MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

[millertime98]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I was considering of starting a franchise with an AL team for once, preferably a young and upcoming team rather than established one (good farm system is a plus). I was considering Minnesota but definitely open to suggestions! Anyone started one with the Twins on here?

The first franchise I do when the game comes out is the Reds. I also do others and my two "hometown" teams are two of the worst: Reds and Tigers. I think Detroit is a pretty good team to use for a rebuild. They have an awesome stadium. 1 elite team in division. Are similar to the Reds in that they have an older 1B with a massive contract, and have to be rebuilt with the draft and FA.

[DarthRambo]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

Side note,

I have no idea how some of you get any hits on HOF, or higher. I'm watching everyone in my lineup's batting average drop significantly by the day after switching to All-Star (hitting) in this 4-game series against the Giants.

I tried HOF hitting for a bit but was too frustrated as well. I play with PCI off and directional, timing hitting interface too though. I think if you're good at placing the PCI you cam hit on any level imo...

I went back down to Allstar and sticking with it. Have games where I get 10+ hits, then a game or two in a row where I can't get any more than 5 or 6 hits.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

[ktd1976]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

Side note,

I have no idea how some of you get any hits on HOF, or higher. I'm watching everyone in my lineup's batting average drop significantly by the day after switching to All-Star (hitting) in this 4-game series against the Giants.

I tried HOF hitting for a bit but was too frustrated as well. I play with PCI off and directional, timing hitting interface too though. I think if you're good at placing the PCI you cam hit on any level imo...

I went back down to Allstar and sticking with it. Have games where I get 10+ hits, then a game or two in a row where I can't get any more than 5 or 6 hits.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

Not sure what your individual approaches are to hitting, and I don't want to assume. But, hitting on Hall of Fame isn't as hard as you would think.

I use Directional hitting, so it relies mainly on the timing of the swing, and the individual hitter's ratings.

But, my approach is this. On 0-0, 1-0, 1-1, 2-0 ,2-1, 3-0, 3-1 counts, I look for a certain pitch in a certain location. If I get it, I swing. If I don't, I lay off. That way, in those "hitters counts" if I swing, it is at MY pitch.

With 2 strikes, I go into "protect the plate" mode. I will use contact swing. I compare it to "choking up on the bat"

Don't swing at a pitch just because it is a strike. Don't be afraid to take a strike if it wasn't the pitch/location you were looking for.

61 games into my Tigers franchise (I play EVERY PITCH of EVERY game, no sim)

.298 Team batting average, 1st in the Major Leagues
362 Runs scored, 1st in MLB
650 Hits, 1st MLB
121 Doubles, 1st MLB
19 Triples, 1st MLB
94 Home Runs, 1st MLB
357 RBI, 1st MLB
21 Stolen Bases, T 28th, MLB
179 BB 22nd, MLB (I have never been great at drawing walks, but this year has been better)
300 Strikeouts, fewest in MLB
.501 Slugging pct. 1st MLB
.353 OBP, 1st MLB

[DarthRambo]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

Not sure what your individual approaches are to hitting, and I don't want to assume. But, hitting on Hall of Fame isn't as hard as you would think.

I use Directional hitting, so it relies mainly on the timing of the swing, and the individual hitter's ratings.

But, my approach is this. On 0-0, 1-0, 1-1, 2-0 ,2-1, 3-0, 3-1 counts, I look for a certain pitch in a certain location. If I get it, I swing. If I don't, I lay off. That way, in those "hitters counts" if I swing, it is at MY pitch.

With 2 strikes, I go into "protect the plate" mode. I will use contact swing. I compare it to "choking up on the bat"

Don't swing at a pitch just because it is a strike. Don't be afraid to take a strike if it wasn't the pitch/location you were looking for.

61 games into my Tigers franchise (I play EVERY PITCH of EVERY game, no sim)

.298 Team batting average, 1st in the Major Leagues
362 Runs scored, 1st in MLB
650 Hits, 1st MLB
121 Doubles, 1st MLB
19 Triples, 1st MLB
94 Home Runs, 1st MLB
357 RBI, 1st MLB
21 Stolen Bases, T 28th, MLB
179 BB 22nd, MLB (I have never been great at drawing walks, but this year has been better)
300 Strikeouts, fewest in MLB
.501 Slugging pct. 1st MLB
.353 OBP, 1st MLB

I play using quick counts only which does add in an element of difficulty to it. Prolly why Allstar is fine for me. I do remember playing a couple games with QC off and I drew tons of walks and seemed to hit and score fairly easily though.

