The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Freak123
    Pro
    • Sep 2010
    • 981

    #121
    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

    Works great bud. And yeah you're right about the playing time, with his potential only being a C-, he probably won't ever see playing time. So yeah it works out great, and you get rid of the chemistry killa in Hedo lol. Nice trade buddy.

    Comment

    • NDAlum
      ND
      • Jun 2010
      • 11453

      #122
      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

      I'm looking to get a draft pick in the 2011 draft.

      New York Knicks trade:
      SG Kelenna Azubuike (71)
      C Ronny Turiaf (66)

      San Antonio Spurs trade:
      '11 1st round pick (probably 20+)
      Fill ins

      I'm going to look at this when I get home tonight. Thoughts?
      SOS Madden League (PS4) | League Archives
      SOS Crew Bowl III & VIII Champs

      Atlanta Braves Fantasy Draft Franchise | Google Docs History
      NL East Champs 5x | WS Champion 1x (2020)

      Comment

      • NDAlum
        ND
        • Jun 2010
        • 11453

        #123
        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

        Originally posted by AgaliareptX
        Trade:

        Nuggets (me) trade:
        Kenyon Martin
        Ty Lawson
        2011 1st Round Pick
        2012 2nd Round Pick

        Mavs (CPU) trade:
        Dirk Nowitzki
        J.J. Barea

        I think if you take out the real-life loyalty factor that Mark Cuban/Mavs have with Dirk, this trade makes some sense. K-Mart has a giant expiring contract and still plays great defense and decent offense and Ty Lawson looks like a legit star in the making to replace Kidd when he's done.

        From the Nuggets side, they finally get a perennial all-star to pair up with Melo, and they can sort-of form a "Big 3" with Melo/Chauncey/Dirk. And J.J.'s not to shabby.

        Threw in a few picks to make it a little more fair as well.
        You do make an argument for it but it's just not happening. Lawson is the PG of the future for DEN and they are only going to get younger.

        So basically you're trading Lawson & cap room for Nowitzki? No way. Your 1st round pick will be mid-late 20s which isn't going to help them for the future.

        Only way it works is if you have a shot at the top pick where they can draft a stud rookie.

        In my opinion you rob the Mavs. I love Lawson but he's not enough to get the franchise player Nowitzki.

        Originally posted by bailey4mvp
        Ok i decided to run with the Bulls for my Asscoiation, i was thinking about this trade down the track.


        Bulls Send: Luol Deng, Taj Gibson/James Johnson, 2011, 2012 1st
        Pacers Send: Danny Granger, A.J. Price/Filler, 2012 2nd

        Reason behind it is that the Pacers have George at the 3 aswell and if Granger moves to SG then what becomes of Stephenson?

        It gives me a scoring SF but i give up Gibson, i was thinking of making it Johnson cause im not to keen on him but i guess its not fair if i don't inclue Gibson.
        #1 issue I have - the 1st round picks are going to be #24+.

        You get the Pacers franchise player for an average SF and backup bigs? Would you do that if you were Indiana?

        Originally posted by kenmasters06
        The trade I just made (I'm the Knicks):

        Warriors Trade:
        Stephen Curry
        Andris Biedrins

        Knicks Trade:
        Raymond Felton
        Gallo
        Anthony Randolph
        Curry is the face of their franchise now. Also the Knicks aren't giving up those people. I don't see this one working out.

        I'm the shooter down of all trades!
        SOS Madden League (PS4) | League Archives
        SOS Crew Bowl III & VIII Champs

        Atlanta Braves Fantasy Draft Franchise | Google Docs History
        NL East Champs 5x | WS Champion 1x (2020)

        Comment

        • kenmasters06
          Banned
          • Nov 2004
          • 182

          #124
          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

          Originally posted by JBH3
          The Official "Get over on the CPU" Thread

          -or-

          The Official "Make a trade for the sake of making a trade when it makes no sense" Thread

          ?

          Seriously? Curry....?

          Rating = *
          Yes Curry. He fits well with the system and it's no secret that the Knicks have always wanted him. Coupled with signing Carmelo in the offseason, it's definitely a trade that makes sense, unless you're an idiot like yourself.

          Comment

          • Buckeye
            MVP
            • Dec 2009
            • 2939

            #125
            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

            Trying to move Felton to make playing time for TD any ideas?
            \

            Comment

            • Chrisksaint
              $$$
              • Apr 2010
              • 19127

              #126
              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

              I just wanted to make a change, not my serious franchise cause i've lost all 10 games still trying to get used to the game this year.

