Babs is marginally better than Russell, but better nevertheless. Babs is fine as a backup, but I just don't believe he's good as a starter. We're trying to polish a turd, here....we DEFINITELY need to get a great safety if one is available in the first round. And o-line help, but I'm hearing the draft is a little anemic this year at OL
The 2005 team was finesse all the way. Alexander was not a hard-nosed runner, he ran with vision and finding holes and seams and avoided contact. Marion Barber is his opposite. Our defense was fast, fast, fast, but not sizeable or exceptionally physical. We won games with efficient and time-consuming offense that would march and score, forcing the other team to play catch up ball and our speedy defense reaping sacks and some picks occasionally as a result. We were exposed if our O got shut down and our defense had to be on the field for a long time.
Hutch was a beast, but his leaving was complicated. By all accounts, he did not want to be here, and his agent and the Vikings concocted the 'poison pill' contract, and Ruskell mishandled Hutch from our end before and during negotiations. Even if he had somehow stayed, he wouldn't have been happy here, and possibly not as good as a result.
I'm in total agreement that we aren't going anywhere until our o-line is solid. If you can't protect the QB or run-block, you are not moving the chains. You are punting or turning the ball over and leaving your defense on the field for far too long, and our defense is built for speed, not endurance.
So, let's just hope Ruskell does his homework and finds one or two OL diamonds in the rough for us in the draft, or can somehow land young talent in FA for the OL....and get us a great safety, too.