Re: A problem with year to year saves

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Log was always scrapped. I've been pushing to have the log maintain the whole season.

Everything auto. Injuries on, 30 team control, traded set to instant.

Also using latest live roster.

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

I saw it in a new '15 franchise start....as it was last year......(except for the waiver deals)

I want to start a new franchise in 14....move it to 15 and see what happens.

M.K.
Knight165

My Y2Y was new. Although it was technically an MLB 14 save from the 2015 season. It started at the very beginning of the year.

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Log was always scrapped. I've been pushing to have the log maintain the whole season.

Everything auto. Injuries on, 30 team control, traded set to instant.

Also using latest live roster.

My trades were not set to instant. Why would that matter?

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Might not. Just accounting for all variables.

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Ok. Thanks.

So just to be clear, the on-screen trade notifications in your experience account for all trades?

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Seems to be. I have double checked. Last year they didn't all appear. What roster are you using? An edited one could impact logic.

Is EVERYTHING set to auto for all teams?

[sink4ever]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

I wonder if the number of trades are at all correlated with the number of teams in a season that have a status of "Playoff Push" or "Rebuilding".

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

What do you want to bet it's the instant trades causing this and not the Y2Y saves?

First sim with instant trades on...

23.

Too many are getting "declined." I'd almost bet on it.

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

What do you want to bet it's the instant trades causing this and not the Y2Y saves?

First sim with instant trades on...

23.

Too many are getting "declined." I'd almost bet on it.

With y2y you had that number of trades?

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

With y2y you had that number of trades?

No. This was in a fresh MLB 15 Franchise.

With Instant Trades off, I had 12 and 9.

With Instant Trades on, I had 23.

Now let me ask you this, how would someone turn Instant Trades on using a Y2Y save? Isn't that an option you would have had to picked BEFORE starting the Franchise (meaning back in MLB 2014)?

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Basically, let's forget for a second that my first three sims were using a Y2Y file and think more about the Instant Trade option.

With Instant Trades off, over five sims:

14 (Y2Y)
11 (Y2Y)
14 (Y2Y)
12 (2015)
9 (2015)

And the second I turn Instant Trades on get an approximate 40% increase:

23

Which is very similar to the totals you and Knight had. Let me guess, you both had Instant Trades on when you saw total trades in the 20's?

I can definitely sim more as this is a theory I have but my first sim toggling the feature was pretty shocking.

[Knight165]

Re: A problem with year to year saves

Basically, let's forget for a second that my first three sims were using a Y2Y file and think more about the Instant Trade option.

With Instant Trades off, over five sims:

14 (Y2Y)
11 (Y2Y)
14 (Y2Y)
12 (2015)
9 (2015)

And the second I turn Instant Trades on get an approximate 40% increase:

23

Which is very similar to the totals you and Knight had. Let me guess, you both had Instant Trades on when you saw total trades in the 20's?

I can definitely sim more as this is a theory I have but my first sim toggling the feature was pretty shocking.

Makes sense in some respects.
With the 3 day window.....the trade proposed and being considered is under some fairly specific conditions.
In those three days and injury could occur which would probably negate one of the variables causing a "no" to the trade.
Good find and hopefully something they can look at if we do determine it's the case.

No way to turn instant trades on/off once you start though.

M.K.
Knight165