I'd say if you are hitting on Allstar to play with quick counts on if you don't want to bump up to HOF. HOF and quick counts on was pretty difficult for me.

And if you're getting those type of stats with the Tigers you may want to try on Legend lol. I do play the game with pitching on HOF though, but again quick counts is always on so it adds in a bit more difficulty.

[ktd1976]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I play using quick counts only which does add in an element of difficulty to it. Prolly why Allstar is fine for me. I do remember playing a couple games with QC off and I drew tons of walks and seemed to hit and score fairly easily though.

I'd say if you are hitting on Allstar to play with quick counts on if you don't want to bump up to HOF. HOF and quick counts on was pretty difficult for me.

And if you're getting those type of stats with the Tigers you may want to try on Legend lol. I do play the game with pitching on HOF though, but again quick counts is always on so it adds in a bit more difficulty.

Tigers still have pretty decent hitting. I pitch on Legend, and am still dominating pitching wise. Still, if I keep hitting like this, I might need to bump up to legend.

[dougdfc]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

What team is the most barebones of them? I'm thinking Miami maybe?

[DarthRambo]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

What team is the most barebones of them? I'm thinking Miami maybe?

The Reds are really bad

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

[alston4659]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

So I'm now in the second season of my Phillies franchise and I couldn't be more excited about the future. We went 100-62 last year and that was with me playing about 65 percent of the games. After the all star break I pretty much went into sim mode as I was looking to get to the offseason and make some moves. During last season though, I ended up trading away guys like Jake Arrieta, Maikel Franco and 3 members of my bullpen (Neshek, Hunter and Garcia) because I wanted a few more prospects and I knew these guys were just eating up money that could be used for future free agents. As for moves that made a impact for our team last season, I acquired Kevin Kiermaier from the Rays for a couple A prospects and reliever Trevor Rosenthal who I picked up via free agency. I ended up moving Rhys Hoskins to First Base because I had Aaron Altherr in Left field and moved Scott Kingery to Third base to fill in for Franco. I also moved Carlos Santana back to Catcher so fill out my infield and I think that move paved the way for the moves I ended up making this off season.

So the big fish of course is Bryce Harper and I ended up signing him to a 7 year deal for like 200 mill or something. Additionally I picked up Manny Machado who surprisingly wasn't resigned by Baltimore like he has been in previous test sims I've done. So after much debate I ended up shipping out Altherr and Odubel Herrera to now have an outfield of Harper, Kiermaier and Hoskins who I moved back to Left Field. I made an additional trade for Matt Olsen to sure up first base and after moving Kingery back to second base, Cesar Hernandez to short stop and Machado back to third base I'm set!! Also shipped out JP Crawford who was just too good to sit on my bench. I felt bad moving Hernandez to Short but it had to be done to get Kingery back to his natural position. My bullpen and starting rotation seems to be my only weakness but they were pretty solid for me last season so that will be something I address this coming offseason. Oh we ended up losing to the Indians in the world series in 6 games so I feel really good about the moves we've made this offseason as were all in this season trying to win the whole thing.

I ended up playing one game of my new season and the bats were alive! Harper hit a 3 run homer and Hoskins hit one right after that! Macado went 3 for 4 and I can already tell I'm going to have a lot of fun with this team. So my lineup looks like this...

1. Hernandez (SS)
2. Machado (3B)
3. Harper (RF)
4. Hoskins (LF)
5. Olsen (1B)
6. Kingery (2B)
7. Kiermaier (CF)
8. Santana (C)

Pitchers

1. Nola
2. Manaea
3. Lively
4. Eickhoff
5. Hutchison
6. Preston Miller (Free Agent pickup beginning of last season)
7. Kendall Graveman

Relief

1. Emilio Pagan
2. Trevor Hildenberger
3. Taylor Rodgers
4. Edubray Ramis
5. Hector Neris

Sent from my SM-G955U using Operation Sports mobile app

[alston4659]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I tried HOF hitting for a bit but was too frustrated as well. I play with PCI off and directional, timing hitting interface too though. I think if you're good at placing the PCI you cam hit on any level imo...

