Objective Evidence - Living Worlds in APF 2K8 and Madden 25 - thoughts?

[illiterateoption]

I had posted this in another thread that got shut down for "trolling." Since when does providing objective evidence mean trolling - I could possibly see it if I posted this in the Madden Forums but I placed the following link in the "other football games" section. My apologies for not understanding "trolling."


All - I wanted to share an example of Living Worlds done in APF 2K8 when compared to Madden 25 (Next Gen).

APF2K8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzfzVZmyjaI

Madden 25 Next Gen

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Han5do8R0vs


What do you think? Does APF stand the test of time or has Madden surpassed it? I'm curious to hear your thoughts.

[illiterateoption]

For the record - I own Madden 25/NCAA 14 for Current Gen. I'm not an EA ***** because I've voted with my wallet. I'm curious if the environment in Next Gen Madden exceeds that, and I hope it does, found in APF.

How do players respond to big plays - are the reactions appropriate and well timed - how many reactions are present?

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by illiterateoption

I had posted this in another thread that got shut down for "trolling." Since when does providing objective evidence mean trolling

Your first thread was two sentences and a link.

No mention of a discussion at all. That's why it was closed.

This thread actually poses a legitimate discussion...

[db56]

25 has improved in the presentation dept. the crowd looks better but they are not at all in tune with what is going on on the field.

2K8 gets the nod here...

[illiterateoption]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

Your first thread was two sentences and a link. No mention of a discussion at all. That's why it was closed. This thread actually poses a legitimate discussion...

Fair enough...,now I know. I appreciate the explanation - happy thanksgiving!

[MINATAURO]

APF gets my vote on this topic but im really enjoying M25 on my Xbox One, first time in a while.

[FaceMask]

Quote: Originally Posted by db56

25 has improved in the presentation dept.

How so? It's the exact same presentation from the 360/PS3 version and that presentation is the absolute worst in sports gaming by a mile. They didn't even bother to make new overlays for the game.

I can see that the A.I. has clearly improved especially DB play, but the presentation is 2 generations behind where it should be.

[Segagendude]

I own neither, but simply judging by the vids, I'd have to go with APF.