Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RonnieG
    Banned
    • Sep 2010
    • 221

    #61
    Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

    Originally posted by capp34
    1. Magic Johnson
    2. Isiah Thomas
    3. John Stockton
    4. Gary Payton
    5. Jason Kidd
    This is pretty close to my list as well.

    Comment

    • Jeffx
      MVP
      • Jan 2007
      • 3045

      #62
      Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

      Originally posted by The15thunter
      magic.
      oscar (i'm finally giving in and considering him a pg)
      isiah.
      john.
      frazier.
      I like this list best.

      Magic was plain sick. Dude was a freak of nature, playing the PG position at 6'9, 225. That was unheard of back then.

      Comment

      • st0rmb11
        All Star
        • Nov 2008
        • 5167

        #63
        Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

        Originally posted by Jeffx
        I like this list best.

        Magic was plain sick. Dude was a freak of nature, playing the PG position at 6'9, 225. That was unheard of back then.
        back then? that's unheard of now

        Cincinnati Reds

        UNC Tarheels

        Twitter: @st0rmb11

        PS4

        Comment

        • The15thunter
          MVP
          • Mar 2003
          • 1639

          #64
          Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

          Originally posted by st0rmb11
          back then? that's unheard of now
          well, to be fair, we've heard of it now, it just hasn't happened again, .
          xbox gt - bmorerep87

          Comment

          • Chrisksaint
            $$$
            • Apr 2010
            • 19127

            #65
            Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

            Originally posted by Subversion
            Are these lists put up by kids born in the mid 90s or what...

            Top 5 all-time -

            Pete Maravich
            Gary Payton
            John Stockton
            Magic Johnson
            Isaiah Thomas


            This list is based on scoring ability and passing ability. These point guards could take over games, score 40+ or dish out insane amounts of assists. They had low turnover/assist ratios and had probably the highest basketball IQ's known.
            Pretty much my favorite list here.

            It's a shame injuries shortened Pete's career
            Saints, LSU, Seminoles, Pelicans, Marlins, Lightning

            Comment

            • CWSapp757
              SimWorld Draft Class Guru
              • Aug 2008
              • 4651

              #66
              Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

              1) Rajon Rondo
              2) Number 9 for the celtics
              3) The dude selected 21st overall in 2006
              4) The player with the highest overall on the celtics on NBA 2K11
              5) The starting point guard for U of Kentucky in 2005

              What you think about my list Paris????

              J/K. I'm not knocking you my man, but it really seems like you genuinely can't stand Rondo. I just find it humerous how hard you be going to make your argument that he's not a top 10 point guard. But like I said I'm not knocking you. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

              All jokes aside though, I am only 26 so I will only list the pgs that I have seen play.

              1) Magic
              2) Isiah T.
              3) J. Stockton
              4) J. Kidd
              5) Nash
              SimWorld NBA 2K19 Fictional Draft Classes
              YOUTUBE / FACEBOOK / TWITCH / SOUNDCLOUD
              TWITTER & INSTAGRAM: @SimWorld4k
              #SimWorldSports #SeeTheGameBeTheGame

              Comment

              • Jukeman
                Showtime
                • Aug 2005
                • 10955

                #67
                Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                Originally posted by CWSapp757
                1) Rajon Rondo
                2) Number 9 for the celtics
                3) The dude selected 21st overall in 2006
                4) The player with the highest overall on the celtics on NBA 2K11
                5) The starting point guard for U of Kentucky in 2005

                What you think about my list Paris????

                J/K. I'm not knocking you my man, but it really seems like you genuinely can't stand Rondo. I just find it humerous how hard you be going to make your argument that he's not a top 10 point guard. But like I said I'm not knocking you. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

                All jokes aside though, I am only 26 so I will only list the pgs that I have seen play.

                1) Magic
                2) Isiah T.
                3) J. Stockton
                4) J. Kidd
                5) Nash


                9 characters

                Comment

                • ParisB
                  MVP
                  • Jan 2010
                  • 1699

                  #68
                  Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                  Originally posted by CWSapp757
                  1) Rajon Rondo
                  2) Number 9 for the celtics
                  3) The dude selected 21st overall in 2006
                  4) The player with the highest overall on the celtics on NBA 2K11
                  5) The starting point guard for U of Kentucky in 2005

                  What you think about my list Paris????

