MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

[BravoSir]

Predict the player overall ratings for your favorite team for MLB 15 The Show! Many player ratings have been shown in some of the videos already out there. Let's predict player overall ratings for your favorite team.

I'll start with mine, the Braves (a "*" means the rating is already known, as it has been shown in videos). This is also my prediction of the Opening Day Roster:

--Rotation
SP Julio Teheran 83
*SP Alex Wood 83
*SP Shelby Miller 80
SP Mike Minor 77
*SP Eric Stults 74

--Bullpen
CP Craig Kimbrel 96
RP Jason Grilli 75
RP Jim Johnson 72
RP James Russell 74
RP Josh Outman 67
RP Arodys Vizcaino 69
RP/SP Wandy Rodriguez 75

--Lineup
*RF Nick Markakis 81
2B Phil Gosselin 75
1B Freddie Freeman 86
LF Jonny Gomes 76
3B Chris Johnson 76
C Christian Bethancourt 72
SS Andrelton Simmons 83
CF BJ Upton 75

--Bench
2B Alberto Callaspo 70
C AJ Pierzynski 70
3B Kelly Johnson 72
OF Eric Young Jr 69
OF Zoilo Almonte 67

--Other Ratings Already Known:
OF Jose Constanza 59
RP Donnie Veal 72

[ajblithe20]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

I'd love to guess but they already showed most of the O's ratings during their Diamond Dynasty stream.

I will say I thought most of the ratings looked pretty good. If I had guessed before seeing them, I would've thought Machado to be higher than 83 (I think that's what he was shown as). Maybe Adam Jones could've been in the 90s, but he needs to work on that Plate Discipline for sure!

I also think just going off memory of last year your ratings for the Braves look pretty spot on. Maybe Freddie Freeman a little bit higher?

[pittsburgher86]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

My guesses for my team, the Pittsburgh Pirates. Ratings in parenthesis are ratings I noticed from the twitch stream from thursday.

--Rotation
SP Gerrit Cole 83 (88)
SP Francisco Liriano 82 (81)
SP AJ Burnett 76 (75)
SP Charlie Morton 76
SP Jeff Locke 74 (75)
SP Brandon Cumpton (76) [I personally don't expect to make the roster, would've guessed 70]

--Bullpen
CP Mark Melancon 84
RP Tony Watson 81
RP Jared Hughes 76
RP John Holdzkom 71
RP Bobby La Fromboise 66
SP/RP Vance Worley 74
[7th position unsure who it'd even be]

--Lineup
3B Josh Harrison 81 (87)
RF Gregory Polanco 76 (77)
CF Andrew McCutchen 97 (95)
2B Neil Walker 78 [82]
LF Starling Marte 84 (86)
1B Pedro Alvarez 70 [76]
SS Jordy Mercer 77
C Francisco Cervelli 68

--Bench
C Christ Stewart 65
1B Corey Hart 72
RF Andrew Lambo 70
UTIL Sean Rodriguez 67
SS Jung-Ho Kang 73 (won't be on original roster)

[Will I Am]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Giants: Bumgarner 99

Dodgers: Kershaw 98

[ShowTyme15]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Giants: Bumgarner 99

Dodgers: Kershaw 98

Pretty sure Kershaw will still be a 99. The guy went 21-3 (Cy Young/MVP). I can see MadBum being a 99 idk if he'll get that, but it wouldn't shock me if he did.

[Will I Am]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Pretty sure Kershaw will still be a 99. The guy went 21-3 (Cy Young/MVP). I can see MadBum being a 99 idk if he'll get that, but it wouldn't shock me if he did.

Yeah I was just joking, Giants fan here.

Kershaw should get a 100 rating when ever he faces the Giants.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Yeah I was just joking, Giants fan here.

Ahhhhhh okay I wasn't sure. Either way though I wouldn't be surprised if MadBum did get a 99 rating. He'll definitely be close to it.

[HypoLuxa13]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

My guesses for my team, the Pittsburgh Pirates.

