2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Youk, Byrd, and maybe Melancon for Billingsley and Sands?

Sands is not enough...do u have any decent relief pitching u'd be willing to give?

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Umm I would proably give up Bichette and Phelps and maybe Warren

Do you know Bichette's and Warren's potential offhand? I have SCEA rosters, so ideally an age/position/potential answer would be the most useful.

And you think at least one MLB ready player (Phelps) needs to be included for Jurrjens?

[Bard]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sands is not enough...do u have any decent relief pitching u'd be willing to give?

Yeah, i have Albers.

[IAmNumberOne718]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you guys think of this trade:

NYY (me) get:

Prince Fielder
Doug Fister

DET gets:

Mark Teixeira
Michael Pineda

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you guys think of this trade:

NYY (me) get:

Prince Fielder
Doug Fister

DET gets:

Mark Teixeira
Michael Pineda

Are you looking for fairness or realism here?

If realism, no way on Fielder. Depending on how many years Texiera and Fielder have left, I would say it's completely unfair too.

If you want Fielder, you'd have to ship Pineda and at least another A potential player before I'd even consider this possible. And then you'd probably have to throw in another B potential or a guy like Robertson. There's no upside for DET in swapping Fielder for Tex. Remove Tex from the deal.

How many years does Fielder have left in your Franchise?

[AC]

wait...so if im getting this right, ur willing to trade Butler for Jones?

No, he meant he likes Adam Jones. I think he realizes that that would be unfair.

Sent from my Nexus S using Tapatalk 2

[IAmNumberOne718]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Are you looking for fairness or realism here?

If realism, no way on Fielder. Depending on how many years Texiera and Fielder have left, I would say it's completely unfair too.

If you want Fielder, you'd have to ship Pineda and at least another A potential player before I'd even consider this possible. And then you'd probably have to throw in another B potential or a guy like Robertson. There's no upside for DET in swapping Fielder for Tex. Remove Tex from the deal.

How many years does Fielder have left in your Franchise?

I was kind of going towards both realism and fairness. Im in year 2 of my franchise and in need of a boost offensively since i lost arod and jeter to retirement, swisher and martin to FA. I did sign David Wright to replace arod but have struggled so far.

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I was kind of going towards both realism and fairness. Im in year 2 of my franchise and in need of a boost offensively since i lost arod and jeter to retirement, swisher and martin to FA. I did sign David Wright to replace arod but have struggled so far.

How many years do Fielder and Tex have left on their contracts? And where are the Tigers in the standings?

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Umm I would proably give up Bichette and Phelps and maybe Warren

Ok. Just cross referenced OSFM.

Warren is a C RP.
Bichette is a B 3B.
Phelps is a C SP/RP.

Is that really enough to get Jair Jurrjens (final year) from a last place Braves? I'm thinking they'd at least want a second B (or A) OR make me take some money off their books???

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Ok. Just cross referenced OSFM.

Warren is a C RP.
Bichette is a B 3B.
Phelps is a C SP/RP.

Is that really enough to get Jair Jurrjens (final year) from a last place Braves? I'm thinking they'd at least want a second B (or A) OR make me take some money off their books???

there's no paying off portions of a guy's contract so u'd be accepting whatever Jurjjens is making....but to answer your question i'd probably change one of the C's to a B, depending on how he's performed so far

[Heroesandvillains]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

there's no paying off portions of a guy's contract so u'd be accepting whatever Jurjjens is making....but to answer your question i'd probably change one of the C's to a B, depending on how he's performed so far

Sorry, that's not what I meant. And I know that the way the game works, I'd have to pay all of whomever I traded for's contract.

I meant that whenever I mock up a deal, the bar fills up like it's $1 draft night when I enter any one of the Braves' struggling multi-multi millionaires (along with Jurrjens) to the equation. I can give "less," according the game, if I "take" more. Make sense?

They want prospects AND to shed payroll, and I'm the Yankees whom can oblige.

Now, you said depending on how he is performing. Did you mean Jurrjens, or my B potential player? Could you elaborate. Jurrjens is pitching wonderfully, by the way. One of the few.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sorry, that's not what I meant. And I know that the way the game works, I'd have to pay all of whomever I traded for's contract.

I meant that whenever I mock up a deal, the bar fills up like it's $1 draft night when I enter any one of the Braves' struggling multi-multi millionaires (along with Jurrjens) to the equation. I can give "less," according the game, if I "take" more. Make sense?

They want prospects AND to shed payroll, and I'm the Yankees whom can oblige.

Now, you said depending on how he is performing. Did you mean Jurrjens, or my B potential player? Could you elaborate. Jurrjens is pitching wonderfully, by the way. One of the few.

i was referrin to Jurjjens...and going back to what u said, i'd give up more if he was performing well as he is so 2 B's and a C is not unrealistic

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Do you know Bichette's and Warren's potential offhand? I have SCEA rosters, so ideally an age/position/potential answer would be the most useful.

And you think at least one MLB ready player (Phelps) needs to be included for Jurrjens?

I believe they all have B's

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

IRL Jurjenns is very overratted in my mind atleast, I believe that Atlanta missed a shot to get rid of him for something decent in the offseason, and now it looks like hes really hurt. His velcotiy is down and his stuff isn't the same, I think that Atl would easliy take that deal giving them some depth in rotation plus a long reliever and a guy who, if he gets his swing fixed, can be there future 3rd baseman after Chipper retires this year.

[WazzuRC]

In Year 2 of my M's franchise, I just dealt Franklin Gutierrez and 2 B prospects for Francisco Lindor, Dexter Fowler, and a C potential SP.