All-Timers Teams

[jorge380]

Re: All-Timers Teams

[QUOTE=MysterioMan007;2041311443]While I agree that Yaz is probably underrated on the roster, I don't think he'll rank as high as Ted Williams, arguably one of the best hitters of all-time.

This stems from the way I was doing ratings early in the roster as compared to later. I probably used Yaz's career stats at that time when I did the Sox. His later less productive years probably drove his rating down a bit. Later rosters (like the Rangers, for example) were mostly done with weighted ratings. I will correct this when I do a final edit in the earlier rosters.

Anyway, the Braves are done (except for a few attributes on the relief pitchers. The Tools are not giving me pitcher attributes right now)

SP Warren Spahn
SP Greg Maddux
SP Phil Niekro
SP Tom Glavine
SP John Smoltz
RP Kid Nichols
RP Lew Burdette
RP Johnny Sain
RP Rick Camp
CP Gene Garber

C Javy Lopez
C Joe Torre
1B Fred McGriff
1B Joe Adcock
2B Marcus Giles
SS Rafael Furcal
SS Rabbit Maranville
3B Eddie Mathews
3B Chipper Jones
OF Hugh Duffy
OF Dale Murphy
OF Andruw Jones
OF Wally Berger
OF Hank Aaron
OF Dave Justice

The Florida Marlins are next and probably won't take too long considering a lot of guys are still in the game...[/QUOTE

How about 2B Glen Hubbard and 3B Bob Horner

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

How about 1B Frank Howard from the old Washington Senators.

The Washington Senators (that version) are now the Texas Rangers (another version are now the Minnesota Twins). The Washington Nationals used to be the Montreal Expos. Frank Howard never played for the Expos. He is on the Rangers roster, however.

As for Bob Horner and Glenn Hubbard, there wasn't room for Horner. I wanted him in, but there was nowhere for him. Eddie Matthews and Chipper Jones were better than him. He'll probably be on the 40-man roster, though. I don't see Hubbard making it. He was a memorable player and I have fond memories of him, but he wasn't really that great at anything in particular, IMO. If I do continue editing after the 40-man rosters are done, I'll make him one of the free agents, as well as a bunch of other guys that were around, but didn't make any teams.

[HGH_whocares]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Yeah sounds good you can put Stan the Man in the Outfield. Play Mize & Pujols at 1st.

What about Rusty Staub for the Expos they retired his number?

Good idea on Mize. The Cards have Albert as their only 1B, so that could open up a spot for Clark on the Giants.

So I'm stuck on the Nationals, half out of laziness, half out of disinterest. One of my least favorite teams to do so far...finding a 1B who wasn't Andres Galarraga (Rockies) was like pulling teeth, so I just went with Adam Dunn, their current 1B. I know he was with the Reds a long time, but they're pretty stacked without him...and the pickings are slim for this franchise.

Not quite done just yet, but I managed to put together the final roster:

SP Steve Rogers
SP Bryn Smith
SP Dennis Martinez
SP Javier Vazquez
SP Bill Gullickson
RP Stephen Strasburg
RP Ugueth Urbina
RP Mel Rojas
RP Tim Burke
RP Ken Hill
CP Jeff Reardon

C Gary Carter
C Darrin Fletcher
1B Adam Dunn
1B Nick Johnson
2B Jose Vidro
2B Delino DeShields
SS Orlando Cabrera
3B Ryan Zimmerman
3B Tim Wallach
OF Andre Dawson
OF Tim Raines
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Marquis Grissom
OF Ellis Valentine

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Not a bad idea at all. I totally overlooked Staub being on the Expos since he spent so many years with other teams, but that's looking to be what I'll go with...thanks, man.

Update: With Roster Tools still not working for pitching stats, I'm a little stalled on the pitchers right now. I'm doing appearances and waiting for the fix to occur. I mostly used Knight's Strasburg stats to get him done. In the meantime, I'll start on the Mets position players hopefully today sometime. Got a couple of long work days coming up, so I want to get a whole lot done today.

[animal829]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Good idea on Mize. The Cards have Albert as their only 1B, so that could open up a spot for Clark on the Giants.

So I'm stuck on the Nationals, half out of laziness, half out of disinterest. One of my least favorite teams to do so far...finding a 1B who wasn't Andres Galarraga (Rockies) was like pulling teeth, so I just went with Adam Dunn, their current 1B. I know he was with the Reds a long time, but they're pretty stacked without him...and the pickings are slim for this franchise.