              Trailblazers(CPU) receive:
              Emeka Okafor
              Marco Belinelli
              '11 2nd round draft pick

              Hornets(me) receive:
              Greg Oden
              Joel Pryzibilla(sp?)
              Saints, LSU, Seminoles, Pelicans, Marlins, Lightning

              Comment

              • Yeah...THAT Guy
                Once in a Lifetime Memory
                • Dec 2006
                • 17294

                #127
                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                Originally posted by NDAlum
                You do make an argument for it but it's just not happening. Lawson is the PG of the future for DEN and they are only going to get younger.

                So basically you're trading Lawson & cap room for Nowitzki? No way. Your 1st round pick will be mid-late 20s which isn't going to help them for the future.

                Only way it works is if you have a shot at the top pick where they can draft a stud rookie.

                In my opinion you rob the Mavs. I love Lawson but he's not enough to get the franchise player Nowitzki.



                #1 issue I have - the 1st round picks are going to be #24+.

                You get the Pacers franchise player for an average SF and backup bigs? Would you do that if you were Indiana?



                Curry is the face of their franchise now. Also the Knicks aren't giving up those people. I don't see this one working out.

                I'm the shooter down of all trades!
                I think the Pacers trade is fine. Deng isn't much worse than Granger and if they could get Taj Gibson and 2 1sts out of it too? I think the Pacers would accept that trade in real life.
                NFL: Bills
                NBA: Bucks
                MLB: Cubs
                NCAA: Syracuse
                Soccer: USMNT/DC United

                PSN: ButMyT-GunDont

                Comment

                • MizzouBravesFan
                  MVP
                  • Mar 2004
                  • 2489

                  #128
                  Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                  Just made these two deals in my Hawks Association...

                  Hawks get:
                  Jason Kidd

                  Suns get:
                  Jamal Crawford
                  2011 1st Round Draft Pick

                  and

                  Hawks get:
                  2011 1st Round Draft Pick

                  Thunder get:
                  Mike Bibby
                  2012 2nd Round Draft Pick

                  Signed Larry Hughes after making these two deals. I'm hoping Kidd can give me two good years and then I can take a run at CP3 and I was happy to get out from under Crawford and Bibby's contract. My CAP SG made Crawford expendable.
                  Last edited by MizzouBravesFan; 10-12-2010, 04:42 PM.
                  Patrick Mahomes > God

                  Comment

                  • Freak123
                    Pro
                    • Sep 2010
                    • 981

                    #129
                    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                    Originally posted by Yeah...THAT Guy
                    I think the Pacers trade is fine. Deng isn't much worse than Granger and if they could get Taj Gibson and 2 1sts out of it too? I think the Pacers would accept that trade in real life.
                    Granger is actually a lot better. He has averaged 25+ points and 23+ points in the last two seasons, Deng hasn't even come close to that. Granger is a very explosive SF while Deng is not. Granger is their franchise player as well, Larry Bird wants to get another superstar to play alongside Danny Granger, and when and if they do, they will be a very, very good team. Pacers are getting there with good young pieces in aforementioned Danny Granger, Roy Hibbert, Darren Collison, Paul George, Lance Stephenson, and Tyler Hansborough. So trading Granger doesn't make a whole lot of sense. He can still do the trade if he wants, it's his choice, we're just commenting on the realism of it. If he doesn't care then kudos to him, I always feel too guilty about making lopsided trades lol.

                    Comment

                    • NDAlum
                      ND
                      • Jun 2010
                      • 11453

                      #130
                      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                      Yea to me Deng isn't close to Granger. Granger is the #1 option All-Star type of player.
                      SOS Madden League (PS4) | League Archives
                      SOS Crew Bowl III & VIII Champs

                      Atlanta Braves Fantasy Draft Franchise | Google Docs History
                      NL East Champs 5x | WS Champion 1x (2020)

                      Comment

                      • bailey4mvp
                        MVP
                        • Mar 2005
                        • 1593

                        #131
                        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                        Originally posted by Freak123
                        Granger is actually a lot better. He has averaged 25+ points and 23+ points in the last two seasons, Deng hasn't even come close to that. Granger is a very explosive SF while Deng is not. Granger is their franchise player as well, Larry Bird wants to get another superstar to play alongside Danny Granger, and when and if they do, they will be a very, very good team. Pacers are getting there with good young pieces in aforementioned Danny Granger, Roy Hibbert, Darren Collison, Paul George, Lance Stephenson, and Tyler Hansborough. So trading Granger doesn't make a whole lot of sense. He can still do the trade if he wants, it's his choice, we're just commenting on the realism of it. If he doesn't care then kudos to him, I always feel too guilty about making lopsided trades lol.
                        I decided to not go that way.

