HELP: Which baseball game to get?

[ChicagoSparty]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
iogdaP said:
I need a little help in picking a good baseball game for XBox. I am a Yankee fan so I will be playing with the Yankees. I had WSB 2K3 and maxed out the sliders and the game was still way too easy. I was 21-3 and the 3 losses were by one run each. I have High Heat now but there is just not enough user control. Even if you are right on a pitch, it just feels like the computer dictates where the ball goes and I hate that. So can someone please help me as to which game to get that combines graphics, gameplay, and a good challenge where I won't go 160-2? How is ASB 2004? How is MVP? How is Inside Pitch? Please, a little feedback.

<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
I was going to recommend WSB first, and then HH behind that. I think ASB is terribly unrealistic, but MVP was somewhat fun to play.

I think playing with the Yankees is tough, because every game has them rated very high (in WSB, they're "100" overall). Maybe you could start a Yankees franchise in WSB with fictional players?

[Sabercatsfan]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

I would recommend ASB 2004 first and then WSB 2K3. MVP is pretty good too. I love the depth of ASB, especially the expansion mode. There is so many things to do. WSB has a good franchise mode and is a lot of fun to play. MLB 2004 is a good try by 989 Sports, but not quite good enough. I never liked High Heat, but some people really love it. I only played Inside Pitch a couple of times and it was just ok. Good luck.

[Sabercatsfan]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

I would recommend ASB 2004 first and then WSB 2K3. MVP is pretty good too. I love the depth of ASB, especially the expansion mode. There is so many things to do. WSB has a good franchise mode and is a lot of fun to play. MLB 2004 is a good try by 989 Sports, but not quite good enough. I never liked High Heat, but some people really love it. I only played Inside Pitch a couple of times and it was just ok. Good luck.

[Sabercatsfan]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

I would recommend ASB 2004 first and then WSB 2K3. MVP is pretty good too. I love the depth of ASB, especially the expansion mode. There is so many things to do. WSB has a good franchise mode and is a lot of fun to play. MLB 2004 is a good try by 989 Sports, but not quite good enough. I never liked High Heat, but some people really love it. I only played Inside Pitch a couple of times and it was just ok. Good luck.

[XTREMEGAMER]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Trust me on this one? many might disagree but MVP is the most fun game i ever played. it is easy to play against the CPU in the highest level, but you could tweak it to make it harder which is more fun to do. My brother is a hardcore yankees fan and hes currently playing with the yankees in MVP and his current record is 17-12. No Joke!! if you change the settings a little it makes it more challenging. He's currently playing in all-star with strike zone and pitching cursor and vibration off. TRUST ME!!! it makes it much harder.

[XTREMEGAMER]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Trust me on this one? many might disagree but MVP is the most fun game i ever played. it is easy to play against the CPU in the highest level, but you could tweak it to make it harder which is more fun to do. My brother is a hardcore yankees fan and hes currently playing with the yankees in MVP and his current record is 17-12. No Joke!! if you change the settings a little it makes it more challenging. He's currently playing in all-star with strike zone and pitching cursor and vibration off. TRUST ME!!! it makes it much harder.

[XTREMEGAMER]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Trust me on this one? many might disagree but MVP is the most fun game i ever played. it is easy to play against the CPU in the highest level, but you could tweak it to make it harder which is more fun to do. My brother is a hardcore yankees fan and hes currently playing with the yankees in MVP and his current record is 17-12. No Joke!! if you change the settings a little it makes it more challenging. He's currently playing in all-star with strike zone and pitching cursor and vibration off. TRUST ME!!! it makes it much harder.

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Wow.

Umm... I would have recommended WSB...

And then, High Heat...

But, IMO ASB is boring, the series has always been like that and its no different this year.

I think you should rent all 3 and see if your interested in any of them.

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Wow.

Umm... I would have recommended WSB...

And then, High Heat...

But, IMO ASB is boring, the series has always been like that and its no different this year.

I think you should rent all 3 and see if your interested in any of them.

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Wow.

Umm... I would have recommended WSB...

And then, High Heat...

But, IMO ASB is boring, the series has always been like that and its no different this year.

I think you should rent all 3 and see if your interested in any of them.

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Yeah, the Yankees are rated a 100 in every game, kind of sucks for Yankee fans (me included). Go start a Franchise with those Tigers , or Devil Rays

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Yeah, the Yankees are rated a 100 in every game, kind of sucks for Yankee fans (me included). Go start a Franchise with those Tigers , or Devil Rays

[SC3BBall]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Yeah, the Yankees are rated a 100 in every game, kind of sucks for Yankee fans (me included). Go start a Franchise with those Tigers , or Devil Rays

[e0820]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Are you playing timed hitting or are u using cursor? You may wanna try some different sliders, I find one of the sliders on this forum to play a great "real" game of baseball (Excell?). Anyway, good luck in your search!

[e0820]

Re: HELP: Which baseball game to get?

Are you playing timed hitting or are u using cursor? You may wanna try some different sliders, I find one of the sliders on this forum to play a great "real" game of baseball (Excell?). Anyway, good luck in your search!