Not quite done just yet, but I managed to put together the final roster:

SP Steve Rogers
SP Bryn Smith
SP Dennis Martinez
SP Javier Vazquez
SP Bill Gullickson
RP Stephen Strasburg
RP Ugueth Urbina
RP Mel Rojas
RP Tim Burke
RP Ken Hill
CP Jeff Reardon

C Gary Carter
C Darrin Fletcher
1B Rusty Staub
1B Adam Dunn
2B Jose Vidro
2B Delino DeShields
SS Orlando Cabrera
3B Ryan Zimmerman
3B Tim Wallach
OF Andre Dawson
OF Tim Raines
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Marquis Grissom
OF Ellis Valentine

How about Al Oliver,Tony Perez,Larry Walker or Cliff Floyd at 1B all better choices than Adam Dunn.

[pjsnell10]

Re: All-Timers Teams

I think Andres Galarraga would be the easy choice for Montreal at 1st base. Cool roster set, looking forward to the final version.

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

How about Al Oliver,Tony Perez,Larry Walker or Cliff Floyd at 1B all better choices than Adam Dunn.

Al Oliver=Pirates
Tony Perez=Reds
Larry Walker=Rockies
Cliff Floyd=Marlins
Andres Galarraga=Rockies

I went with Rusty Staub. He wasn't already on another roster...and is probably my best option at this time. Dunn's still on the roster, just as a backup now...

[Joey]

Re: All-Timers Teams

I agree with where you put all these guys. Seeing as how the Rockies have really only had 2 first basemen (albeit they were 2 good ones), you about have to put Galarraga on that team. You can always assign Tim Wallach 1B as his secondary position too, as he did play quite a few games there.

Al Oliver=Pirates
Tony Perez=Reds
Larry Walker=Rockies
Cliff Floyd=Marlins
Andres Galarraga=Rockies

I went with Rusty Staub. He wasn't already on another roster...and is probably my best option at this time. Dunn's still on the roster, just as a backup now...

[pjsnell10]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Did Helton make it onto the Rockies, or is this for only retired players?

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Wallach does have a secondary 1B position...and yes, Todd Helton is on the Rockies. I don't think it would be the Rockies without him

[Joey]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Dunn is on the Nats/Expos so I'm guessing it's not only for retired players - unless that was just an exception.

Edit: Ha, Mysterio, you must type quicker than me!

Did Helton make it onto the Rockies, or is this for only retired players?

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Yeah, there's tons of active players on some teams, especially teams like the Marlins, D-Backs, Rockies, etc. who've been around a short amount of time, so it's not just retired guys.

[HGH_whocares]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Not a bad idea at all. I totally overlooked Staub being on the Expos since he spent so many years with other teams, but that's looking to be what I'll go with...thanks, man.

Update: With Roster Tools still not working for pitching stats, I'm a little stalled on the pitchers right now. I'm doing appearances and waiting for the fix to occur. I mostly used Knight's Strasburg stats to get him done. In the meantime, I'll start on the Mets position players hopefully today sometime. Got a couple of long work days coming up, so I want to get a whole lot done today.

Whos on the Mets roster? Is Kevin Mitchell gonna make it (best years with giants)? Came up as a SS hahaha believe it or not. That lineup will be dirty with Keith Hernandez, Kevin Mitchell and my 2nd fav player of all time Darryl Strawberry!

[MysterioMan007]

Re: All-Timers Teams

I've finished the Nationals except for the pitchers' ratings. The Mets will probably be as follows unless something changes:

SP Tom Seaver
SP Dwight Gooden
SP David Cone
SP Jerry Koosman
SP Sid Fernandez
RP Bobby Ojeda
RP Jesse Orosco
RP Roger McDowell
RP Armando Benitez
RP Ron Darling
CP John Franco

C Mike Piazza
C Todd Hundley
1B Keith Hernandez
2B Edgardo Alfonzo
2B Gregg Jefferies
2B Wally Backman
SS Jose Reyes
3B David Wright
3B Howard Johnson
OF Daryl Strawberry
OF Cleon Jones
OF Kevin McReynolds
OF Tommie Agee
OF Lenny Dykstra

I have Kevin Mitchell on the Giants...sorry to disappoint on that...

[capa]

Re: All-Timers Teams

Would love if you swapped out Hundley for Grote.

C