Sorry to hear you are having issues. The Indians are tough outs, especially that top of the order of Webster, Money, and Keys.
You can bump up pitch speeds for your hitting. Even a tick can alter things a lot.
As for pitching. I'd look at your pitching patterns. You have to balance out attacking hitters and nibbling. Sounds to me like you may be nibbling too much. Also, you can always drop down to AS if it is still too hard for you; no shame in that at all, that's why the option is there.

Comment