--Rotation
SP Gerrit Cole 83
SP Francisco Liriano 82
SP AJ Burnett 76
SP Charlie Morton 76
SP Jeff Locke 74

--Bullpen
CP Mark Melancon 84
RP Tony Watson 81
RP Jared Hughes 76
RP John Holdzkom 71
RP Bobby La Fromboise 66
SP/RP Vance Worley 74
(7th position unsure who it'd even be)

--Lineup
3B Josh Harrison 81
RF Gregory Polanco 76
CF Andrew McCutchen 97
2B Neil Walker 78
LF Starling Marte 84
1B Pedro Alvarez 70
SS Jordy Mercer 77
C Francisco Cervelli 68

--Bench
C Christ Stewart 65
1B Corey Hart 72
RF Andrew Lambo 70
UTIL Sean Rodriguez 67
SS Jung-Ho Kang 73 (won't be on original roster)

Go back and check out the twitch stream archive from Thursday

[pittsburgher86]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Go back and check out the twitch stream archive from Thursday

I am watching it currently . Will be editing my predictions post with real player ratings seen from the stream.

[RLebron12]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

That was my one question...what will MadBum be. Will they give him the proper respect he's due and have him up there or are they going to give him like a 93? We pretty much know the rest of the Giants stats. Personally think Belt should be a little higher. Feel like they don't give him enough credit on defense. I personally think he's a future Gold Glover.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mrhenry209]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

I'd be interested to see where Verlander is ranked, considering his awful season last year. Here are my best guesses, although in the past relievers have been rated lower across the board than I would have them.

Pitchers

SP D. Price (93)
SP J. Verlander (86)
SP A. Sanchez (85)
SP S. Greene (74)
SP A. Simon (72)

CL J. Nathan (70)
SU J. Soria (73)
RHP B. Rondon (68)
RHP A. Alburquerque (72)
RHP T. Gorzellany (71)
LHP I. Krol (67)
LHP B. Hardy (70)

Position Players

C A. Avila (73)
1B M. Cabrera (94)
2B I. Kinsler (87)
SS J. Iglesias (76)
3B N. Castellanos (72)
LF Y. Cespedes (89)
CF R. Davis (75)
RF J.D. Martinez (77)
DH V. Martinez (92)

C J. McCann (68)
SS/2B A. Romine (66)
CF A. Gose (70)
RF S. Moya (67)

[ajblithe20]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

I'd be interested to see where Verlander is ranked, considering his awful season last year. Here are my best guesses, although in the past relievers have been rated lower across the board than I would have them.

Pitchers

SP D. Price (93)
SP J. Verlander (86)
SP A. Sanchez (85)
SP S. Greene (74)
SP A. Simon (72)

CL J. Nathan (70)
SU J. Soria (73)
RHP B. Rondon (68)
RHP A. Alburquerque (72)
RHP T. Gorzellany (71)
LHP I. Krol (67)
LHP B. Hardy (70)

Position Players

C A. Avila (73)
1B M. Cabrera (94)
2B I. Kinsler (87)
SS J. Iglesias (76)
3B N. Castellanos (72)
LF Y. Cespedes (89)
CF R. Davis (75)
RF J.D. Martinez (77)
DH V. Martinez (92)

C J. McCann (68)
SS/2B A. Romine (66)
CF A. Gose (70)
RF S. Moya (67)

Not to say that Ubaldo Jiminez is or ever has been that comparable to Verlander, but he's a 69 overall on MLB 15 I believe. He was an 81 I think last year, so you might expect a little bigger of a dip for Verlander than an 86

[mrhenry209]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

Not to say that Ubaldo Jiminez is or ever has been that comparable to Verlander, but he's a 69 overall on MLB 15 I believe. He was an 81 I think last year, so you might expect a little bigger of a dip for Verlander than an 86

I don't remember if it was The Show, but I remember hearing that some sports franchise used ratings averaged from the past 3 seasons. If that indeed is the case with The Show, 86 would be more justifiable, but based on Ubaldo's 69 perhaps a 78/79 would be more in line for Verlander.

[Jimmydm90]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

I'm curious to see how they rate the Giant's Joe Panik after his stellar rookie season.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: MLB 15 The Show Player Rating Predictions

I'm curious to see how they rate the Giant's Joe Panik after his stellar rookie season.

He's a 74 overall.

That was my one question...what will MadBum be. Will they give him the proper respect he's due and have him up there or are they going to give him like a 93? We pretty much know the rest of the Giants stats. Personally think Belt should be a little higher. Feel like they don't give him enough credit on defense. I personally think he's a future Gold Glover.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk