Recommended Videos

**ferriscj24** · 08-17-2010, 02:05 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode:

Franchise.

Incorrect Commentary:

I am playing as the Detroit Tigers against the Cleveland Indians, once again at Progressive Field in Cleveland. An Indians batter hits a routine ground ball to my shortstop. When I field the ball, Vasgersian...once AGAIN...gets excited and yells "And it stays in the park as it is off the Center Field Wall!"

Why was it incorrect?

It was a routine ground ball to the shortstop. This is at least the THIRD or FOURTH commentary problem I have posted, in Progressive Field alone.

**KingHalladay34** · 08-22-2010, 08:38 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Originally posted by 5th_fathom

I will re-report this. I've heard it as well.

i have as well, Carlos Pena hit it to RF and Fukudome threw it to second as he was rounding. it doesn't bother me, as sometimes i keep the ball, let them run then throw them out :P

**MatrixTN** · 08-26-2010, 11:58 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
RTTS (probably any reg. gameplay mode)

Wrong
Opp. pitcher has a mound visit and Vas says "he's probably gonna tell him 'QUIT WALKING GUYS!'"

Why
While he walked a couple of batters earlier in the inning, the previous batter prior to the visit hit a loaded 2-run double.

**spitoon** · 08-28-2010, 12:43 AM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
Franchise

Wrong
Playing in Minnesota, Morneau was at the plate and took a fastball down the middle. Dave mentioned that "Usually they would be looking for that one somewhere beyond the baggie"...

Why
Target Field doesn't have 'the baggie'...

I can fully understand how this one is in there...just a remnant from years passed.

**ferriscj24** · 08-29-2010, 04:53 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Originally posted by spitoon

Mode
Franchise

Wrong
Playing in Minnesota, Morneau was at the plate and took a fastball down the middle. Dave mentioned that "Usually they would be looking for that one somewhere beyond the baggie"...

Why
Target Field doesn't have 'the baggie'...

I can fully understand how this one is in there...just a remnant from years passed.

There are still quite a few "recycled" commentary lines from year's past. For instance Jermaine Dye is a free agent, and in my franchise was signed by Seattle. Whenever he swings and misses, Vasgersian still says "...and Dye was swinging for the downs on that one..." Though he is no longer on the White Sox, and was a FA when the game was released.

**MatrixTN** · 08-30-2010, 03:33 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
Ex, any regular gameplay

Wrong
"Both starters have recently departed" or something to that effect. The Starting Pitchers comparison was shown during the top 8th (both pitched the full 7 innings).

Why
I brought in a reliever at the start of the 8th, the opp. pitcher had not been removed yet.

**harvey88** · 09-04-2010, 09:10 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode - Franchise, Post Season (ALCS)

What - During the second inning a pop up shows up showing the playoff tree. The announcers say "Lets look at the playoff bracket. With this series well under way it will be interesting to see who will face the AL Champs the Toronto Blue Jays in the Fall Classic". I'm playing as the Jays and both the ALCS and NLCS are not over yet.

**ThatDudeandThatGuy** · 09-05-2010, 05:27 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Not sure if this is considered incorrect commentary...

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? Franchise/Season
Incorrect Commentary? Sometimes, when a speedster gets on base, it shows his base stealing stats but they're all 0's!
Why was it incorrect? This happened, so I stole a base only to find out he had 41 stolen bases on the season!

**MatrixTN** · 09-05-2010, 10:51 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Originally posted by ThatDudeandThatGuy

Not sure if this is considered incorrect commentary...

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? Franchise/Season
Incorrect Commentary? Sometimes, when a speedster gets on base, it shows his base stealing stats but they're all 0's!
Why was it incorrect? This happened, so I stole a base only to find out he had 41 stolen bases on the season!

That belongs in Bugs/Glitches, and it's already been posted (including by me).

**zippy2212** · 09-20-2010, 10:58 AM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
Franchise

Wrong
Carlos Marmol saved game number 55 in my franchise and Matt V. says something to the effect of "with only 2 more saves Marmol will tie the single season all time saves record of 57 set way back in 1990"

Also when I saved number 58 he talked about breaking the record.

Why
The single season saves record is 63 set in 2008.

**JustSteve** · 09-20-2010, 05:56 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Originally posted by zippy2212

The single season saves record is 63 set in 2008.

Actually 62 by Francisco Rodriguez.

**zippy2212** · 09-20-2010, 07:57 PM

I knew it was something like that just to lazy to look it up.

**MatrixTN** · 09-20-2010, 11:16 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Originally posted by Superbone

Actually 62 by Francisco Rodriguez.

Yeah, that was in '09 as well. They probably forgot to update that one.

**Joey** · 09-29-2010, 04:14 PM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game mode
Season

Incorrect Commentary
Playing in Shea Stadium, I hit a homerun (with a RH batter, if that makes a difference) within 20' of the RF foul pole and Matt said something to the affect of "And a homerun to straightaway left field".

Why was it incorrect?
Hit the homerun to right field, not left.

**MatrixTN** · 10-01-2010, 06:16 AM

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
RTTS as SP (probably any regular gameplay)

Wrong
As I'm being pulled after allowing a home run to tie the game, Vas says "He'll leave with the game tied but he is responsible for the runner at 3rd."

Why
There was no one on base when I was removed, the last batter homered. There was a runner on 1st when the home run was hit but that wouldn't have a bearing.