The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DustinT
    Big Dummy
    • Nov 2004
    • 1933

    #1006
    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

    Originally posted by mvspree8
    No chance the Thunder touch that trade IRL. I doubt the Suns have anybody that the Thunder like enough to trade Ibaka.
    No chance? I know the Thunder love Ibaka, but getting two draft picks and a solid back up for Durant would be a great return for them. Plus the Suns are likely to wind up in the lottery.

    If that trade was proposed in reality the Thunder front office would have to seriously consider pulling the trigger.
    Former OS Editor.
    Follow me on Twitter

    R.I.P Seattle SuperSonics

    Comment

    • Chetballard
      Rookie
      • Aug 2006
      • 277

      #1007
      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

      Pistons Get

      Kenyon Martin
      Jr Smith

      Nuggets Get

      Tasyan Prince
      Charlie Villanueva

      Prince just isnt that good for me, sure he averages 10ppg(Most of those points came when he was playing for the Pistons) I assume he is a decent backup for Anthony.I just dont personally like him, he misses too many shots,and its not too late to find other backup for Anthony but not sure if ever if a player has been traded twice in one year. I will keep Prince for now

      Comment

      • loloben
        Pro
        • May 2010
        • 672

        #1008
        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

        Originally posted by Chetballard
        Pistons Get

        Kenyon Martin
        Jr Smith

        Nuggets Get

        Tasyan Prince
        Charlie Villanueva

        Prince just isnt that good for me, sure he averages 10ppg(Most of those points came when he was playing for the Pistons) I assume he is a decent backup for Anthony.I just dont personally like him, he misses too many shots,and its not too late to find other backup for Anthony but not sure if ever if a player has been traded twice in one year. I will keep Prince for now
        This is a good deal for you, but it is completely unrealistic. With Carmelo probably leaving, there is no way the Nuggets are taking on Charlie V's salary
        "My body could stand the crutches but my mind couldn't stand the sideline"- Michael Jordan

        Comment

        • Chetballard
          Rookie
          • Aug 2006
          • 277

          #1009
          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

          Yeap Charlie does have a big but not huge contract, its something like 22 million for 3 years, but I didnt even look at that when I did the Trade. I did that trade when i just got the game, and now all other trades I pay close mind to there salaries.

          Comment

          • ROABS
            Like Father Like son
            • Dec 2006
            • 1071

            #1010
            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

            after searching for a bigman for the suns i came across a. randolph of the knicks. lately in rl he has been rumoured to be on the block for a 1st round pick and he has requested a trade through his agent. in my association the knicks have lost gallo for the year and are in nd of a sf.

            trade offered

            suns rec

            a.randolph 70 ovr


            knicks rec

            g.hill 78 ovr

            1st rnd pick 12
            2nd rnd pick 11


            thoughts? do you think phoenix is overpaying ? the knicks will accept with only the 1st round pick but wanted to add a bit more.

            Comment

            • ffaacc03
              MVP
              • Oct 2008
              • 3486

              #1011
              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

              Originally posted by ROABS
              after searching for a bigman for the suns i came across a. randolph of the knicks. lately in rl he has been rumoured to be on the block for a 1st round pick and he has requested a trade through his agent. in my association the knicks have lost gallo for the year and are in nd of a sf.

              trade offered

              suns rec

              a.randolph 70 ovr


              knicks rec

              g.hill 78 ovr

              1st rnd pick 12
              2nd rnd pick 11


              thoughts? do you think phoenix is overpaying ? the knicks will accept with only the 1st round pick but wanted to add a bit more.
              Indeed. IRL they are willing to trade him just for a first pick. Unless PHO is in first place or really near it, I dont see NY rejecting an offer for solely their pick.

              Hill, both on IRL and ingame, is a productive player and any team would jump at him ... he might retire, but NY would surely welcome the cap flexibility ... to add a second rp, is just a rip off ala LA-Gasol.

              Comment

              • winrehs_ipang
                Rookie
                • Dec 2010
                • 115

                #1012
                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                Originally posted by Chetballard
                Pistons Get

                Kenyon Martin
                Jr Smith

                Nuggets Get

                Tasyan Prince
                Charlie Villanueva

                Prince just isnt that good for me, sure he averages 10ppg(Most of those points came when he was playing for the Pistons) I assume he is a decent backup for Anthony.I just dont personally like him, he misses too many shots,and its not too late to find other backup for Anthony but not sure if ever if a player has been traded twice in one year. I will keep Prince for now
                Tayshaun and Rip are the leaders of that team, and why would the Pistons opt to like Smith? They already have many talented guys in that position.

                Charlie V. and K. Mart is a decent trade but J.R. for Prince? I don't think so.

