MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

[jdiaz891]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Frazier having a career year exactly when he and the club needs it? Hitting 100 points higher than his career average over 3000+ AB's? 1 low B SP prospect.







This year, 2 high C prospects. Keep it in context as my answer is going to be different for the next franchise ('17 vs. '19)

White Sox Receive Marcos Molina

Mets Receive Todd Frazier

White Soxs Receive Yasmany Tomas

DiamondBacks Receive Jameson Fisher and Amado Nunez



Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[hampshirestags]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

White Sox Receive Marcos Molina

Mets Receive Todd Frazier

White Soxs Receive Yasmany Tomas

DiamondBacks Receive Jameson Fisher and Amado Nunez



Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

I like where you're headed with this. After looking at the 2 packages, I have an alternate suggestion (which puts a neat spin on it). Frazier is raking (I'm assuming you're pushing the buttons in every game with no sims?), he'll come back down to Earth but will still provide the pop needed in the NYM lineup. Let's add L.Guillorme (he's blocked seven ways from Sunday with the Mets) to the deal for Frazier. Then, since J.Fisher has shown potential and injury concern at the same time, swap A.Nunez with L.Guillmore and buy yourself Y.Tomas.

This gets proper value for Frazier and gives ARZ two decent prospects...hopefully one of them makes the show.

[dran1984]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Everything I've read in the last 20 min or so tells me this kid can play anywhere in the grass and add value immediately. I came across one of those rumors that involved J.Iglesias and DET said no. That should throw up red flags everywhere on SD perceived value of him.

I'm going to go back and see what your deal was. Weren't you the guy that wanted to trade A.Jones? Was this his replacement?

Yea, I'm sending Jones to the Dodgers and Jankowski will be his replacement. Butcher also adds depth for when I work out a trade for Britton.

[jdiaz891]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

I like where you're headed with this. After looking at the 2 packages, I have an alternate suggestion (which puts a neat spin on it). Frazier is raking (I'm assuming you're pushing the buttons in every game with no sims?), he'll come back down to Earth but will still provide the pop needed in the NYM lineup. Let's add L.Guillorme (he's blocked seven ways from Sunday with the Mets) to the deal for Frazier. Then, since J.Fisher has shown potential and injury concern at the same time, swap A.Nunez with L.Guillmore and buy yourself Y.Tomas.



This gets proper value for Frazier and gives ARZ two decent prospects...hopefully one of them makes the show.

Sounds great . Thanks I'll make the adjustment . And yes I do play every game every year on hall of fame I really enjoy it . I feel like in legend the CPU gets a little out of control with the long ball .

On a side note . I have josh bell switching between 1B RF and DH. I'm thinking about moving Jose Abreu who is also raking. Does he fit with the Blue Jays , Rangers or Astros ? All are contending but don't have any significant injuries


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[hampshirestags]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Yea, I'm sending Jones to the Dodgers and Jankowski will be his replacement. Butcher also adds depth for when I work out a trade for Britton.

This hurts my heart (at least you're sending him 'home'). Also, it's the major reason why I don't comment on O's trades as I know that team/farm inside and out, backwards/forwards. It's impossible for me to be objective and the one thing I try my hardest to do in responses is to be consistent.

We debated our approaches a few days ago so I won't rehash. Good luck and I hope you build a winner for the Charm city!

[hampshirestags]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Sounds great . Thanks I'll make the adjustment . And yes I do play every game every year on hall of fame I really enjoy it . I feel like in legend the CPU gets a little out of control with the long ball .

On a side note . I have josh bell switching between 1B RF and DH. I'm thinking about moving Jose Abreu who is also raking. Does he fit with the Blue Jays , Rangers or Astros ? All are contending but don't have any significant injuries


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

First, I'll apologize in advance. I recognize your name as a consistent poster but I respond to a lot of questions so I don't remember how you got J.Bell. That being said, I'm sky high on J.Abreu so we might want to wait on someone else to chime in on his value.

As far as need, HOU has 1B covered, along with DH (probably) so if TOR or TEX haven't made any major moves with their trade currency, those are the two teams you should look at. We did a similar move a few weeks ago sending E.Hosmer to TEX with J.Profar involved, check Mr. Seredipity spreadsheet and you might be looking at a similar package. Though (again, I'm really high on Abreu), I think J.Abreu>E.Hosmer.

