NCAA 11 rosters (360)?

[yanks26ngoin]

Quote: Originally Posted by BigHouse14

No problem. Just to clarify the "I think player A is faster than player B" suggestions won't be in the roster. Even ones that I think are fairly unbiased (i.e. - I've stated I believe Tate Forcier SPD is too high, and so is Robert Bolden's (PSU Freshman QB)) have not been changed.

Actually, I just played with Tate, and the speed really doesnt seem that high in this game. In fact, it seems to me that its just right for him. I guess thats because speed isnt everything in this game, thank god! As for Denard, yikes, was that man robbed! I broke off a big run with him, and well, 92 does not do him justice by the looks of it. I mean, if he was where I think would be just right for him, like a 94 or a 95, he would have been gone. If it was in real life, there was no way that the LB would have caught him from behind, which is what happened in the game

[boostedms3]

hes right never thought of it that way

[boltz433]

If you need me to do any teams I'm available, just let me know. Thanks

[BCJMU99]

Quote: Originally Posted by Krioniq

Mack left the team. Along with Quintin Hunter, Javanti Sparrow, Lamar Milstead, and one or two other guys.

I knew the others did, wasn't sure about Mack...Thanks!

[chapmanosu1]

Quote: Originally Posted by LC AAU

Hey Carson just wanted to let you know you forgot to add Justin Siller, QB to Purdue. He was reinstated this year after being academically in eligible last season. He was suppose to start at QB last year and may start this year

Siller's not going to play any QB.

And Marve's already been named starter.

[bluengold34_OS]

Quit with the "status" request. When they have an update, they will post on it. If someone ask again, please report it right away. So it might not be the smartest thing to ask again!

[KleShreen]

I remember back on GameCube and PS2 when I was naming rosters each year...I think I was the only one who was pissed that they moved the roster number from 55 to 70. I sat there for a couple hours after reading that going "this is going to add 5-10 more minutes to each team." Haha.

Kudos to you guys...got out of the business a while ago, so I know what it takes.

[HMBBabyface]

This may or may not be helpful. Kinda did this out of my own curiosity. ESPN's writer for the Big Ten ranked the top 25 players in the conference as of the preseason and I think the list is pretty solid. You can make arguments for players to go either way but all of them are more or less correct. I've compared them with their in-game rankings and a few things stick out:

# No. 1: Iowa DE Adrian Clayborn - 91
# No. 2: Michigan State LB Greg Jones - 95
# No. 3: Ohio State DL Cameron Heyward - 95
# No. 4: Wisconsin RB John Clay - 94
# No. 5: Iowa S Tyler Sash - 94
# No. 6: Penn State RB Evan Royster - 94
# No. 7: Ohio State QB Terrelle Pryor - 94
# No. 8: Penn State G/C Stefen Wisniewski - 93
# No. 9: Ohio State G Justin Boren - 92
# No. 10: Purdue DE Ryan Kerrigan -92
# No. 11: Wisconsin LT Gabe Carimi - 96
# No. 12: Ohio State LB Ross Homan - 93
# No. 13: Purdue WR Keith Smith - 93
# No. 14: Indiana WR Tandon Doss - 88
# No. 15: Wisconsin G/C John Moffitt - 92
# No. 16: Wisconsin LB Chris Borland - 86
# No. 17: Ohio State WR DeVier Posey - 93
# No. 18: Iowa QB Ricky Stanzi - 89
# No. 19: Wisconsin QB Scott Tolzien - 89
# No. 20: Ohio State LB Brian Rolle - 90
# No. 21: Michigan State QB Kirk Cousins - 86
# No. 22: Northwestern LB Quentin Davie - 90
# No. 23: Iowa DT Karl Klug - 81
# No. 24: Illinois RB Mikel LeShoure - 80
# No. 25: Wisconsin DE J.J. Watt - 88

Big Ten Players who might be overrated:
Indiana LT Andrew McDonald - 88
Iowa LT Riley Rieff - 93
Iowa FS Brett Greenwood - 92
Michigan C David Molk - 96
Michigan RE Craig Roh - 91
Michigan DT Mike Martin - 90
Michigan State C John Stipek - 91
Ohio State CB Chimdi Chekwa - 94
Ohio State DT Dexter Larimore - 94
Ohio State C Michael Brewster - 94
Wisconsin RG Kevin Zeitler - 94
Wisconsin RT Josh Oglesby - 94
Wisconsin C Peter Konz - 93

I put players who were not on the list but highly ranked in the questionable list. It seems Wisconsin as a whole is way overpowered this year. They're a good team, but both times I simmed through the season, they won the NC against Alabama. (I love the Big Ten, but REALLY?) Being an Iowa fan and it being the program I know best, I'll use it as an example), my biggest issue is with Clayborn (and really, Iowa's defense as a whole. How can a Top 5 defense be rated a B+ on the same team as an A- offense that was at best questionable (or lucky). Once again EA shows love to OSU, probably unfairly. I'm not saying these changes should be made right now (I'm really appreciative for what you all are doing). I'm just wondering what Kool-Aid EA was drinking.