Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

[Bulls4life]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I'll upload the roster, and you can look at the Braves. GT is SCampbell904 and I'll title it as "TEST"

I feel pretty good about where I have everyone ranked on them. You'll see a few guys with D potentials now. Those are players that I deem as career fringe/minor league tier players. Keeping them in the 67-69 range avoids creating a log jam of 70+ rated players, and opens up starting positions 2-3 years from now when the prospects are starting to enter into their MLB call-up age bracket.

The roster is not anywhere near 100%, but the Braves, D-Backs, Red Sox, and Orioles are 100% complete. Always open to constructive feed back.

I average about 2 teams per day on the weekday. I will try to grind out more than that on the weekend since I don't have to work.


UPDATE 7:33 AM

Cubs and White Sox are complete, but they aren't in the vault in the "TEST" version. As I go through each roster with a fine tooth comb, I will remove players from teams that were traded/released (Villar on the Cubs in the old version - now on the Angels in the new version, Dallas Kuechel released from the White Sox, etc.) Also, switching players positions (Morel from 3B to CF) and creating players that didn't exist before (Mark Leither Jr)

Cease got the biggest bump so far out of all the teams. He's up to a 94 OV with his potential going from a B to an A.

Thanks for what you’re doing. I used to do my own rosters before my health issues and I can verify. It is a grind. Especially when you’re spending your time off from work to do it.

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Awesome, I will go over the Braves and Orioles here in a bit. And I agree completely about the D potentials, every AA and AAA team is comprised of a lot of players who are career minor leaguers.
Also, any way you could get the Reds done in the next few teams? No worries if not, I’m just terrible with patience

Reds are complete. I uploaded it to the vault. Had to take a break yesterday bc my girlfriend wanted to spend the night.

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Thanks for what you’re doing. I used to do my own rosters before my health issues and I can verify. It is a grind. Especially when you’re spending your time off from work to do it.

No problem, I don’t mind sharing them amongst the 10 of us that keep up with this still 😂

Like I said, I get more enjoyment out of editing rosters sometimes than I do playing the game. I will even edit these rosters AGAIN after I finish editing every team.

It’s just what I like to do.

[Redsdude]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Reds are complete. I uploaded it to the vault. Had to take a break yesterday bc my girlfriend wanted to spend the night.

You are the man. I am going to try and get on later and comb through them. Doing some stuff with the new born and family now lol.

[Jay_AB81]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

No problem, I don’t mind sharing them amongst the 10 of us that keep up with this still 😂

Like I said, I get more enjoyment out of editing rosters sometimes than I do playing the game. I will even edit these rosters AGAIN after I finish editing every team.

It’s just what I like to do.

Same here, I'm currently working with someone else to do an offseason NBA 2K22 roster for the Switch, keep tweaking things, both of us lol

[Redsdude]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Reds are complete. I uploaded it to the vault. Had to take a break yesterday bc my girlfriend wanted to spend the night.

These are the best rosters I’ve seen, ratings wise, which is by far the most important aspect. I look at some of the lower level guys to see how in depth a roster is. You nailed guys like Rece Hinds and Austin Hendrick on the Reds. Very questionable hit tool but with big power potential.
Also the best De La Cruz and McClain I’ve seen. I also love the adjustments to major leaguers. Love the ratings of guys like Senzel,Stephenson, then Albies, Riley and others on the Braves.
Great job and I’m starting my franchise with both. I’ll be able to simply manually make the bigger trades. Thanks for working on these man!

[Firestorm]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I don't even own the game anymore, but out of curiosity, is this new version yall been talking about based on the original or the equipment edited version that I made a few months ago?

I love how you purposely didn't respond to my comment... very classy.

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

These are the best rosters I’ve seen, ratings wise, which is by far the most important aspect. I look at some of the lower level guys to see how in depth a roster is. You nailed guys like Rece Hinds and Austin Hendrick on the Reds. Very questionable hit tool but with big power potential.
Also the best De La Cruz and McClain I’ve seen. I also love the adjustments to major leaguers. Love the ratings of guys like Senzel,Stephenson, then Albies, Riley and others on the Braves.
Great job and I’m starting my franchise with both. I’ll be able to simply manually make the bigger trades. Thanks for working on these man!

Appreciate it! I literally read every scouting report for every prospect, look at their stats, splits, etc. And then I do the same for the MLB players. It’s a lot of work, but definitely entertaining and a great way to kill time for me. Just glad that Fidelity gave us such an in depth prospect roster, because the other ones always leave out so many good prospects.

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I love how you purposely didn't respond to my comment... very classy.

I honestly have no idea, unless Fidelity uploaded yours into his vault, then I’m probably using the OG version.

[nbrammer3]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Stumbled on this thread, and took a look at your “Test 2” ratings.. these are phenomenal. Well done. Spencer Strider rating dialed in. How many teams have you done? And are they all updated and uploaded to the vault?

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Stumbled on this thread, and took a look at your “Test 2” ratings.. these are phenomenal. Well done. Spencer Strider rating dialed in. How many teams have you done? And are they all updated and uploaded to the vault?

Thank you.

So far (in that version you downloaded) the teams that I’ve completed are Arizona, Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago Cubs, Chicago White Sox, Cincinnati.

[nbrammer3]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Thank you.

So far (in that version you downloaded) the teams that I’ve completed are Arizona, Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago Cubs, Chicago White Sox, Cincinnati.

Right on. Thx for the reply. How quickly have you been knocking these out? A couple a day? Do you update this post when you complete another team?

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Right on. Thx for the reply. How quickly have you been knocking these out? A couple a day? Do you update this post when you complete another team?

I usually average 2 a day on the weekday. I will probably get 3 done today. I’m working on Cleveland right now, and so far they have been the most time consuming out of all the teams I’ve done so far.

I want to knock out 3, possibly 4 today. I will def update the thread after each day to list what teams I’ve completed.

[nbrammer3]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I usually average 2 a day on the weekday. I will probably get 3 done today. I’m working on Cleveland right now, and so far they have been the most time consuming out of all the teams I’ve done so far.

I want to knock out 3, possibly 4 today. I will def update the thread after each day to list what teams I’ve completed.

Right on. Your ratings are so good, that it helps unbelievably for franchise realism and longevity. When you finish a team do you update them to the vault immediately ? Or do you wait to do it when you are done for the day? Just didn’t know your process. Thx.

[Bushido]

Re: Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Right on. Your ratings are so good, that it helps unbelievably for franchise realism and longevity. When you finish a team do you update them to the vault immediately ? Or do you wait to do it when you are done for the day? Just didn’t know your process. Thx.

I don’t update the vault daily. I only did it in this instance because the reds fan wanted it, and didn’t necessarily care about the rest of the teams wanting to be completed lol.