                Comment

                • LHSLax_D24
                  MVP
                  • Feb 2009
                  • 1035

                  #1013
                  Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                  30-team Association:

                  Nate Robinson keeps complaining. He's getting 20+ MPG (as a Role Player), yet his morale is <25%. So, I just said screw it and benched him; he's no longer part of the 12-man rotation and has demanded a trade.

                  Since the Celtics are basically screwed with all the complainers on the bench, who can I trade Robinson for that would not complain for limited minutes.

                  BTW, I find this completely unrealistic because he chose to re-sign knowing he would get limited minutes.
                  Purdue Boilermakers
                  Washington Redskins
                  Washington Wizards
                  Washington Capitals
                  Washington Nationals

                  R.I.P. #21

                  Comment

                  • thedukejr
                    Rookie
                    • Jan 2005
                    • 65

                    #1014
                    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                    i signed melo to a 5yr max deal in the offseason in my bulls association. i was using trade finder and seeing what teams would offer for melo. i was surprised by the heat offer.

                    melo & rose

                    for

                    lebron, miller & a 2nd rd pick

                    i was just surprised that they are offering lebron and no i didn't do the deal since i like the combo of rose and melo.

                    Comment

                    • parker987
                      MVP
                      • Nov 2010
                      • 1034

                      #1015
                      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                      Originally posted by thedukejr
                      i signed melo to a 5yr max deal in the offseason in my bulls association. i was using trade finder and seeing what teams would offer for melo. i was surprised by the heat offer.

                      melo & rose

                      for

                      lebron, miller & a 2nd rd pick

                      i was just surprised that they are offering lebron and no i didn't do the deal since i like the combo of rose and melo.
                      Only if you didn't lose Rose, I would do the trade and do a rose + lebron combo
                      Chicago Bulls 1996
                      Dallas Mavericks 2011
                      Boston Celtics 1986
                      2001 Lakers

                      Comment

                      • redsrule
                        All Star
                        • Apr 2010
                        • 9396

                        #1016
                        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                        Originally posted by LHSLax_D24
                        30-team Association:

                        Nate Robinson keeps complaining. He's getting 20+ MPG (as a Role Player), yet his morale is <25%. So, I just said screw it and benched him; he's no longer part of the 12-man rotation and has demanded a trade.

                        Since the Celtics are basically screwed with all the complainers on the bench, who can I trade Robinson for that would not complain for limited minutes.

                        BTW, I find this completely unrealistic because he chose to re-sign knowing he would get limited minutes.
                        Turn roles off then. I understand your aggravation with that.
                        Cincinnati Reds University of Kentucky Cincinnati Bengals
                        @GoReds1994

                        Comment

                        • thedukejr
                          Rookie
                          • Jan 2005
                          • 65

                          #1017
                          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                          Originally posted by parker987
                          Only if you didn't lose Rose, I would do the trade and do a rose + lebron combo
                          i thought the same thing but i guess i could try to work a 3 team trade and sub noah in the deal for rose if i decided to make that trade.

                          Comment

                          • thedukejr
                            Rookie
                            • Jan 2005
                            • 65

                            #1018
                            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                            Originally posted by LHSLax_D24
                            30-team Association:

                            Nate Robinson keeps complaining. He's getting 20+ MPG (as a Role Player), yet his morale is <25%. So, I just said screw it and benched him; he's no longer part of the 12-man rotation and has demanded a trade.

                            Since the Celtics are basically screwed with all the complainers on the bench, who can I trade Robinson for that would not complain for limited minutes.

                            BTW, I find this completely unrealistic because he chose to re-sign knowing he would get limited minutes.
                            i agree the player roles are un-realistic. people with the roles of role players/six man won't around 25-30 minutes a game so it make it hard to keep everyone happy.

                            Comment

                            • parker987
                              MVP
                              • Nov 2010
                              • 1034

                              #1019
                              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                              Originally posted by thedukejr
                              i thought the same thing but i guess i could try to work a 3 team trade and sub noah in the deal for rose if i decided to make that trade.
                              Try that, either put in Boozer or Noah at the trade spot for Rose, I personally prefer Noah as i like his rebounding skills and shot blocking.
                              Chicago Bulls 1996
                              Dallas Mavericks 2011
                              Boston Celtics 1986
                              2001 Lakers

                              Comment

                              • thedukejr
                                Rookie
                                • Jan 2005
                                • 65

                                #1020
                                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                                Originally posted by parker987
                                Try that, either put in Boozer or Noah at the trade spot for Rose, I personally prefer Noah as i like his rebounding skills and shot blocking.
                                i prefer noah too so ill work on a trade and post it on here if successful.

                                Comment

                                Working...