OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Can you please post a link here as i can't access the vault. My password won't work.

When the file is complete I will for sure.

[hoser]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

OK, OS Classic 4/4 in the vault.

Added everyones players

I added:

Darryl Strawberry, Gorman Thomas, Devon White,Roberto Alomar and a few others from the vault.

I downloaded this roster last night and noticed a few things with the Twins roster.

There's two Kirby Pucketts on the Twins. I believe the one I created is in CF and there's someone else's version in LF. Out of the 1707 games Kirby played he played 1432 in CF and only 10 games in LF.

I created an Eddie Yost - 3B however he's not on the Twin's roster. I do see someone named Eddie Youst playing 1B. Out of the 2035 games that Eddie Yost played he played 2008 of them at 3B and only 9 of them were at 1B.

Butch Wynegar was not on the roster. He's on the roster that I uploaded a week or so ago.

There's a number of players that I created that were not included. Harmon Killebrew, Walter Johnson, Gary Gaetti, and others. It looks like someone else's version was used. If there's already good players created for a roster that I am working on then great, let's use them. However, I really don't want to spend the time creating players like this if they're not going to be used. It's a waste of time and there's hundreds of other players that do need to be created that aren't currently available.

Thanks.

[pjsnell10]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

The LF Puckett on there was scooters, I downloaded it to check out the face, both versions on there look good, so I left it on there. The CF was mine that I already had on there.

Yost was Scooters, I just think it was spelled wrong and had the wrong position.

Must have missed Wynegar somehow, thought I got them all.

The Gaetti was yours, I think I just took his beard off.

Scooters doing all of the guys pre 1985, so we don't need to worry about them. Thats why we're having a few doubles on there (Johnson, Killebrew). I already had them on there, so I didn't need a second version.

We should update our chart as soon as we create a guy to dismiss a bit of the confusion.

I downloaded this roster last night and noticed a few things with the Twins roster.

There's two Kirby Pucketts on the Twins. I believe the one I created is in CF and there's someone else's version in LF. Out of the 1707 games Kirby played he played 1432 in CF and only 10 games in LF.

I created an Eddie Yost - 3B however he's not on the Twin's roster. I do see someone named Eddie Youst playing 1B. Out of the 2035 games that Eddie Yost played he played 2008 of them at 3B and only 9 of them were at 1B.

Butch Wynegar was not on the roster. He's on the roster that I uploaded a week or so ago.

There's a number of players that I created that were not included. Harmon Killebrew, Walter Johnson, Gary Gaetti, and others. It looks like someone else's version was used. If there's already good players created for a roster that I am working on then great, let's use them. However, I really don't want to spend the time creating players like this if they're not going to be used. It's a waste of time and there's hundreds of other players that do need to be created that aren't currently available.

Thanks.

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

The LF Puckett on there was scooters, I downloaded it to check out the face, both versions on there look good, so I left it on there. The CF was mine that I already had on there.

Yost was Scooters, I just think it was spelled wrong and had the wrong position.

Must have missed Wynegar somehow, thought I got them all.

The Gaetti was yours, I think I just took his beard off.

Scooters doing all of the guys pre 1985, so we don't need to worry about them. Thats why we're having a few doubles on there (Johnson, Killebrew). I already had them on there, so I didn't need a second version.

We should update our chart as soon as we create a guy to dismiss a bit of the confusion.

Just to add on though, there are a lot of players in the vault already made. I told pj if he finds a better quality face for anything that was made by any of us to use it. Some of PJs creations have been bumped, some of mine have been bumped, and some of scooters will be bumped if there are better ones out there.

We kind of agreed that the best model would go into the roster. I don't know anything about the situation you were talking about and I understand your frustration, but I'll be happy with the roster if it has all the best faces possible and not one of mine was decided to be the best.

Don't be discouraged by the WIP file. At the end we will decide as a whole which to use.

[hoser]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Just to add on though, there are a lot of players in the vault already made. I told pj if he finds a better quality face for anything that was made by any of us to use it. Some of PJs creations have been bumped, some of mine have been bumped, and some of scooters will be bumped if there are better ones out there.

We kind of agreed that the best model would go into the roster. I don't know anything about the situation you were talking about and I understand your frustration, but I'll be happy with the roster if it has all the best faces possible and not one of mine was decided to be the best.

Don't be discouraged by the WIP file. At the end we will decide as a whole which to use.

As I've said multiple times I don't care if someone already has a great version of a player for a roster I'm working on; by all means let's use it. Walt Weiss of the Rockies is a great example. I'm working on the Rockies roster right now and someone already created a good Weiss so I'm not going to bother creating him. I would hope that if someone's created player is going to be used that the player at least have their name spelled right and they play the correct position though.

