2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[RevisIsland2010]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Probably the wrong thread. This one is about making trades fair. The cheese trade that exploits bad trade AI is down the hall.

...sounded like a typical Dodgers move to me. I think th game has pretty decent trade logic

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

...sounded like a typical Dodgers move to me. I think th game has pretty decent trade logic

u must be in the minority with ur last sentence

[ubernoob]

lol...just lol

Its a rental trade. That's how they work, normally one top tier prospect and a couple young prospects at a B&C level (or a prospect and role players to help shore things up.)

See: Greinke, Zack. Traded for Profar, Hellweg and Pena.

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

my issue isnt with Seager.....just please take out Capuano and substitute with a promising prospect

You realize you're treating the Yankees like they're the friggin Marlins, right?

Honestly I haven't looked up any of the values... But an elite prospect and someone to provide a solid starting pitcher is fair value for a half year rental to me for Cano.

Maybe another mid C to high C prospect added in.

Agreed. It really doesn't take more than an elite prospect who'll probably be a top 50 prospect next year and a solid #4 for a rental.

lol...just lol

Unnecessary condescension FTW lol

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Its a rental trade. That's how they work, normally one top tier prospect and a couple young prospects at a B&C level (or a prospect and role players to help shore things up.)

See: Greinke, Zack. Traded for Profar, Hellweg and Pena.

u mean Segura....and the haul that Milwaukee got back were prospects...no veterans

[ubernoob]

u mean Segura....and the haul that Milwaukee got back were prospects...no veterans

Yeah, Segura. A slip up, my bad.

Regardless, you are looking at middling prospects. Switch out Cappy for a meh prospect then.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

so let me get this straight.......ur the Yanks and ur out of contention(thats what im assuming is the situation).......u would rather have Capuano then a promising prospect?

[RevisIsland2010]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Honestly I haven't looked up any of the values... But an elite prospect and someone to provide a solid starting pitcher is fair value for a half year rental to me for Cano.

Maybe another mid C to high C prospect added in.

Dude do you even watch baseball? Seager is somewhat promising but keep in mind he hit .260 last year. Ya hes gna get a lot better but if I had to rank his potential I'd give it a 7. And cano is arguably the best hitter in the game. And capuano? Lol. As people have said, hes 34 and has maybe 1 or 2 decent years left

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

u mean Segura....and the haul that Milwaukee got back were prospects...no veterans

Because Milwaukee was assuming they'd enter rebuilding after the trade

NYY is not rebuilding

so let me get this straight.......ur the Yanks and ur out of contention(thats what im assuming is the situation).......u would rather have Capuano then a promising prospect?

You're getting both though

I'm arguing that Cano isn't worth more than Capuano + Seager

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Yeah, Segura. A slip up, my bad.

Regardless, you are looking at middling prospects. Switch out Cappy for a meh prospect then.

i cant settle for meh if im dealing away Cano....even if it's just a rental

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Because Milwaukee was assuming they'd enter rebuilding after the trade

NYY is not rebuilding



You're getting both though

I'm arguing that Cano isn't worth more than Capuano + Seager

im talking about a prospect IN ADDITION to Seager......

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Dude do you even watch baseball? Seager is somewhat promising but keep in mind he hit .260 last year. Ya hes gna get a lot better but if I had to rank his potential I'd give it a 7. And cano is arguably the best hitter in the game. And capuano? Lol. As people have said, hes 34 and has maybe 1 or 2 decent years left

Corey Seager hit .309 in his debut last year, are we watching the same sport?

And no, Cano is not the best hitter in the game. There are multiple better hitters.

[ubernoob]

Dude do you even watch baseball? Seager is somewhat promising but keep in mind he hit .260 last year. Ya hes gna get a lot better but if I had to rank his potential I'd give it a 7. And cano is arguably the best hitter in the game. And capuano? Lol. As people have said, hes 34 and has maybe 1 or 2 decent years left

Since you want to play the condescending game. If you knew anything about baseball, you'd realize that a prospect with a potential of 7 is extremely highly regarded.

Cano isn't arguably the best hitter in the game. At 2nd base? Yeah. In the game? I can give you a handful of players that are better.

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

im talking about a prospect IN ADDITION to Seager......

And I'm saying that Cano ISN'T WORTH THAT..

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i cant settle for meh if im dealing away Cano....even if it's just a rental

Corey Seager

Is

Not

MEH

come on man