Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

[tommycoa]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

PS5, 75m preseason default roster with no manipulation.

Cpu vs cpu is still playing fine for the most part. Ints are decent and more realistic. Fumbles on the other hand need work. 4 games yesterday, had 6 total with 4 lost, and 8 today with 7 lost. 1 game had 3 drives with 3 fumbles. I'm seeing 1 to 2 ints a game. That's realistic to me. The nfl avg now is over/under 1.

Gameplay is so smooth, even more defensive and so nice. 7 games after patch and it is so nice to watch now. Just need to tone fumbles down. It's game fumbles not team fumbles. Good runners run, scramblers move, speedy DE gets pressure, elite dbs shutdown sides of field. Receivers that get hit while catching is 50/50 if they hold on. I've never seen such great gameplay.

Try bumping fumble up to 40. If that doesn’t work, try 41. You want to keep it slightly below tackle if possible., so you still get 1-2 fumbles a game. The past 2 seasons has seen a rise in wrs and backs fumbling because defenses are punching the ball out more.

[BungerHenry]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

In CPU v CPU games, I pause the game before kickoff, Super Sim Slow, and go to End of Game. My understanding is that Pro gives the User a slight advantage and All Pro makes both teams equivalent to their ratings. So, if the CPU v CPU game is played at Pro level, doesn’t that give my team an unfair advantage? Or is that setting ignored during Super Sim?

[tommycoa]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

In CPU v CPU games, I pause the game before kickoff, Super Sim Slow, and go to End of Game. My understanding is that Pro gives the User a slight advantage and All Pro makes both teams equivalent to their ratings. So, if the CPU v CPU game is played at Pro level, doesn’t that give my team an unfair advantage? Or is that setting ignored during Super Sim?

skill level doesnt have that effect with cpu vs cpu. Pro plays way better. Players play more to ratings and there’s more animations.

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

In CPU v CPU games, I pause the game before kickoff, Super Sim Slow, and go to End of Game. My understanding is that Pro gives the User a slight advantage and All Pro makes both teams equivalent to their ratings. So, if the CPU v CPU game is played at Pro level, doesn’t that give my team an unfair advantage? Or is that setting ignored during Super Sim?

As Tommie stated you can throw that stuff out the window when playing CPU vs CPU because USER has no IMPACT on the outcome or ratings of the players.

Now if your playing USER vs CPU games then yes on Pro the USER gets the ratings advantage over the CPU. But it's just the opposite if you were playing on AM where the CPU gets the advantage with a ratings boost.

I think the bigger issue is EA probably doesn't even know themselves the actual effects of their own sliders because they been coding old code over top of old code for years and refuse to tear it down and rebuild fresh.

[benton32]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

My only wonder at times.... when u see user vs cpu sliders and usually the user ones are lower then the cpu so its more challenging especially on PRO, i assume thats for the people controlling all the players, QB, etc etc, Defenders, but i like to sometimes do coach mode, so then when i see user vs cpu sliders im like well on coach mode i hope it doesnt make my team worse, say if i were to use qb acc at like 5-10 but the cpu is around 40-45-50 but im doing coach mode and im not controlling the guys i dont wanna make my team worse, so usually in coach mode for user ill have the sliders maybe 5-10 lower then the cpu sliders, but idk, i assume when people post user sliders its for the ones who control the players...

[forme95]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

PS5, cpu vs cpu.
Noticing something with turnovers in my CFM. I cant get my secondary to get picks. They just bobble and drop everything. However (more so w/win turnover battle) fumbles increase. Watson will throw a int about once a game. Ok, hes still 2 or 3 to 1. However it seems my team causes fumbles left and right, but cant hold on to a int. Through 6 weeks, 1 Int and 7 FF 5 recovered. I have sliders at, Int 10 and fumbles 40.

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

PS5, cpu vs cpu.
Noticing something with turnovers in my CFM. I cant get my secondary to get picks. They just bobble and drop everything. However (more so w/win turnover battle) fumbles increase. Watson will throw a int about once a game. Ok, hes still 2 or 3 to 1. However it seems my team causes fumbles left and right, but cant hold on to a int. Through 6 weeks, 1 Int and 7 FF 5 recovered. I have sliders at, Int 10 and fumbles 40.