                  J/K. I'm not knocking you my man, but it really seems like you genuinely can't stand Rondo. I just find it humerous how hard you be going to make your argument that he's not a top 10 point guard. But like I said I'm not knocking you. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

                  All jokes aside though, I am only 26 so I will only list the pgs that I have seen play.

                  1) Magic
                  2) Isiah T.
                  3) J. Stockton
                  4) J. Kidd
                  5) Nash
                  I like Rondo. He's just overrated. That is all

                  Comment

                  • AlexBrady
                    MVP
                    • Jul 2008
                    • 3341

                    #69
                    Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                    I love subjective lists.

                    1. Magic Johnson
                    2. Oscar Robertson
                    3. Jerry West
                    4. John Stockton
                    5. Walt Frazier

                    Comment

                    • The15thunter
                      MVP
                      • Mar 2003
                      • 1639

                      #70
                      Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                      Originally posted by AlexBrady
                      I love subjective lists.

                      1. Magic Johnson
                      2. Oscar Robertson
                      3. Jerry West
                      4. John Stockton
                      5. Walt Frazier
                      what makes you put west at point?
                      xbox gt - bmorerep87

                      Comment

                      • AlexBrady
                        MVP
                        • Jul 2008
                        • 3341

                        #71
                        Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                        Originally posted by The15thunter
                        what makes you put west at point?
                        Sharman always said he was the point guard. Plus, the broadcasts made it known that he was a point guard.

                        Comment

                        • The15thunter
                          MVP
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 1639

                          #72
                          Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                          Originally posted by AlexBrady
                          Sharman always said he was the point guard. Plus, the broadcasts made it known that he was a point guard.
                          hmmm, i have a tough time with him. i view him like iverson, in that he wasn't big (6'2", 175 pounds), but neither were most guards are that time. i know he played forward in college and transitioned to guard in the pros. my sense is that he was named point primarily because he handled the ball most, but was also a shooting guard because he was their scorer when elgin was gone and for much of his career. to me, he's more of a combo guard in the wade or iverson ilk. able to do both, but more scorer/shooting guard than point.
                          xbox gt - bmorerep87

                          Comment

                          • daflyboys
                            Banned
                            • May 2003
                            • 18238

                            #73
                            Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                            No particular order:

                            1. Frazier
                            2. Stockton
                            3. Tiny Archibald
                            4. Big "O"
                            5a. West
                            5b. Maravich (though by later standards was probably consider a SG)

                            I never considered Magic a point guard. I'm not saying he couldn't handle the ball, but he was probably analagous to baseball's utility player for the Lakers, clearly not something just anyone could do.
                            Last edited by daflyboys; 01-05-2011, 04:40 PM.

                            Comment

                            • AlexBrady
                              MVP
                              • Jul 2008
                              • 3341

                              #74
                              Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                              Originally posted by The15thunter
                              hmmm, i have a tough time with him. i view him like iverson, in that he wasn't big (6'2", 175 pounds), but neither were most guards are that time. i know he played forward in college and transitioned to guard in the pros. my sense is that he was named point primarily because he handled the ball most, but was also a shooting guard because he was their scorer when elgin was gone and for much of his career. to me, he's more of a combo guard in the wade or iverson ilk. able to do both, but more scorer/shooting guard than point.
                              For sure. West could be categorized as either a point guard or shooting guard. I like to call him a point because he often carried the ball across the timeline and made the intial pass to get the Lakers into their sets. You're right, his number was called often in the clutch.

                              Comment

                              • 44drob
                                Pro
                                • Oct 2010
                                • 848

                                #75
                                Re: Top 5 Point Guards of All Time

                                1. Magic Johnson
                                2.Issaiah Thomas
                                3. Jason Kidd
                                4. Steve Nash
                                5.John Stockton
                                NFL: RAIDERS
                                NBA:LAKERS

                                GLORYERACLOTHING.COM
                                TRU2THA GAME

                                Comment

                                Working...