The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

[TripleCrown]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I personally think it’s a good idea to remove those min & max !!

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I personally think it’s a good idea to remove those min & max !!

How aggressively should we tweak reliever stamina?

I'm thinking about multi-inning guys who could probably start. We're seeing this now more than ever with guys like Michael King, Garrett Crochet, Rasmussen etc being converted into starters.

This is a good read:

https://pitcherlist.com/identifying-relievers-who-could-start/

We often talk about how to convert relievers into starters as well on these forums, so maybe using stamina as a clearer hint could be an idea.

Some examples:
Luke Weaver (former starter, now high leverage reliever): 51 stamina

Andrew Wantz (mentioned in the article above, faced about 6 batters a game year before last): 62 stamina

Devin Williams (closer): 27 stamina

Shawn Armstrong (5.18 batters faced per game): 48 stamina

Josh Hader (closer): 25 stamina

I can test more guys too. But what do you think?

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Im liking the way the updated pitcher stamina ratings are looking

How do you guys feel about RP overalls? Should they be more spread out?

Looking at the live roster, SDS has Cleveland as follows:
Cade Smith 90 (seems high for a RP)
Hunter Gaddis 82
Tim Herrin 80
Sam Hentges 78
James Karinchak 74
Nick Sandlin 71

Rockies
John Curtiss 72
Daniel Bard 71
Matt och 66
Jake Bird 65
Lucas Gilbreath 65
Ryan Faltmer 64
Justin Lawrence 63

Are 80+ too high for relivers? I see some relivers in the 50s as well. Is that too low?

After doing the Orioles, this is how the overalls look with a slightly modified OVR system:
Félix Bautista 93
Seranthony Domínguez 74
Yennier Cano 77
Keegan Akin 78
Gregory Soto 73
Cionel Pérez 71
Bryan Baker 67
Colin Selby 67
Thaddeus Ward 66
Matt Bowman 67


Blue Jays
Chad Green 80
Yimi García 71
Erik Swanson 67
Nick Sandlin 72
Ryan Burr 66
Brendon Little 69
Tommy Nance 66
Zach Pop 67
Nick Robertson 65
Josh Walker 64
Michael Petersen 64
Brett de Geus 63
Easton Lucas 61

[TuffJuff]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Happy new year!

As we start laying the groundwork for MLB 25 rosters - I just imported all the data I need for ratings yesterday! - are there any changes you all would be interested in seeing?

I've heard some say, for example, that for pitchers, they would like the starter stamina minimum of 75 be removed, and the reliver max stamina of 30 be removed. It was done a couple of years ago to help bullpen logic some, but I'm open to changes.

Any and all feedback is welcome!

I know you probably don’t want to give away the goods, but any advice for someone looking to mess around and do this for themselves on a smaller scale while we wait for you to finish?

Seems like for about a 1 strikeout per inning pitcher we want the k/9 to be around 75ish. What about for the other attributes? What would you say an average walks/9 guy would be? Hits/9, etc. I know Kutter Crawford led the league by giving up 34 homers last season. How low we making him in Hr/9?

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I know you probably don’t want to give away the goods, but any advice for someone looking to mess around and do this for themselves on a smaller scale while we wait for you to finish?

Seems like for about a 1 strikeout per inning pitcher we want the k/9 to be around 75ish. What about for the other attributes? What would you say an average walks/9 guy would be? Hits/9, etc. I know Kutter Crawford led the league by giving up 34 homers last season. How low we making him in Hr/9?

Well, let's see what I have for Crawford's updated ratings. That may give you an idea:

Stamina 77 - 23 batters faced per game last year
Pitching Clutch 41 - .285 avg with RISP for his career
H/9 60 - average ERA the past 3 seasons is 4.48
HR/9 52 - 1.67 homers/9 last year would be about a 47
K/9 73 - 175 Ks last year, 8.6 Ks per 9 innings
BB/9 65 - WHIP was 1.12 over 183 IP last year


New thread:
https://forums.operationsports.com/f...-mlb-25-a.html