MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

[DallasRocks]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

Over the years never understood relievers who have an era of less than 3 for years in a row be rated like a 66. Then some random stater with career era over 5 is like a 78.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

Jared Karros needs three of his four /9 attribute ratings tuned down to mid 50's. Otherwise he would be far and away easily be the best minor league player in the game , especially if you change his position to starting pitcher. Or if he truly is a reliever, then cut his stamina rating in half.

[tessl]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

Starting with Red Sox pitcher Brayan Bello. I understand he's had a couple injuies the last couple years but his Durability at 13? Even thru injury, he's managed to pitch nearly 320 innings. I would think at worst he's earned at least a 65. At least.

What would you guys have his Durability set to?

I'm curious what roster you used.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

I'm curious what roster you used.

I used the second default , the one with Pete Alonso on the Mets. The original default had Pete a Free Agent. Then I started making my tweaks and massages from there.

[Madden08PCgmr]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

Over the years never understood relievers who have an era of less than 3 for years in a row be rated like a 66. Then some random stater with career era over 5 is like a 78.

Stamina has to be factored in, too much so.

I've never played franchise deep enough to know how this affects roster building. I would guess lower rated players aren't valued?

But conversely, not totally out of line with MLB. As a Mariners fan, they've burned through quite a few quality relievers, even after career years.. (Sewald, Swanson, Streckenrider)

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The SHOW Players Attributes Discussion.

Jared Karros needs three of his four /9 attribute ratings tuned down to mid 50's. Otherwise he would be far and away easily be the best minor league player in the game , especially if you change his position to starting pitcher. Or if he truly is a reliever, then cut his stamina rating in half.

They fixed Karros /9 ratings in the roster update. Between him and Boston Bello, good job Sony.