MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MLB Bob
    MVP
    • Jan 2011
    • 1008

    #196
    Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

    as far as the giants being under rated, the Giants have an MVP at a position that most teams either have a offensive liability or defensive liability. If you have a few good pitchers and every position is reasonably filled, having that MVP as a catcher makes the team a lot better. But individually, not a lot there thats outstanding.

    Comment

    • slickkill77
      Pro
      • Sep 2006
      • 583

      #197
      Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

      The one thing The Show gets wrong every year. The overall rankings, team defense etc...

      And to the person that used errors to prove how good the Mariners defense is....just no. Errors are not a good way to judge a defense at all unless you live in the 1960's. They may have a good defense, but errors are not the way you argue that point.

      Just like the player rankings, way too much weight is given to certain ratings which end up boosting teams way to high like the Rockies
      Last edited by slickkill77; 02-23-2013, 12:41 AM.

      Comment

      • AUTiger1
        MVP
        • Oct 2008
        • 2413

        #198
        How are the Red Sox #3? WTF man? I have no reason to believe the Red Sox won't make a serious run at 90 losses again this year. They have no pitching!
        Atlanta Braves
        Atlanta Falcons
        Auburn Tigers
        Detroit Red Wings
        Winnipeg Jets

        Comment

        • ElectricAggie
          Rookie
          • Jul 2012
          • 168

          #199
          The Astros aren't last in every category! Hurray!
          Fightin' Texas Aggies
          Houston Astros
          Houston Texans
          Houston Rockets

          Comment

          • Lovesports
            Rookie
            • Jul 2011
            • 469

            #200
            Originally posted by Rasco11
            Yankees #1 in team defense is laughable to me!!! C'mon...
            Actually its not

            Comment

            • Lovesports
              Rookie
              • Jul 2011
              • 469

              #201
              Originally posted by Bat
              There is actually a good number of M's fans on this board. Personally, I hope both the Yankees and Sox sink into the ocean :P
              Lets sink the greatest rivalry in sports...what a great idea! I get that every team has fans, that doesnt mean we change the thread to "who starts in the RF for the m's". Lets stay on the subject, thats all.

              Comment

              • AUTiger1
                MVP
                • Oct 2008
                • 2413

                #202
                Originally posted by SportsGamingBlake
                I wonder when people will start to realize that the team who made the biggest splash in the offseason doesn't have to be one of the top rated teams and is not guaranteed to win (Marlins, Angels 2012). I mean, Braves, Jays, and Red Sox are too high. Defending champs at 17? Seriously? So those ratings are basically saying that they got lucky last year?
                How are saying the Braves are too high at 8?
                Atlanta Braves
                Atlanta Falcons
                Auburn Tigers
                Detroit Red Wings
                Winnipeg Jets

                Comment

                • Jdezzy209
                  Rookie
                  • May 2012
                  • 1

                  #203
                  Originally posted by DodgerFanatic2K3
                  I know it's going to look like I'm just hating being a Dodger fan but besides the pitching there not that good overall

                  They won it all last year because every call and bounce went their way early on in the playoffs
                  Your joking right... 6 elimination games won because the ball bounced their way? 2 championships in 3 years cause we got every call? Do you even know good baseball when you see it? Oh yeah ... Your a dodger fan...

                  Comment

                  • bkrich83
                    Has Been
                    • Jul 2002
                    • 71574

                    #204
                    Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

                    This thread is great.

                    Every posters favorite team is underrated, and their rival is overrrated?

                    Did I read Dodger fan say Giants won a couple of world championships because they got EVERY call and EVERY break? Wow. Talk about sour grapes
                    Tracking my NCAA Coach Career

                    Comment

                    • HustlinOwl
                      All Star
                      • Mar 2004
                      • 9713

                      #205
                      Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

                      lol only 6 pages last year

                      http://www.operationsports.com/forum...g-defense.html

                      Comment

                      • dodgerblue
                        MVP
                        • Feb 2003
                        • 1239

                        #206
                        Wow these are pretty surprising. So the Giants are the defending champs and are behind Colorado and not even considered the best in their own division? The Phillies at number 10? Dodger defense at 2? SMH.
                        Pitchers and Catchers Report; Life Worth Living Again

                        Comment

                        • nomo17k
                          Permanently Banned
                          • Feb 2011
                          • 5735

                          #207
                          Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

                          Seeing how this thread has become one of the most active threads in recent memory, I cannot help but be disappointed by the prospect of more realistic player rating system diminishing to nothingness....

                          SCEA must be doing something right about rating to get people excited it this much.....


                          The Show CPU vs. CPU game stats: 2018,17,16,15,14,13,12,11

                          Comment

                          • AccidentalGenius
                            Just started!
                            • Dec 2012
                            • 5

                            #208
                            I laughed when I saw that the Rockies had the #23 best pitching in the game...they have the the worst by far. And third in offense? Really? Besides Tulo and Cargo they have nobody else. They had the third worst record in the league last year, and now they have a better team than the defending champs..oh great. The reason the Giants are so low is that: Lincegum will have a horrible rating based on his performance last year, they have undervalued guys in the bullpen such as Kontos and Javi Lopez, the game does not factor in the manager, Pence will have bad ratings, there is no team or clubhouse chemistry , and the game doesn't appreciate the amazing defense of Brandon Belt and Brandon Crawford. These ratings are only based on the the teams on paper NOT how they play out in the field. The Giants do all the little things right and they are ultimately a top 10 team. Also, Dodgers fans stop hating on the Giants. No matter how much money you spend and how many excuses you come up with, you will never be able to beat us.

                            Comment

                            • seanjeezy
                              The Future
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 3347

                              #209
                              Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

                              Originally posted by nomo17k
                              Seeing how this thread has become one of the most active threads in recent memory, I cannot help but be disappointed by the prospect of more realistic player rating system diminishing to nothingness....

                              SCEA must be doing something right about rating to get people excited it this much.....


                              The question is from what are the ratings and subsequent rankings derived from? Traditional stats? Sabermetrics? Both? Neither? I think if people knew exactly how the ratings were determined then there wouldn't be as much bellyaching...
                              Bakin' soda, I got bakin' soda

                              Comment

                              • nomo17k
                                Permanently Banned
                                • Feb 2011
                                • 5735

                                #210
                                Re: MLB 13 The Show - Overall Team Ratings, Including Batting, Pitching and Defense

                                Originally posted by seanjeezy
                                The question is from what are the ratings and subsequent rankings derived from? Traditional stats? Sabermetrics? Both? Neither? I think if people knew exactly how the ratings were determined then there wouldn't be as much bellyaching...
                                The issue with a ranking system like this is that it really doesn't mean much for the purpose of evaluating team talents... I think it's just there to have something like "power ranking" that's kinda popular in the media, to just feed people with something to talk about.... (...see i'm really jaded.....hahaha)

                                I think the team ratings are derived from player ratings. When you play franchise and look at team ratings before and after spring training, you see the rankings can be drastically different. I'm assuming that's because pre-season, the team ratings are derived from all players (don't know if that's just 40 man or all including minors), but after the spring training and 25/40 man rosters are done, then the team ratings probably are derived from the players on those more limited roster.

                                So team ratings aren't really what many think they are...
                                The Show CPU vs. CPU game stats: 2018,17,16,15,14,13,12,11

                                Comment

                                Working...