What I'm absolutely not going to do is to waste my time creating players that aren't going to be used. I'll gladly step aside and let someone else do all the work to create all the players for all the teams for this roster. I've got no problem whatsoever not contributing anything else to this project and letting someone else do all the player creations.

[pjsnell10]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Again, as soon as someone makes a player, we need to add it to the chart so we know whats created already.

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

As I've said multiple times I don't care if someone already has a great version of a player for a roster I'm working on; by all means let's use it. Walt Weiss of the Rockies is a great example. I'm working on the Rockies roster right now and someone already created a good Weiss so I'm not going to bother creating him. I would hope that if someone's created player is going to be used that the player at least have their name spelled right and they play the correct position though.

What I'm absolutely not going to do is to waste my time creating players that aren't going to be used. I'll gladly step aside and let someone else do all the work to create all the players for all the teams for this roster. I've got no problem whatsoever not contributing anything else to this project and letting someone else do all the player creations.

I think all the players you are still signed up for 100% will be used. I mean, I signed up for the Indians, but since creating more and more people have popped out good player faces that I will just edit.

If I make a Jose Mesa, and a week later somebody does a better job on it than I did I am going to use it. Thats the only point I am trying to make.

With the Rockies I don't see any problems, but if somebody comes on the site and shows an awesome Larry Walker, or Andres Galarraga it will be used if it's better.

At this point we are not doubling up players. We said before just to create players post-1985 to prevent doubling up just for the time being. I can promise that nobody on our team is working on the same players that you claimed, but I can't promise that somebody not affiliated with us wont do an awesome job on a face. If that's the case we will use it.

Do you understand what I mean at least?

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Again, as soon as someone makes a player, we need to add it to the chart so we know whats created already.

I PM'd Scooter about getting a list of players he will be creating in the future.

The problem isn't who's been created, it's who is going to be created. Want the roster now in the vault to update some things?

I hadn't been able to work on it since late last night, but I will be able to again tonight if you want it during the day?

[hoser]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

I think all the players you are still signed up for 100% will be used. I mean, I signed up for the Indians, but since creating more and more people have popped out good player faces that I will just edit.

If I make a Jose Mesa, and a week later somebody does a better job on it than I did I am going to use it. Thats the only point I am trying to make.

With the Rockies I don't see any problems, but if somebody comes on the site and shows an awesome Larry Walker, or Andres Galarraga it will be used if it's better.

At this point we are not doubling up players. We said before just to create players post-1985 to prevent doubling up just for the time being. I can promise that nobody on our team is working on the same players that you claimed, but I can't promise that somebody not affiliated with us wont do an awesome job on a face. If that's the case we will use it.

Do you understand what I mean at least?

The bottom line for me is I'm not interested in spending time creating players if they might not be used. It's a waste of time and I'm not interested in wasting time.

Good luck with the rosters.

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

The bottom line for me is I'm not interested in spending time creating players if they might not be used. It's a waste of time and I'm not interested in wasting time.

Good luck with the rosters.

Fair enough. So are you out for good?

[hoser]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Fair enough. So are you out for good?

If I uploaded something to the vault by all means use it if you'd like. If not, that's fine too.

Like I said, I'm not going to create any more players if it's possible they aren't going to be used. It's a waste of time.

[capa]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Bedwards, PJ, Scooter,

Can't tell you how excited and anxious I am for this release this year! To be honest, I spent almost all my playing time with your classic teams in 2011 and hope to do the same in 2012. The 3 of you are off to an amazing start and I know this release will come to fruition alot sooner than last years.

Are you still considering doing a specific year as well? if so, which year is topping the list?

C

[pjsnell10]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Thanks for the kind words! I'll be happy if we can get this thing completely finished, we kind of ran out of steam last year.

If we do finish early, I've thought about doing a mid 60's, or early 70's set, but we'll see. I'm looking forward to that '89 set going, fun stuff.

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

If I uploaded something to the vault by all means use it if you'd like. If not, that's fine too.

Like I said, I'm not going to create any more players if it's possible they aren't going to be used. It's a waste of time.

I understand, thanks a ton for everything you have contributed thus far!

[bedwardsroy19]

Re: OS All-Time Classic Roster (The Show '12)

Im uploading a set now for you PJ.

Didn't get to work on it last night like I wanted to, so I am just going to send it your way.

I started to clean up the minors a little bit by importing over every fake player and player that there is absolutely no chance we will be using their SCEA face (and I mean absolutely no chance like they are not in the roster and could not possibly be considered to be on any team).

When I get it next time I will start the massive attribute overhaul now that we are starting to get most of the greats in the game.

It's starting to shape up nicely

Roster is in the vault
file name: for PJ.
PSN: bedwardsroy19