Hi as you can see i'm new here, but i've been lurking on these forums for a long time. In fact it was the vast majority of ppl here that made me a SEGA SPORTS fan. 
Anyways on to the post at hand.
STADIUMS: ASB seems to have the edge in stadium models. They have captured the essence of the stadiums i've seen so far however WSB seems to have more detail with other things related to the stadiums. (like the big apple at Shea and the train at Minute Maid) WSB's stadiums look a bit big and slightly cartoony to me...that is until I saw the screenshot of the Polo Grounds! Wow that was gorgeaus! I wonder if they'll have Ebbetts Field in the game?
Anyways I was thinking of something interesting for ballpark atmosphere but wouldn't it be cool if during a blowout there would be a cutscene of fans playing with a beach ball and it rolling on the outfield?
I do have one question tho, does any of the games have park specific chants etc? You know like the chants for Yankee players and the drums at Oakland.
UNIFORMS: This is almost as important as gameplay to me in a game where a season is 162 games long. Seems to me that WSB has better variety of uniforms with the regular, alt, and 3 throwbacks. I did read in the PJ Snavely interview that a team would get at least one throwback in ASB....wonder how much throwbacks would be the max for a team? Anyways uniform accuracy is a big thing for me and the SEGA titles get these right for the most part (cept for minute details) so which franchise (ASB/WSB) has better accuracy?
MISC. I just love the behind the pitcher view! WOOHOO WSB!
I don't know why the ASB people are so against that view as it would really up the realism of the game. I also dislike the squating in ASB...sadly they didn't fix that. All in all, I think i'm going to purchase both WSB and ASB. I just thought i'd give some graphical opinions with a couple questions. Thanks for reading.
Anyways on to the post at hand.STADIUMS: ASB seems to have the edge in stadium models. They have captured the essence of the stadiums i've seen so far however WSB seems to have more detail with other things related to the stadiums. (like the big apple at Shea and the train at Minute Maid) WSB's stadiums look a bit big and slightly cartoony to me...that is until I saw the screenshot of the Polo Grounds! Wow that was gorgeaus! I wonder if they'll have Ebbetts Field in the game?
Anyways I was thinking of something interesting for ballpark atmosphere but wouldn't it be cool if during a blowout there would be a cutscene of fans playing with a beach ball and it rolling on the outfield?
I do have one question tho, does any of the games have park specific chants etc? You know like the chants for Yankee players and the drums at Oakland.UNIFORMS: This is almost as important as gameplay to me in a game where a season is 162 games long. Seems to me that WSB has better variety of uniforms with the regular, alt, and 3 throwbacks. I did read in the PJ Snavely interview that a team would get at least one throwback in ASB....wonder how much throwbacks would be the max for a team? Anyways uniform accuracy is a big thing for me and the SEGA titles get these right for the most part (cept for minute details) so which franchise (ASB/WSB) has better accuracy?
MISC. I just love the behind the pitcher view! WOOHOO WSB!
I don't know why the ASB people are so against that view as it would really up the realism of the game. I also dislike the squating in ASB...sadly they didn't fix that. All in all, I think i'm going to purchase both WSB and ASB. I just thought i'd give some graphical opinions with a couple questions. Thanks for reading.
Comment