Who would you take...?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • letsgopens66
    Pro
    • Aug 2010
    • 846

    #1

    Who would you take...?

    I've been thinking about this the past few days, and I hopefully I explain it well enough. If for some crazy reason, the MLB decides start over and puts all its players in a pool for a fantasy draft you had the first overall pick, who would you take? Would you take an up and coming rookie who has a 10-15 year upside and could be a franchise cornerstone? Or would you take a more established player? An example would be Bryce Harper vs. Josh Hamilton. Who would you take?

    This doesn't have to be limited to the MLB, btw.

    Personally, I would risk it with a younger, yet unproven player. The upside would be too much for me to pass up on.
    Pittsburgh Penguins
    Penn State Nittany Lions
    Pittsburgh Pirates
    Denver Broncos
  • cardinals57
    Pro
    • Mar 2011
    • 792

    #2
    Re: Who would you take...?

    I would probably have to go with Bryce Harper as my first pick. I know he is very unproven but I like what I've seen from him so far, and his ceiling is ridiculously high. Hes got a cannon for an arm, and he just has a certain attitude about him. I don't know, I might be wrong but I see him becoming a superstar.

    Comment

    • TCM
      MVP
      • Jun 2011
      • 1800

      #3
      Re: Who would you take...?

      If I had to take a hitter, Giancarlo Stanton. If I had to take a pitcher it would be Clayton Kershaw.
      1905 1921 1922 1933 1954 2010 2012
      San Francisco Giants

      Butte College

      Comment

      • joshuar9476
        MVP
        • Feb 2006
        • 1880

        #4
        Re: Who would you take...?

        Joey Votto
        Individuality: Always remember that you are unique. Just like everybody else.

        Fan of:
        Indiana Hoosiers
        Cincinnati Reds
        Joey Logano

        Comment

        • Happy29
          All Star
          • Jan 2006
          • 5489

          #5
          Re: Who would you take...?

          Such a tough question there's so many what if's with unproven players and then there's the age thing that goes with the experience. I'm a take a little experience over youth and take Josh Hamilton with my first pick and build around him a team of youth and speed.
          “Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”
          Benjamin Franklin

          Comment

          • VandyRedskins21
            MVP
            • Dec 2010
            • 1898

            #6
            Re: Who would you take...?

            I'd take a young player who has already proven himself. Plus, I'd rather go with pitching first. With that said, I'd go with Strasburg. (slightly biased )
            Last edited by VandyRedskins21; 06-09-2012, 11:52 AM.
            “If you’re true to yourself, you’re going to be true to everyone else.”

            Comment

            • KingV2k3
              Senior Circuit
              • May 2003
              • 5881

              #7
              Re: Who would you take...?

              Firstly, I take an "every day" position player for maximum "bang" for my buck...

              Secondly, I'd want a "high character" / "leader" / "face of the franchise" guy for marketing and chemistry...

              We're building a team around this guy...

              Considering that, and the fact that he should be able to hit for power, average, field and be in an age group with some "legs" left to his career arc...

              Well...

              I'm having a tough time coming up with a better option than Evan Longoria...

              I'm not even that big a fan of his, he just seems to fit the criteria quite well...

              Comment

              • Chrisksaint
                $$$
                • Apr 2010
                • 19127

                #8
                Re: Who would you take...?

                Originally posted by TCM
                If I had to take a hitter, Giancarlo Stanton. If I had to take a pitcher it would be Clayton Kershaw.
                Pretty much this, In a year or two when Harper/Trout are more established then it could change but Stanton has showed his serious raw power and is already developing into a more all around hitter.
                Saints, LSU, Seminoles, Pelicans, Marlins, Lightning

                Comment

                • PhilliesFan13
                  Banned
                  • May 2009
                  • 15651

                  #9
                  Re: Who would you take...?

                  Without a doubt I'm taking Giancarlo Stanton. Dude is a beast.

                  Comment

                  • Travis40
                    MVP
                    • Nov 2008
                    • 1651

                    #10
                    Re: Who would you take...?

                    I'd pick Clayton Kershaw.

                    Comment

                    • 55
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2006
                      • 20857

                      #11
                      Re: Who would you take...?

                      We just had this thread like last month, but I'll reiterate:

                      Pitcher - Kershaw

                      Position Player - Longoria

                      Comment

                      • Spider Tre
                        Rookie
                        • Aug 2010
                        • 428

                        #12
                        Re: Who would you take...?

                        for pitcher: Clayton Kershaw

                        for hitter: Joey Votto

                        Comment

                        • djep
                          MVP
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 1128

                          #13
                          Re: Who would you take...?

                          Mike Trout. Love his game.

                          Comment

                          • Sportsforever
                            NL MVP
                            • Mar 2005
                            • 20368

                            #14
                            Re: Who would you take...?

                            Hard to go wrong with any of the guys mentioned. It is amazing to me how little talk Kershaw gets compared to Strasburg when they are essentially the same age. Kershaw has been doing it for 5 years now.

                            Anyway, as for my pick I'd probably go with Drew Butera...it's hard to find those hustle/heart guys who can't hit and you apparently can't win without them.
                            "People ask me what I do in winter when there's no baseball. I'll tell you what I do. I stare out the window and wait for spring." - Rogers Hornsby

                            Comment

                            • TCM
                              MVP
                              • Jun 2011
                              • 1800

                              #15
                              Re: Who would you take...?

                              Originally posted by Sportsforever
                              Anyway, as for my pick I'd probably go with Drew Butera...it's hard to find those hustle/heart guys who can't hit and you apparently can't win without them.
                              He brings such a winning presence to the club house. Finally someone understands.
                              1905 1921 1922 1933 1954 2010 2012
                              San Francisco Giants

                              Butte College

                              Comment

                              Working...