Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Options?

[seanhazz1]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Since we have our answer for now, continued the criticism on the topic appears short sighted IMO. If we the community charted the continued progress of LIVE series, and the more critical reviews along the way, we can clearly see the direction the game is going, the community suggestions added, the growing confidence of the new team, and the overall progress of the series toward its continued resurgence.

In contrast, the competition gets unwavering support in Live's forum (somewhat warranted) even though it's feature modes are generally unplayable for two months after it's annual release(forum complaints). We still buy.

Strong moment-to-moment game play is their obvious priority(as it should IMO), and keeps the Live series moving forward positively, maybe not fast enough for some, but hopefully and eventually to the re-addition and continued development of our missing and beloved features, to include editing.

The Demo will tell a true tale when it drops....at about $0.18 per day per person per copy.

[wrestlinggod1]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

I thought we weren't able to edit their ratings. We won't be able to put players on different teams?

[DIRK41NOWITZKI]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Possible Create a Player in the game?

Sent from my SM-G920W8 using Tapatalk

[Playmakers]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

I thought we weren't able to edit their ratings. We won't be able to put players on different teams?

You won't be able to do any of that without the ability to edit

Here's the sad thing when the season is over and you get those top college players going into the NBA we can't do a damn thing about it because we can't edit/creat draft classes

I'm not sure about anyone else but fake rookies kill the immersion factor for me in sports games

Not having the ability to even create classic rosters and players kills the replay value of the game.

Not to mention in franchise mode you can't play multiple games since they only allow you to control one team

I've always hated not being able to play the best games with any teams in the league and not being allowed to play other playoff games

Live used to have all these things 15 years ago

[3ShowTime2]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Roster editing is a nice extra but why shouldnt I buy NBA Live if the game is fun on its own?

If its decent ill buy NBA Live just to support competition...

[wrestlinggod1]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Hopefully they release one hell of a demo

[Dekkfly]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

My question for EA is how often will they update rosters? Like accessories and player moves? We shouldnt have to wait a week after a player gets traded. And who manages the rosters so we can send them suggestions.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Operation Sports mobile app

[Tonyattia]

Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Options?

I guess there is a disconnect from the community and the devs on just how much time it would take to add roster/player editing and a sharing feature. Since we've had these options in previous games dating back 3 generations of systems, we just can't fathom that it's a difficult thing to put in. But if it's something that would significantly affect gameplay or mode development, I'd rather continue to wait. I remember Sean O'Brien said in an interview that their code was so messed up that it would take a lot of effort to add it. Hopefully the roster editors pay attention to the ratings and accessory threads we make and update consistently.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Dekkfly]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Swaggyplino and dboygamerz had a interview with Projectleet a dev. He said it was just him managing rosters last year, but said they would have multiple people working on rosters.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Operation Sports mobile app

[sarlndr]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

No editing means no day one, full price buy from me. If this is true. It's just crazy & blows my mind. Come on man.

I'm an old head. I like simplicity. I like playing franchise and creating a team through the draft and via trades. Things considered basic in most sports games. I want to go on a rant but it will do absolutely no good. EA has once again, let me down.

The only positive is that Live 18 will continue it's annual tradition and be on sale for $20-$25 when Black Friday rolls around. I'll scoop it up then.

Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk

[swac07]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Man all I gotta say is God forbid anything happens on EA's side to where they can't change player ratings or update teams with trades or injuries. You will be stuck with a game that doesn't mirror whats going on in the nba and guess what??? you can't do ANYTHING about it because there aren't any editing features on the users end.Everybody says"its no biggie" until they experience it themselves.Just a little something to think about..hopefully they can get this feature back in soon as possible

[23]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Man all I gotta say is God forbid anything happens on EA's side to where they can't change player ratings or update teams with trades or injuries. You will be stuck with a game that doesn't mirror whats going on in the nba and guess what??? you can't do ANYTHING about it because there aren't any editing features on the users end.Everybody says"its no biggie" until they experience it themselves.Just a little something to think about..hopefully they can get this feature back in soon as possible

You mean like Live 16?

yeah.........

[skinnybonez]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Was Live 10 the last player edit?

[wrestlinggod1]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Oh man, that's gonna really suck for people with no online access

[cthurt]

Re: Will You buy NBA Live 18 IF it doesnt have Roster Editing(Editing Players) Option

Was Live 10 the last player edit?

I believe so, and wasn't that the year Mike Wang joined the Live team just for that one year, sad the last good Live had some 2k influence.