Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you've seen)

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Comp625
    Rookie
    • Mar 2003
    • 477

    #1

    Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you've seen)

    The New Years is rapidly approaching. Within the next couple months, we'll be swarmed with media previews of all the baseball games coming out. Then one by one, each game will be released. However, before we get too far ahead of ourselves, please rank each upcoming console baseball game with the #1 game being the game that you're looking forward to the most. Then if you want, write about what you're looking forward to about the game and what turns you off about the game.

    #1 - All Star Baseball
    I'll be honest and say, ASBArt and ASBMan's Q&A threads are what hooked me with this game. There were so many things that I didn't know existed in the All Star Baseball franchise until reading about it. If I had known about the attention to detail (such as 3d Bullpens), I would have picked up this baseball game last year. However, slowly I'm starting to unravel little flaws that will still exist in the 2005 edition (no lefty/righty attributes, pitchers staying in the crouch position, vaccuum fielding, etc.) so that's turning me off a little.

    #2 - ESPN Baseball
    I played World Series Baseball 2003 last year and although the game was fun, there were many "little" things that ticked me off as the season progressed. Eventually, the game became WAY too easy. The only thing that kept the game challenging was the Power-Pro Hitting mode. Although compared to other franchises, there hasn't been much information released about this game but I'm confident Visual Concepts will produce another solid game. The trick is, will ESPN Baseball stand out against the competition?

    #3 - MLB 2005
    This game SOUNDS very immersive and excellent. Although 989 Sports releases solid games, their games tend to fall short versus the competition every year. Who knows, maybe 2004 will be the year for MLB 2005 to finally shine. Too bad I don't have a Playstation 2 but if this game plays as good as it sounds, I'm definitely going to lay down some cash and get a PS2 along with MLB 2005.

    #4 - MVP Baseball
    From what I've read so far in the 1up and IGN interviews, this game sounds awesome. All of the off-field features seem nifty. Its true test will be how the game of baseball is actually played. This was an area where MVP sorely lacked last year. Granted, EASports barely had development time to make MVP last year so hopefully, things will be different this year. No XBox Live play really turns me off about this gamae, though.

    #5 - Microsoft's Game...
    No one knows much about the future of Inside Pitch and High Heat Baseball. Will Microsoft release another baseball game in the middle of the summer (like they did last year with IP2003)? Even if they do, my gut feeling says the game won't hold a candle against the stiff competition listed above. Will they even keep the franchise name "Inside Pitch" or will they switch names once (or if) they start tinkering with the High Heat code.

    So in short:
    1. All Star Baseball 2005
    2. ESPN Baseball
    3. MLB 2005
    4. MVP Baseball 2004
    5. Microsoft's Game
  • dust247
    MVP
    • Jul 2003
    • 3369

    #2
    Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

    1.ASB 2005
    2.Mvp 2004
    3.MLB 2005
    4.Espn
    5.Microsoft
    Colorado Avalanche (NHL)
    Denver Nuggets (NBA)
    Green Bay Packers (NFL)
    Iowa Hawkeyes (NCAA)
    Minnesota Twins (MLB)
    Tennessee Volunteers (NCAA)

    Comment

    • dust247
      MVP
      • Jul 2003
      • 3369

      #3
      Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

      1.ASB 2005
      2.Mvp 2004
      3.MLB 2005
      4.Espn
      5.Microsoft
      Colorado Avalanche (NHL)
      Denver Nuggets (NBA)
      Green Bay Packers (NFL)
      Iowa Hawkeyes (NCAA)
      Minnesota Twins (MLB)
      Tennessee Volunteers (NCAA)

      Comment

      • dust247
        MVP
        • Jul 2003
        • 3369

        #4
        Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

        1.ASB 2005
        2.Mvp 2004
        3.MLB 2005
        4.Espn
        5.Microsoft
        Colorado Avalanche (NHL)
        Denver Nuggets (NBA)
        Green Bay Packers (NFL)
        Iowa Hawkeyes (NCAA)
        Minnesota Twins (MLB)
        Tennessee Volunteers (NCAA)

        Comment

        • TedTurner
          Banned
          • Feb 2003
          • 645

          #5
          Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

          Why the fanboism for ASB ?

          ESPN/WSB is obviously better.

