Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mattanite
    MVP
    • Sep 2015
    • 1716

    #46
    Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

    Originally posted by F17
    Hi mate, sorry, I haven't paid too much mind to this since CFMs got nuked and the drive for the game died. I'll have a look and see what I can find that doesn't work
    It really was an epic way to soulsuck the energy right out of you. Felt for all leagues (solos and online), they all take a lot of effort. Especially if you've done multiple scouting tool sheets for hours and hours.

    Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
    The State of Madden Franchise
    Scouting Tool
    Draft Class Strength Generator
    Franchise Tips

    Comment

    • bwanafulana
      Rookie
      • Dec 2021
      • 21

      #47
      Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

      I see a version 4 just came out. Is that good to go or are you doing more with it?

      Comment

      • Mattanite
        MVP
        • Sep 2015
        • 1716

        #48
        Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

        Originally posted by bwanafulana
        I see a version 4 just came out. Is that good to go or are you doing more with it?
        I'll leave F17 to answer that.

        Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
        The State of Madden Franchise
        Scouting Tool
        Draft Class Strength Generator
        Franchise Tips

        Comment

        • midnite7
          Rookie
          • Feb 2023
          • 5

          #49
          Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

          Thanks F17, appreciate it bro! About to use the tool in my CFM, was wondering what that column was meant to function as

          Comment

          • recklessfear
            Just started!
            • Jun 2023
            • 2

            #50
            Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

            Hello, thanks so much for making this, it has been an awesome tool for our online CFM.


            I have some questions about the CB and HB position not filling correctly like other positions.


            I noticed the Team Scout Grade, and PhysScore always show 0 or 0.0.



            Am I doing something incorrectly, and if so, please advise how to resolve.


            Thank you so much for the help, and again thank you SO MUCH for making this amazing tool.

            Comment

            • Mattanite
              MVP
              • Sep 2015
              • 1716

              #51
              Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

              Originally posted by recklessfear
              Hello, thanks so much for making this, it has been an awesome tool for our online CFM.


              I have some questions about the CB and HB position not filling correctly like other positions.


              I noticed the Team Scout Grade, and PhysScore always show 0 or 0.0.



              Am I doing something incorrectly, and if so, please advise how to resolve.


              Thank you so much for the help, and again thank you SO MUCH for making this amazing tool.
              Does this work in the m23 light version? That will help is know where it's going wrong between additions to this sheet.

              Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
              The State of Madden Franchise
              Scouting Tool
              Draft Class Strength Generator
              Franchise Tips

              Comment

              • recklessfear
                Just started!
                • Jun 2023
                • 2

                #52
                Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                Originally posted by Mattanite
                Does this work in the m23 light version? That will help is know where it's going wrong between additions to this sheet.

                Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk



                thanks for reaching out so fast!!


                I am unsure what you mean by "m23 light version."

                I downloaded both the v4 version of the tool in the original post and tried to input the same values for that prospect and received the same behavior.


                I have resolved this, for now, by removing Archetype under all CBs, then the outstanding cells populate.

                Am I maybe using the wrong position group or something?


                thank

                Comment

                • Mattanite
                  MVP
                  • Sep 2015
                  • 1716

                  #53
                  Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                  Originally posted by recklessfear
                  thanks for reaching out so fast!!


                  I am unsure what you mean by "m23 light version."

                  I downloaded both the v4 version of the tool in the original post and tried to input the same values for that prospect and received the same behavior.


                  I have resolved this, for now, by removing Archetype under all CBs, then the outstanding cells populate.

                  Am I maybe using the wrong position group or something?


                  thank
                  I've just seen again it's not the "geodude scoutscore" which shows to be indexing fine, it's with the F17 Scoutscore version (he altered the formula to weight differently), but physcore isn't displaying either - I think that changed between m23 original and this version too. I'll have to leave him to check, sorry.

                  Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
                  The State of Madden Franchise
                  Scouting Tool
                  Draft Class Strength Generator
                  Franchise Tips

                  Comment

                  • Mattanite
                    MVP
                    • Sep 2015
                    • 1716

                    #54
                    Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                    Are all the combine or pre combine cells filled from the picklist?

                    Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
                    The State of Madden Franchise
                    Scouting Tool
                    Draft Class Strength Generator
                    Franchise Tips

                    Comment

                    • zieiz
                      Just started!
                      • Apr 2019
                      • 1

                      #55
                      Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                      Been using the tool and absolutely love it!

                      Yet, I seem to be running into a problem and not sure if it's my user mistake or what, would appreciate any help!

                      I have attached a screenshot of the first few players from my draft class to show the issue. For the most part, the formulas are working and update as they should except Team Scout Grade, Geodude ScoutScore, ScoutScore JJ Value, and Value at Pick for example.

                      Is it because I haven't filled out the entire draft class yet or did I accidentally change a formula?
                      Attached Files

                      Comment

                      • F17
                        Rookie
                        • Aug 2017
                        • 113

                        #56
                        Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                        Originally posted by zieiz
                        Been using the tool and absolutely love it!

                        Yet, I seem to be running into a problem and not sure if it's my user mistake or what, would appreciate any help!

                        I have attached a screenshot of the first few players from my draft class to show the issue. For the most part, the formulas are working and update as they should except Team Scout Grade, Geodude ScoutScore, ScoutScore JJ Value, and Value at Pick for example.

                        Is it because I haven't filled out the entire draft class yet or did I accidentally change a formula?

                        That's my fault cause I was new at this. I am looking to release a new version in the next couple of weeks that is all sorted and has a far expanded scouting report system. The reason you're getting those errors is because I missed a $ somewhere and also forgot to remove a link to a second sheet, so it all went bonkers

                        Comment

                        • allthemalarkey31
                          Rookie
                          • Jul 2013
                          • 6

                          #57
                          Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                          Does this tool work for Madden 24 too? Has anyone tried?

                          Comment

                          • Mattanite
                            MVP
                            • Sep 2015
                            • 1716

                            #58
                            Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                            Originally posted by allthemalarkey31
                            Does this tool work for Madden 24 too? Has anyone tried?
                            In terms of scouting systems, this tool and the other updated m22to23 tool work. I believe F17 might have a faulty formula and has a new expanded m24 version coming out soon.

                            Sent from my H3113 using Tapatalk
                            The State of Madden Franchise
                            Scouting Tool
                            Draft Class Strength Generator
                            Franchise Tips

                            Comment

                            • F17
                              Rookie
                              • Aug 2017
                              • 113

                              #59
                              Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                              Not as well as I'd like. But it's been rebuilt. Give me a few weeks and I'll have a new tool out

                              Comment

                              • Bhrodhnos
                                Just started!
                                • Mar 2020
                                • 2

                                #60
                                Re: Fraser (& Mattanite) Madden 23 Scouting Tool

                                I've recently started up a new Franchise, but I've been running into an issue wherein, for some reason, the Geodude score and rank don't seem to be computing or displaying. I'm sure I'm just doing something wrong, but I don't know what. This issue seems to be the case right when I open the tool up from the download link.
                                Attached Files

                                Comment

                                Working...