest raid playmakers skills too but cant shot a catch and shoot shot at all. I love him so far. I always drive to the basket. But playmakers would be the best for being pretty good at everything.
Oh and the speed cap for shot creator is around the mid 80's and with the ball mid 70's. So you would have to be really creative with dribble moves to free you up for a shot.