                        I am looking for a SF that can score, i can't get going with Deng.

                        Any ideas?

                        Comment

                        • JoelMali
                          Rookie
                          • Oct 2010
                          • 3

                          #132
                          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                          Hey guys, i play the hornets and want to make a deal for igouadala.

                          Hornets give: Ariza, Stojakovic (1y exp, 15mio), West/Okafor, 1nd Round Pick 2011
                          76ers give: Igouadala, Brand, Kapono

                          Any Opinions? 76ers get a good backup for the 3 spot in Ariza and get rid of Brands bad contract. Plus West or Okafor? Im not sure, what fits better... you think this deal make sense and is fair?

                          Comment

                          • canes21
                            Hall Of Fame
                            • Sep 2008
                            • 22930

                            #133
                            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                            The Bulls just offered me a trade and I maneuvered around and this is what they'll accept at the most. Should I take this?

                            Pistons Trade Away
                            Ben Gordon
                            Tony Allen
                            '11 1st Round Pick(Grizzlies)

                            Bulls Trade Away
                            Luol Deng
                            Ronnie Brewer
                            '11 1st Round Pick(Bulls)
                            '11 2nd Round Pick(Bulls)
                            “No one is more hated than he who speaks the truth.”


                            ― Plato

                            Comment

                            • Yeah...THAT Guy
                              Once in a Lifetime Memory
                              • Dec 2006
                              • 17294

                              #134
                              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                              Originally posted by Freak123
                              Granger is actually a lot better. He has averaged 25+ points and 23+ points in the last two seasons, Deng hasn't even come close to that. Granger is a very explosive SF while Deng is not. Granger is their franchise player as well, Larry Bird wants to get another superstar to play alongside Danny Granger, and when and if they do, they will be a very, very good team. Pacers are getting there with good young pieces in aforementioned Danny Granger, Roy Hibbert, Darren Collison, Paul George, Lance Stephenson, and Tyler Hansborough. So trading Granger doesn't make a whole lot of sense. He can still do the trade if he wants, it's his choice, we're just commenting on the realism of it. If he doesn't care then kudos to him, I always feel too guilty about making lopsided trades lol.
                              Eh I don't see Granger as a guy you can build a team around. He's a great shooter, doesn't do much rebounding or playmaking. From the little I've seen he doesn't play much defense and it seems like he does all his damage catching and shooting like Ray Allen or Rip Hamilton (based on the fact that like 60% of his jumpers are assisted). Deng is a very solid mid range shooter and he's a very solid defender. He doesn't shoot the 3 often, but he isn't terrible anymore at it like he used to be. I really don't think the dropoff is THAT much. And throw in 2 1st round picks and a prospect in Taj Gibson? I'll take it.
                              NFL: Bills
                              NBA: Bucks
                              MLB: Cubs
                              NCAA: Syracuse
                              Soccer: USMNT/DC United

                              PSN: ButMyT-GunDont

                              Comment

                              • willIam9387
                                Pro
                                • Jun 2010
                                • 640

                                #135
                                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                                Originally posted by Yeah...THAT Guy
                                Eh I don't see Granger as a guy you can build a team around. He's a great shooter, doesn't do much rebounding or playmaking. From the little I've seen he doesn't play much defense and it seems like he does all his damage catching and shooting like Ray Allen or Rip Hamilton (based on the fact that like 60% of his jumpers are assisted). Deng is a very solid mid range shooter and he's a very solid defender. He doesn't shoot the 3 often, but he isn't terrible anymore at it like he used to be. I really don't think the dropoff is THAT much. And throw in 2 1st round picks and a prospect in Taj Gibson? I'll take it.
                                Yeah I agree Granger is limited in what he can do offensively as he gets most of his points from working off the ball, running off picks, and then hitting an open jumper. And your right his defense is suspect, so in my mind he's not really a build around type player. He's most effective in helping a team like the bulls, who could use a shooter such as him as they have all the other required pieces in place.

                                And it's not like the Pacers are getting ripped off in this trade either as they are getting deng, who like you mentioned can knock down a mid range shot, and is really a solid defender. Taj Gibson is an athletic big who can shoot a little and if developed could potentially be a starter and a key piece for the Pacers in the future. Johnson is athletic, can defend, so again your getting a serviceable player in return. The two first round picks although probably late in the first round again are pretty good assets the Pacers could package to move up in the first round and possibly get a star player for the future who can carry a team offensively. I know Larry Bird is high on Granger, but given a different gm for the Pacers, I could see them going in this direction.

                                Comment

                                Working...