PS3 or X360

[ericjwm]

Re: PS3 or X360

I have both and got to play both last night. The game is really the same on both systems. The graphics are really pretty close--the 360 seemed a bit brighter but that's really it. Gameplay was exactly the same. I agree with one of the posters earlier--get the one for the controller you feel most comfortable with.

I will spend most of my time with the PS3 (I just like the controller and the quiet of the system better), but online will be spent with the 360. If you have other questions about the two, fire away.

Well, I got the ps3 version so i can now compare it to the 360 demo.
First off ill say that they look different. The first thing to stick out to me is the grass... on the ps3 its just kinda a blurry green texture and on the 360 it has a bit more detail. Not alot of detail, mind you, but definitely more than the ps3. But, the rest of the PS3 graphics *pop* alot more (on my set, atleast). The players look sharper as do the stadiums.

Im running both in 720p. I havent tried 1080i (nor do I even know if its availible for the ps3).

From a gameplay standpoint the game definitely plays better on the ps3... it just feels more polished. BUT, im betting the final version of the 360 version does also. The camera in the ps3 version is less jerky and the game just feels smoother. But, again, I think that's because the 360 demo is early.

The grass thing is a major bummer since thats what takes up the majority of the screen 99% of the time. But the rest looks nicer. I could see fanboys from either system arguing that their version is OMG TOTALLY BETTER... but in reality beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I prefer the ps3 look but that is probably because i bought the ps3 version... :P

Like i said earlier the gameplay is alot smoother on the ps3, but it would be better to talk to favre4vr about that one, for sure.

Thanx alot for the PS3/360 comparison guys, but what about the self shadowing on players? I've heard that its not quite as noticeable in the PS3 version (ie: the players arms & bat casting a shadow on them,etc..). Can either of you comment on that a little?

[bkrich83]

Re: PS3 or X360

that's what I was still thinking since most still don't have PS3's roster updates and playing online would be better towards the 360 so far I don't like the PSN and XBL is way better for now that is. have you played the game online yet

One game so far. Played pretty smooth online for me.

[Gary Armida]

Re: PS3 or X360

Thanx alot for the PS3/360 comparison guys, but what about the self shadowing on players? I've heard that its not quite as noticeable in the PS3 version (ie: the players arms & bat casting a shadow on them,etc..). Can either of you comment on that a little?

Eric--I'm probably the wrong guy to answer this as I tend to not notice this (not saying it's not important). I think the 360 is more detailed with that and it may not be there on the PS3, but I didn't really look. I'll be playing more tonight and I will look.

[ericjwm]

Re: PS3 or X360

Eric--I'm probably the wrong guy to answer this as I tend to not notice this (not saying it's not important). I think the 360 is more detailed with that and it may not be there on the PS3, but I didn't really look. I'll be playing more tonight and I will look.

Maybe since you didn't notice theres not that much of a difference. Someone in another thread said that the PS3 ver does have it, but he was the first to confirm it..... so I guess I'm looking for further confirmation. I know it's not that big a deal, but I just think that particular detail makes the game look alot more realistic.
Anyway, I'll check back later to see what you found out with closer observation.

[stark21]

Re: PS3 or X360

I know in the other thread they said the self shadowing was not in the ps3 unless I misread it so don't quote me on that.

[Sully]

Re: PS3 or X360

I have both now, and a few things I've noticed in my brief time with them...

The 360 version seems to have better lighting, but the PS3's player models look better. Played 6 games total on the Pro setting for the PS3, and only hit 6 homeruns, while have the CPU hit 5 against me. Played 2 games today on the All Star setting for the 360, and I hit 11 homeruns total, while having 5 hit against me. I'm not putting much stock into this, but it's something I'm going to keep an eye on.

[Scottdau]

Re: PS3 or X360

I have both now, and a few things I've noticed in my brief time with them...

The 360 version seems to have better lighting, but the PS3's player models look better. Played 6 games total on the Pro setting for the PS3, and only hit 6 homeruns, while have the CPU hit 5 against me. Played 2 games today on the All Star setting for the 360, and I hit 11 homeruns total, while having 5 hit against me. I'm not putting much stock into this, but it's something I'm going to keep an eye on.

Don't you think maybe the controllers might be the reason?

[Sully]

Re: PS3 or X360

Don't you think maybe the controllers might be the reason?

I was using classic one button hitting on both, so...No.

[bluengold34_OS]

Re: PS3 or X360

Scotty, I have been meaning to ask what you thought about this game.....I love it on the PS3 and I hear good things on the 360 as well...not a perfect game by any stretch, but damn am I having fun playing on-line(psn)

[DrUrsus]

Re: PS3 or X360

I bought both yesterday, and I am no fanboy of either because I have both systems. On my TV (A Samsung DLP I run in 720p), the Xbox 360 version overall looks better, but only because of the self-shadowing and grass textures. But, it is darker, and partly due to this, especially in night games I have a really tough time with hard hit ground balls and spotting the blue spot where the ball will land in the outfield. The PS3 version is slightly sharper and brighter. The hats, etc don't shadow on the PS3 version like they do on the Xbox 360. The Xbox 360 version has a more realistic look to it because of the shadowing. There are shadows of the players bodies, and bats on the PS3 version, but not for instance under their hats.Next Fielding just works better on the PS3 for some reason. I am not sure if it is because I can see the ball off the bat better or if the controller is just more responsive, or if the game just runs smoother, I will have to play more to find out. The xbox 360 batting is more responsive for some reason, but you get used to the different timing on the PS3.Next, little things. Xbox 360 Manny Ramirez has the dreads, but Not the PS3 Manny. Why? I haven't looked at big unit or some other players with long hair yet. Haven't noticed any difference in menus or presentation overall.Don't like the sixaxis batting as of now, and opted for one button swing on both systems.Overall for me, the PS3 version is more fun to play. Fielding is easier, and I see the ball better. I have absolutely no trouble fielding even in night games on the PS3, but on the Xbox 360 I have struggled on occasion, especially at night games.I miss the rumble that the Xbox 360 has. It has a nice feel when the ball hits the mit, and during tough situations when the ball bounces around. It does this on the PS3, but it doesn't rattle you as much. PS3 please pay the rumble people and come out with an optional rumble controller for God's sake.Overall, like the game so far, but not the one fielding camera for ground balls. I would rather have a good camera and paper crowds if that is the issue (which I don't believe it is anyway). I haven't played enough games for real yet to see if last years stuff is fixed (rocket arms, can't score from 2nd on a single to right, not using the cut-off man (have seen them use it), substitions, etc.)But, I struggled on which version to buy, so I bought both for peace of mind since I don't buy a ton of games anyway, just the major sports, and big games like Halo series, Call of duty, Gears of War, Resistance, etc.I would say if you have both systems and only can afford one, and Xbox live is not a big issue with you, and you mostly play against the computer like me, gameplay is a little more important to you than graphics, get the PS3 version, otherwise get the 360 version. Rent first if you have the patience to wait.

[Scottdau]

Re: PS3 or X360

I was using classic one button hitting on both, so...No.

Oh OK, that makes sense, thanks

[DrUrsus]

Re: PS3 or X360

Sully, are you finding the PS3 fielding to be a little easier?