Re: WOW!
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
-
Originally posted by Jay Bilas -
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Really? I think they look fine, the batting stances are most excellent. That MVP pic really captures the "atmosphere" and largeness of the stadium...I think it looks awesome.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Really? I think they look fine, the batting stances are most excellent. That MVP pic really captures the "atmosphere" and largeness of the stadium...I think it looks awesome.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Really? I think they look fine, the batting stances are most excellent. That MVP pic really captures the "atmosphere" and largeness of the stadium...I think it looks awesome.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
I personally like asb and mvp above wsb. I just think that the wsb player models look funny. asb and mvp players actully look like real people. I don't really know just something bothers me about the wsb players.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
Wow, ASB looks pretty bad compared to those. MVP looks nice, but I don't like the player models.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Really? I think they look fine, the batting stances are most excellent. That MVP pic really captures the "atmosphere" and largeness of the stadium...I think it looks awesome.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
I personally like asb and mvp above wsb. I just think that the wsb player models look funny. asb and mvp players actully look like real people. I don't really know just something bothers me about the wsb players.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
I think they look to bunched up an midgety. Sort of like Madden, and I don't like there player models either. I like pretty much all the other parts of MVP's graphics thoughOriginally posted by Jay BilasComment
-
Re: WOW!
I think they look to bunched up an midgety. Sort of like Madden, and I don't like there player models either. I like pretty much all the other parts of MVP's graphics thoughOriginally posted by Jay BilasComment
-
Re: WOW!
I've been browsing this site for a couple of weeks and the one thing I thought was cool was that the editors seemed really objective. But now I'm starting to think otherwise. I mean, how can you post screenshots of different sizes and perspectives and say to compare? Posting huge WSB screenshots where the player models are blown up, and then tiny screenshots of the other games! In order to be fair and objective, the player models should all be at least the same scale as the others, and the image size should definitely be the same. Everyone should realize that some of these companies run their screenshots through PhotoShop many times and it never looks that good on the console. IMHO this is a very bias display and makes me wonder about who's actually running the show. I'm very dissappointed in what I thought was a great forum to discuss sports games. As sad as it sounds, this is only my second post and it may be my last.
Comment
-
Re: WOW!
I've been browsing this site for a couple of weeks and the one thing I thought was cool was that the editors seemed really objective. But now I'm starting to think otherwise. I mean, how can you post screenshots of different sizes and perspectives and say to compare? Posting huge WSB screenshots where the player models are blown up, and then tiny screenshots of the other games! In order to be fair and objective, the player models should all be at least the same scale as the others, and the image size should definitely be the same. Everyone should realize that some of these companies run their screenshots through PhotoShop many times and it never looks that good on the console. IMHO this is a very bias display and makes me wonder about who's actually running the show. I'm very dissappointed in what I thought was a great forum to discuss sports games. As sad as it sounds, this is only my second post and it may be my last.
Comment
-
Re: WOW!
Snappa,
Peter probably spent five minutes gathering up other screens. In fact Peter wrote up a comparitive forum feature on all the games...don't know where that went though. It was all unintentional...
although being from Canada just makes us all wonder some times
Comment
-
Re: WOW!
Snappa,
Peter probably spent five minutes gathering up other screens. In fact Peter wrote up a comparitive forum feature on all the games...don't know where that went though. It was all unintentional...
although being from Canada just makes us all wonder some times
Comment
-
Re: WOW!
Snapy, we'll miss you. Let us know how things work out.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
Snapy, we'll miss you. Let us know how things work out.Comment
-
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
IMHO this is a very bias display and makes me wonder about who's actually running the show. I'm very dissappointed in what I thought was a great forum to discuss sports games. As sad as it sounds, this is only my second post and it may be my last.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
It just shows how little you know about us. Peter of all the staff is the biggest supporter of ASB we have. We are all human after all and have some bias but since he was the one who put countless hours in putting a baseball comparison off all the games together you are so off on your comments it is not even funny.
If you want to leave because of a couple of screenshots then don't let that virtual door hit you on the way out.
But to be fair here are some "in game" screens if each game. Using the Xbox version (excluding MLB which is only on the PS2 and Slugfest since GS only had PS2 screens) and all from the same source (gamespot.com) and all the same size.
ASB 2004
MVP 2003
High Heat 2004
WSB 2K3
MLB 2003
MLB Slugfest 20-04
They are just screenshots by the way. It's not like he put in some hidden message to buy WSB.
Comment
-
Re: WOW!
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
IMHO this is a very bias display and makes me wonder about who's actually running the show. I'm very dissappointed in what I thought was a great forum to discuss sports games. As sad as it sounds, this is only my second post and it may be my last.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
It just shows how little you know about us. Peter of all the staff is the biggest supporter of ASB we have. We are all human after all and have some bias but since he was the one who put countless hours in putting a baseball comparison off all the games together you are so off on your comments it is not even funny.
If you want to leave because of a couple of screenshots then don't let that virtual door hit you on the way out.
But to be fair here are some "in game" screens if each game. Using the Xbox version (excluding MLB which is only on the PS2 and Slugfest since GS only had PS2 screens) and all from the same source (gamespot.com) and all the same size.
ASB 2004
MVP 2003
High Heat 2004
WSB 2K3
MLB 2003
MLB Slugfest 20-04
They are just screenshots by the way. It's not like he put in some hidden message to buy WSB.
Comment
Comment