MLB 13 The Show Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

[moose616]

I guess it makes sense compare someone who has 60 wins at age 38 to someone who has 100 at 26...if were gonna base it off one year might as well make tim lincecum one of the worst in the game

By that logic, Mike Trout shouldn't have a rating at all...

[Factzzz]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

I guess it makes sense compare someone who has 60 wins at age 38 to someone who has 100 at 26...if were gonna base it off one year might as well make tim lincecum one of the worst in the game

Last 3 years kid

[moose616]

whys that? im not saying dickey shouldnt have a rating. Im saying he shouldn't be an 98 or 99 overall because of one great season. trouts also not 40 years old

Not based off one season, but Fact used the last three. Everyone knows professional sports is all about "what have you done lately'."

[Knight165]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Ratings suck...that is all.

M.K.
Knight165

[authentic]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Looks pretty solid. I like the new look menu's and overlays, making it look more like an actual broadcast. Pitching motions look fluid as usually. One thing I am concerned about is that fielding animations still look the same and the ball still looks like it floats up in the air far too long. Not every single hit in baseball is a screaming throw the infield or in the gap. I would like to see more weakly hit battled balls for singles. I have only seen a couple videos so hopefully it's a little better.

[seanjeezy]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Last 3 years kid

OK, here are Dickey's stats over the last 3 years:

6.83 K/9
2.19 BB/9
0.80 HR/9
2.95 ERA

Johnny Cueto put up almost identical numbers in that time frame, do you think he's as good as Verlander/Felix/Kershaw?

[Majingir]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

This is why I hate numerical ratings. If there is a option to toggle it off as Ramone alluded to, then that will be the ABSOLUTE first thing I do when I get the game.

Ratings were always in the game, when you edit players, you see their ratings right there. Only difference was outside of edit player menu, you couldn't see ratings. I'm guessing there'll be option to have ratings shown outside of edit player, and option to now.

[Factzzz]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

OK, here are Dickey's stats over the last 3 years:

6.83 K/9
2.19 BB/9
0.80 HR/9
2.95 ERA

Johnny Cueto put up almost identical numbers in that time frame, do you think he's as good as Verlander/Felix/Kershaw?

That's irrelevant, I'm talking about Felix and Dickey right now, and to say their numbers are not comparable last 3 years is extremely ignorant. Furthermore, to say that if Dickey is rated 99, then Felix should be rated 140 is asinine.

[Carbon]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

OK, here are Dickey's stats over the last 3 years:

6.83 K/9
2.19 BB/9
0.80 HR/9
2.95 ERA

Johnny Cueto put up almost identical numbers in that time frame, do you think he's as good as Verlander/Felix/Kershaw?

Doesn't Cueto lead the majors in ERA+ over the past 2 seasons? There's a case, one I wouldn't necessarily agree with, that Cueto isn't far behind those guys.

[yanksdaniel99]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

OK, here are Dickey's stats over the last 3 years:

6.83 K/9
2.19 BB/9
0.80 HR/9
2.95 ERA

Johnny Cueto put up almost identical numbers in that time frame, do you think he's as good as Verlander/Felix/Kershaw?

But he won almost 20 games last year !!!!!!!

[moose616]

I would love to see authentic minor league stadiums. Not all at once, of course, but progressively. They're adding more anyways, it'd be nice if they added 3-5 AAA stadiums each year for those of us whose hometown team isn't quite in the majors :-)

[Knight165]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Ratings were always in the game, when you edit players, you see their ratings right there. Only difference was outside of edit player menu, you couldn't see ratings. I'm guessing there'll be option to have ratings shown outside of edit player, and option to now.

But that's only because they gave us the ability to edit attributes.
There was a time when even the editor didn't have numbers.

I wonder if God uses numbers when he creates ballplayers?
(and I wish someone would show me where I can edit my Met players IRL ....I still can't see it anywhere)

M.K.
Knight165

[yanksdaniel99]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

That's irrelevant, I'm talking about Felix and Dickey right now, and to say their numbers are not comparable last 3 years is extremely ignorant. Furthermore, to say that if Dickey is rated 99, then Felix should be rated 140 is asinine.

Can I get their WAR value the past 3 years ?

[Majingir]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

I would love to see authentic minor league stadiums. Not all at once, of course, but progressively. They're adding more anyways, it'd be nice if they added 3-5 AAA stadiums each year for those of us whose hometown team isn't quite in the majors :-)

I'd rather they make all MLB stadiums as accurate as possible(only inaccuracies should be ads(for obvious reasons) and any changes made recently before the game came out) before really bothering about minor league stadiums

[seanjeezy]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Video - New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

Can I get their WAR value the past 3 years ?

Lol I was trying to avoid this one since it is the most obvious case of Felix's superiority...

Dickey - 9.9 WAR
Felix - 17.3 WAR

Felix should be rated between 171 and 173

Want to just use last year's #'s?

Dickey - 4.6
Felix - 6.1