The very first thing you do is go edit every single player you will be using. This is a must. You have to edit down every players contact all the way down to nothing. Move it ALL the way to the left so every player has a contact rating of 0 both LT CONTACT and RT CONTACT. You must do this. This is the most important part.
Now basic settings (I'm only going to post the ones that I feel have an impact on gameplay)
HOF mode
API OFF (too many fastballs are thrown to me and they are too easy to hit. I think it's done perfect because that's how it is in real life but too many fastballs are too easy to hit in video games)
GUESS PITCH ON (don't use it though. this is just so you can use the swing analysis feature)
now onto the sliders
USER CONTACT: all the way to the left (0)
USER POWER: -8
PLATE AWARENESS: all the way to the left (0)
CPU PITCH AGGRESSIVENESS: all the way to the left (0)
PITCH SPEED: all the way to the left (0)
PITCH COUNT: all the way to the right (maxxed out)
Every other slider is obviously left at default. I wasn't about to type every slider and say default next to it LOL.
This has helped me toning down the hits. Now you will actually pull balls but it's still hard to do. I was zoned in and hit a 3 run homer to Mike Lowell because I really concentrated and got my pitch. The best part about it was I pulled it over the Monster. Something I didn't do ever. I hope these help anybody out there that is finding hitting way too easy.
Comment