[bravesfan1984]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys, what do you think it would take to acquire Aaron Hicks from NYY in my Braves franchise, which I haven't started yet so I have no stats. Do you think a swap of Wisler or Blair might do?

[BlueJays09]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Leonys Martin got DFA by Seattle . I traded for him to be my everyday center fielder for the rest of the season . Fast , Good arm .

Edit: Angel Pagan can be picked up if he's still a free agent . I picked him up as well ( Wasn't comfortable with the White Soxs outfield)

Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Young, cheap, fast OF that can hit for contact...aren't we all! I'll poke around a little but like Jdiaz brought up, L.Martin can be had for a 10 game package of box seats at Rogers. He can fill in until you find better (maybe next years FA class?).



I'm all about getting K.Pillar some help out there. I want you guys at full strength when the O's take ya'll to the woodshed this year. We owe you one!

Thanks guys! I am still considering Pagan. I looked at Martin and he was playing better in my franchise than real life. Not sure on exact stats at this point but I will look when I get home. Paulo Orlando is my other option. Will maybe make a decision this weekend.

Thanks for the input you guys.

PS: hampshirestags I hope the Jays turn it around so we can see some good competitive games come October


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jdiaz891]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

First, I'll apologize in advance. I recognize your name as a consistent poster but I respond to a lot of questions so I don't remember how you got J.Bell. That being said, I'm sky high on J.Abreu so we might want to wait on someone else to chime in on his value.



As far as need, HOU has 1B covered, along with DH (probably) so if TOR or TEX haven't made any major moves with their trade currency, those are the two teams you should look at. We did a similar move a few weeks ago sending E.Hosmer to TEX with J.Profar involved, check Mr. Seredipity spreadsheet and you might be looking at a similar package. Though (again, I'm really high on Abreu), I think J.Abreu>E.Hosmer.

I received Josh Bell and Taylor Glasnow for Quintana . That was one of the early trades discussed here for Quintana. Out of curiosity I always save the gave and sim the rest of the season just to see how it pans out and Quintana always has a killer year and takes them deep into the playoffs .

I'm high on Jose Abreu as well so it's difficult to gauge his value. He's also having a really good year in my franchise.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[jdiaz891]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys, what do you think it would take to acquire Aaron Hicks from NYY in my Braves franchise, which I haven't started yet so I have no stats. Do you think a swap of Wisler or Blair might do?

Looking back through the pages Gamecocks17 said a High C should get the trade done.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[brandonholmes]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

First, I'll apologize in advance. I recognize your name as a consistent poster but I respond to a lot of questions so I don't remember how you got J.Bell. That being said, I'm sky high on J.Abreu so we might want to wait on someone else to chime in on his value.

As far as need, HOU has 1B covered, along with DH (probably) so if TOR or TEX haven't made any major moves with their trade currency, those are the two teams you should look at. We did a similar move a few weeks ago sending E.Hosmer to TEX with J.Profar involved, check Mr. Seredipity spreadsheet and you might be looking at a similar package. Though (again, I'm really high on Abreu), I think J.Abreu>E.Hosmer.

TOR has too many 1B/DH types as it is right now. Morales, Pearce should be at first, Bautista could be moved there if he loses another step, etc. I'd say TEX is the best bet for Abreu.

[milldaddy35]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What would the Rays get for Derek Norris? He is playing a little above average. .255/.317/.397

[Armor and Sword]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

OK I'm throwing this out there for discussion. A trade deadline deal. Yankees going after Yu Darvish. Thoughts, comments and possible trade packages?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Bard]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

OK I'm throwing this out there for discussion. A trade deadline deal. Yankees going after Yu Darvish. Thoughts, comments and possible trade packages?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Top 51-75 prospect in baseball is his value if he is doing well. Prior to Judge going off that would have been a fair swap.

Sent from my SM-G925V using Tapatalk

[GamecocksLaw17]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Top 51-75 prospect in baseball is his value if he is doing well. Prior to Judge going off that would have been a fair swap.

Sent from my SM-G925V using Tapatalk

So if Yu is absolutely lights out you might could talk me into Frazier to headline. I think very very good Yu could get Rutherford as headliner. I think normal Yu could get Sheffield and Mateo

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app