          Comment

          • TedTurner
            Banned
            • Feb 2003
            • 645

            #6
            Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

            Why the fanboism for ASB ?

            ESPN/WSB is obviously better.

            Comment

            • TedTurner
              Banned
              • Feb 2003
              • 645

              #7
              Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

              Why the fanboism for ASB ?

              ESPN/WSB is obviously better.

              Comment

              • SPTO
                binging
                • Feb 2003
                • 68046

                #8
                Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                Far too early to say but my provisional list is:

                MVP (very narrowly edging out ASB)
                ASB
                MLB
                ESPN
                Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

                "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

                Comment

                • SPTO
                  binging
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 68046

                  #9
                  Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                  Far too early to say but my provisional list is:

                  MVP (very narrowly edging out ASB)
                  ASB
                  MLB
                  ESPN
                  Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

                  "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

                  Comment

                  • SPTO
                    binging
                    • Feb 2003
                    • 68046

                    #10
                    Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                    Far too early to say but my provisional list is:

                    MVP (very narrowly edging out ASB)
                    ASB
                    MLB
                    ESPN
                    Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

                    "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

                    Comment

                    • Stoud
                      MVP
                      • Mar 2003
                      • 1259

                      #11
                      Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                      Based on what I've seen, not "Fanboyism", because they have given out about 20 times as much info as any of the other games, ASB is #1. ESPN MLB #2, MVP #3, MLB #4

                      Comment

                      • Stoud
                        MVP
                        • Mar 2003
                        • 1259

                        #12
                        Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                        Based on what I've seen, not "Fanboyism", because they have given out about 20 times as much info as any of the other games, ASB is #1. ESPN MLB #2, MVP #3, MLB #4

                        Comment

                        • Stoud
                          MVP
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 1259

                          #13
                          Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                          Based on what I've seen, not "Fanboyism", because they have given out about 20 times as much info as any of the other games, ASB is #1. ESPN MLB #2, MVP #3, MLB #4

                          Comment

                          • cub
                            MVP
                            • Mar 2003
                            • 1126

                            #14
                            Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                            </font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
                            TedTurner said:
                            Why the fanboism for ASB ?

                            ESPN/WSB is obviously better.

                            <hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

                            WSB wasn't nearly as detailed, realistic-looking, or deep. ASB had all of the features the other series had... plus a ton more. The physics, details, variety of game modes, unlockables, create-a-franchise, and player-specific animations were the most impressive I've ever seen in a sports game of any kind. It actually had all the hitting interfaces from all the other baseball games (including High Heat's zone system), but very few people took the time to change it from the default. It had a few nagging problems (a steep learning curve being the biggest), but mostly it just suffered from misinformation and misunderstanding.

                            That said, WSB was probably better for a pick-up-and-play one-shot game. There was virtually no learning curve, and WSB offered very few of the long-term, rewarding details (like the way ASB had the ivy slowly grow in at Wrigley over the course of the season). So after an hour or two of playing WSB, you saw almost everything it had to offer. It was also better for casual baseball fans who don't really care about authenticity or long-term depth.

                            Comment

                            • cub
                              MVP
                              • Mar 2003
                              • 1126

                              #15
                              Re: Rank your 2005 Console Baseball Games (based on what you\'ve seen)

                              </font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
                              TedTurner said:
                              Why the fanboism for ASB ?

                              ESPN/WSB is obviously better.

                              <hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

                              WSB wasn't nearly as detailed, realistic-looking, or deep. ASB had all of the features the other series had... plus a ton more. The physics, details, variety of game modes, unlockables, create-a-franchise, and player-specific animations were the most impressive I've ever seen in a sports game of any kind. It actually had all the hitting interfaces from all the other baseball games (including High Heat's zone system), but very few people took the time to change it from the default. It had a few nagging problems (a steep learning curve being the biggest), but mostly it just suffered from misinformation and misunderstanding.

                              That said, WSB was probably better for a pick-up-and-play one-shot game. There was virtually no learning curve, and WSB offered very few of the long-term, rewarding details (like the way ASB had the ivy slowly grow in at Wrigley over the course of the season). So after an hour or two of playing WSB, you saw almost everything it had to offer. It was also better for casual baseball fans who don't really care about authenticity or long-term depth.

                              Comment

                              Working...