Pointless

[Wbcfan]

Re: “Crazy” Amount of Trades

You don't need to be condescending. It's an actual problem with the roster, "bro". The trade engine is compensating for a lack of balance in the default rosters and you can thank tabarnes19 for figuring this out. You might be fine with this problem but there's no need to chide people for pointing out a legitimate problem. And when I say legitimate, I mean that while Moncada, Lewis and Zimmerman might get traded, the game would not do that but for the faulty and unbalanced default rosters (again you can thank tabarnes19 for discovering this).

Seriously if it doesn't affect him, he doesn't care. As if the up and coming whitesox would trade their future cornerstone for nobody. Ya, that's realistic. You can't lie and say you've got full minor league rosters when that's a huge strecth. Full minor league rosters would mean all real players and single A would be playable. When you're going to make statements like this and release a broken roster, which you've had months to test ( a simple sim of franchsie for a year or two would show you every thing you need to know) you are going to be subject to criticism. People who buy the game every year have a right to complain.

[Caulfield]

Re: “Crazy” Amount of Trades

You’ve stated what people are talking about though. Look at April vs April. It’s not just the number of trades, it’s the number and the reason why. It’s not to get better, it’s rebalancing a slanted roster.

exactly, if rosters are balnced properly, silly season reverts to normal, for the Show

Just wanted to give some numbers to everyone who is complaining that there’s way to many trades in franchise.


Here’s the breakdown for trades in the real MLB in 2019:


March + April
15
May
15
June
14
July
70


That’s a total of 44 before July and 114 trades in 2019.


Here’s the breakdown from a simulation I just ran:


April
41
May
1
June
4
July
60


That’s a total of 46 before July and 106 total. Looks pretty spot on to me.


Everyone wants to talk about things being as sim as possible. Then when they do it you complain about it haha.

I wouldn't really try to compare the Show trades to IRL MLB trades. for one thing, those roughly 45 trades in your sim aren't equal to the IRL 45 or so trades because of one significant reason: Show team organisations = 90 players. IRL organisations = closer to 225
huge difference. but it really is the why and not the amount. in past years rosters were balanced, this year teams have like 10 catchers and 12 outfielders. the CPU is making those trades to regain the balance it used to employ. with 225 players to choose from, the wrong combination of 90 in these rosters were selected. but it's all good. no problem, the Wolf (Ridin & Co.) should be coming directly. problem solved

[tc020791]

“Crazy” Amount of Trades

Can a mod delete this thread.

[Ryanreeser]

Re: “Crazy” Amount of Trades

Can a mod delete this thread.

Yes, could a mod please delete this stupid thread that shouldn't have been posted in the first place?

Sent from my SM-G955U using Operation Sports mobile app

[Caulfield]

Re: “Crazy” Amount of Trades

Yes, could a mod please delete this stupid thread that shouldn't have been posted in the first place?

Sent from my SM-G955U using Operation Sports mobile app

worthwhile discussion, cant learn if you cant have the conversation

[BrianM207]

Re: Pointless

Yeah, its defintely that wonky default roster. Im playing with my personal roster and only had 4 trades. And only 1 of them involved a top prospect that I felt the need to reverse.