I need to go back through the base rosters by EA again to determine some values for CPU vs CPU gameplay

I'll get to testing this upcoming week

But for now, if everyone can use 40 Fumble vs 40 Tackle and then set INT to 24.

Base setting was originally at 38 Fumble vs 42 Tackle and INT was at 10

Play about 2-3 games with those settings if you get a chance until I observe gameplay this week.

Hope everyone enjoys their NFL Sunday have a great day

[Lil Worm]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

I need to go back through the base rosters by EA again to determine some values for CPU vs CPU gameplay

I'll get to testing this upcoming week

But for now, if everyone can use 40 Fumble vs 40 Tackle and then set INT to 24.

Base setting was originally at 38 Fumble vs 42 Tackle and INT was at 10

Play about 2-3 games with those settings if you get a chance until I observe gameplay this week.

Hope everyone enjoys their NFL Sunday have a great day

I will make these changes this evening!!!

I actually missed the playoffs with my Panthers in a close playoff battle in my 2026 season cpu vs cpu, and damn it man it felt so good!!! I play more cpu vs cpu now than user and love it!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[BungerHenry]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

Is there a post somewhere on how to set up gameplan plays before CPU v CPU games? And, on the menu where you choose which playbook you're going to use right before each game, if you set it to a custom playbook or another team's playbook, and then you start the game and go to Super Sim Slow, will the CPU use the playbook you chose, or does it go back to the default playbook of your team?

[trusaleen1]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

I need to go back through the base rosters by EA again to determine some values for CPU vs CPU gameplay

I'll get to testing this upcoming week

But for now, if everyone can use 40 Fumble vs 40 Tackle and then set INT to 24.

Base setting was originally at 38 Fumble vs 42 Tackle and INT was at 10

Play about 2-3 games with those settings if you get a chance until I observe gameplay this week.

Hope everyone enjoys their NFL Sunday have a great day

I've played or watched every madden since Apple II E days. I can say that after these adjustments with CPU v. CPU, this is the best game play I've seen in over a decade if not longer. Let's hope EA doesn't mess this up with a patch.

[Teleo]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

Playmakers -

Hope all is well - I have a question:

Do you still have your QBA chart from Madden 11? I googled this and I received an error when clicking on the link - I googled who’snext as well and that link doesn’t work either - This was an INCREDIBLE chart for differentiating between talent at the QB position

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

Playmakers -

Hope all is well - I have a question:

Do you still have your QBA chart from Madden 11? I googled this and I received an error when clicking on the link - I googled who’snext as well and that link doesn’t work either - This was an INCREDIBLE chart for differentiating between talent at the QB position

Yeah, I remember that chart from like Madden 11

I've only used it that one year

It was awesome to help separate the QB's

Guys like Brady and Manning would be in the high 90's on the Slider and then lower rated guys would be in the like 60's on the slider.

I think I used that for All Pro Level though

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

I've played or watched every madden since Apple II E days. I can say that after these adjustments with CPU v. CPU, this is the best game play I've seen in over a decade if not longer. Let's hope EA doesn't mess this up with a patch.

Thanks for the feedback

I'm assuming your using the Fumble and Tackle slider both at 40 with the INT slider at 24?

I still have yet to play or test Madden in over a week

But it's good to hear that the gameplay is no longer frustrating for most of you all.

[JasonZimmerman]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

here you go JasonZimmerman

Awesome! Thanks PM!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Teleo]

Re: Playmakers Madden 23 Pro Level (Classic Passing) User vs CPU & CPU vs CPU Sliders

Yeah, I remember that chart from like Madden 11

I've only used it that one year

It was awesome to help separate the QB's

Guys like Brady and Manning would be in the high 90's on the Slider and then lower rated guys would be in the like 60's on the slider.

I think I used that for All Pro Level though

Thank you but do you happen to have the chart still?