I went back down to Allstar and sticking with it. Have games where I get 10+ hits, then a game or two in a row where I can't get any more than 5 or 6 hits.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

Yeah All Star is the level for me. Tried Hall of Fame and while I had some success, it just wasn't as fun for me. I still have both bad games and good on all star and still lose my fair share.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Operation Sports mobile app

[Bushido]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I tried HOF hitting for a bit but was too frustrated as well. I play with PCI off and directional, timing hitting interface too though. I think if you're good at placing the PCI you cam hit on any level imo...

I went back down to Allstar and sticking with it. Have games where I get 10+ hits, then a game or two in a row where I can't get any more than 5 or 6 hits.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

I would probably throw my controller across the room if I tried one game on HOF. I know what my issue is, besides this being the first time I played a baseball game. It's that I rarely move the PCI when I swing. I have a hard enough time tracking the ball with my eyes, that I just leave the PCI dead center. I still get good contact, especially with my star players. Last time however, I did finally track a low fastball, moved the PCI down and hit the game winning homerun in the 11th inning. But that was pure luck, as I noticed the trend of the pitcher continuing to throw all his stuff below the knees to Pavin Smith.

[DarthRambo]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I would probably throw my controller across the room if I tried one game on HOF. I know what my issue is, besides this being the first time I played a baseball game. It's that I rarely move the PCI when I swing. I have a hard enough time tracking the ball with my eyes, that I just leave the PCI dead center. I still get good contact, especially with my star players. Last time however, I did finally track a low fastball, moved the PCI down and hit the game winning homerun in the 11th inning. But that was pure luck, as I noticed the trend of the pitcher continuing to throw all his stuff below the knees to Pavin Smith.

Highly recommend directional hitting so there is no need to worry about the pci then. That way the only thing you have to worry about is tracking the ball and timing your swing.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

[Bushido]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

Highly recommend directional hitting so there is no need to worry about the pci then. That way the only thing you have to worry about is tracking the ball and timing your swing.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

I just watched a youtube video on directional hitting. That looks a lot easier, but what are the cons to it?

[DarthRambo]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

I just watched a youtube video on directional hitting. That looks a lot easier, but what are the cons to it?

The only cons I can think of is you have to rely of the player attributes moreso than your skill level. But for a lot of people, me included, that is seen as a good thing.

Players will go through hot and cold streaks throughout a season like real life. Meaning, you can have a ball pitched dead center and you time it perfectly but the contact is weak since that player currently is not hitting well. On the other hand, a bal low and outside to a lefty for example can be timed perfectly and somehow manage to make good contact at the same time on a really tough pitch to hit if the player is hot.

Hopefully that makes sense!

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

[MileHighMadness1]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

Side note,

I have no idea how some of you get any hits on HOF, or higher. I'm watching everyone in my lineup's batting average drop significantly by the day after switching to All-Star (hitting) in this 4-game series against the Giants.

On legend, you almost have to use zone/analog and PCI, and you have to be good with it.. I haven’t seen many people have success using directional hitting on higher levels (there are exceptions). I’ve been playing on Legend difficulty for 4 or 5 years now, but it took me a good 2/3 years to get to the point where I consider myself a “good” hitter on legend

[Bushido]

Re: MLB The Show 18 Franchise Discussion Thread

The only cons I can think of is you have to rely of the player attributes moreso than your skill level. But for a lot of people, me included, that is seen as a good thing.

Players will go through hot and cold streaks throughout a season like real life. Meaning, you can have a ball pitched dead center and you time it perfectly but the contact is weak since that player currently is not hitting well. On the other hand, a bal low and outside to a lefty for example can be timed perfectly and somehow manage to make good contact at the same time on a really tough pitch to hit if the player is hot.

Hopefully that makes sense!

Sent from my SM-G920P using Operation Sports mobile app

Makes perfect sense, so if Player A is a .265 caliber hitter, there's basically no chance that he's going to improve and become a .280-285 hitter on directional?

Versus

Your stick skills can make him a .280 (or better) hitter if you use PCI