Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • **DONOTDELETE**
    Hall Of Fame
    • Oct 2025
    • 19598

    #16
    Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

    vladimir guerrero. he gets a lot of praise, but he deserves a million times more! a lot of people don't realize how ridiculously good this kid is.

    Comment

    • **DONOTDELETE**
      Hall Of Fame
      • Oct 2025
      • 19598

      #17
      Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

      vladimir guerrero. he gets a lot of praise, but he deserves a million times more! a lot of people don't realize how ridiculously good this kid is.

      Comment

      • ScottISU
        Rookie
        • Dec 2002
        • 180

        #18
        Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

        "O-ver, RAY- ted" : Derek Jeter. If he played for the Expos, you'd hear much less about him than you hear about Guerrero.

        Under- Magglio Ordonez. If he played for the Yankees, they'd already be building him a plaque in monument park.

        Comment

        • ScottISU
          Rookie
          • Dec 2002
          • 180

          #19
          Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

          "O-ver, RAY- ted" : Derek Jeter. If he played for the Expos, you'd hear much less about him than you hear about Guerrero.

          Under- Magglio Ordonez. If he played for the Yankees, they'd already be building him a plaque in monument park.

          Comment

          • DragDashOn
            Rookie
            • Jul 2002
            • 497

            #20
            Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

            Scott made a very good point that I have been saying forever. Your team has a lot to do with how you are rated. Not only does a good team make you better and a bad team make you worse, a good team makes you seem better and a bad team makes you seem worse

            Comment

            • DragDashOn
              Rookie
              • Jul 2002
              • 497

              #21
              Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

              Scott made a very good point that I have been saying forever. Your team has a lot to do with how you are rated. Not only does a good team make you better and a bad team make you worse, a good team makes you seem better and a bad team makes you seem worse

              Comment

              • Ckhoss29
                MVP
                • Feb 2003
                • 980

                #22
                Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                Overrated
                Mike Cameron
                Jeter
                Mo Vaughn
                Jeromy Burnitz


                Underrated
                Ryan Klesko
                Brian Giles
                Richie Sexson
                Bartolo Colon

                Comment

                • Ckhoss29
                  MVP
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 980

                  #23
                  Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                  Overrated
                  Mike Cameron
                  Jeter
                  Mo Vaughn
                  Jeromy Burnitz


                  Underrated
                  Ryan Klesko
                  Brian Giles
                  Richie Sexson
                  Bartolo Colon

                  Comment

                  • keRplunK
                    MVP
                    • Jul 2002
                    • 4080

                    #24
                    Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                    Overrated

                    1.Derek Jeter
                    2.Roberto Alomar
                    3.Sammy Sosa
                    4.Bartolo Colon
                    5.Roger Clemens
                    6.Omar Vizquel

                    Underrated
                    1.Roy Halladay
                    2.Jamie Moyer
                    3.Brian Giles
                    4.Mark Buerhle
                    5.Torii Hunter
                    6.John Olerud

                    Comment

                    • keRplunK
                      MVP
                      • Jul 2002
                      • 4080

                      #25
                      Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                      Overrated

                      1.Derek Jeter
                      2.Roberto Alomar
                      3.Sammy Sosa
                      4.Bartolo Colon
                      5.Roger Clemens
                      6.Omar Vizquel

                      Underrated
                      1.Roy Halladay
                      2.Jamie Moyer
                      3.Brian Giles
                      4.Mark Buerhle
                      5.Torii Hunter
                      6.John Olerud

                      Comment

                      • HMcCoy
                        All Star
                        • Jan 2003
                        • 8212

                        #26
                        Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                        I think if a single person calls EEEEEsherro overated,That makes him underrated in my book. Many great hitters struggle for a bit when switching leagues, but this guy switched universes.

                        Switched Parks,pitchers,strikezones,teamates,culture.
                        And still flirted with .400?
                        That is un-freakin'-real.

                        Over:
                        Jeter
                        Kent
                        Colon
                        Manny (unless he woulda' re-signed with my tribe )

                        Hank's Custom Collectibles 3D printer/painter extraordinaire

                        Comment

                        • HMcCoy
                          All Star
                          • Jan 2003
                          • 8212

                          #27
                          Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                          I think if a single person calls EEEEEsherro overated,That makes him underrated in my book. Many great hitters struggle for a bit when switching leagues, but this guy switched universes.

                          Switched Parks,pitchers,strikezones,teamates,culture.
                          And still flirted with .400?
                          That is un-freakin'-real.

                          Over:
                          Jeter
                          Kent
                          Colon
                          Manny (unless he woulda' re-signed with my tribe )

                          Hank's Custom Collectibles 3D printer/painter extraordinaire

                          Comment

                          • bkrich83
                            Has Been
                            • Jul 2002
                            • 71582

                            #28
                            Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                            My most 2 underrated players both play for the Royals.

                            Mike Sweeney and Carlos Beltran. Both players put up pretty nice numbers but neither player really gets much national exposure.

                            Tracking my NCAA Coach Career

                            Comment

                            • bkrich83
                              Has Been
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 71582

                              #29
                              Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                              My most 2 underrated players both play for the Royals.

                              Mike Sweeney and Carlos Beltran. Both players put up pretty nice numbers but neither player really gets much national exposure.

                              Tracking my NCAA Coach Career

                              Comment

                              • HatTrick
                                Rookie
                                • Aug 2002
                                • 105

                                #30
                                Re: Most overrated/underrated player in the Majors.

                                This is no longer an overrated/underrated thread. It's become more of which players do you like and which players do you hate. You can't say guys like Alomar, Vaughn, and Johnson are overrated. Washed up maybe, but not overrated, because they were once pretty good. Just because they piss you off now because they aren't what they used to be doesn't turn them into overrated players.

                                Look at the stats. Koskie is not underrated. He's really just an average player. So are Olerud, Bell, Nixon, Kotsay, and most of the other guys mentioned. Now guys like Giles, Beltran, and Buehrle who actually put up numbers but don't get much recognition, that's underrated.

                                Comment

                                Working...