Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • GTheorenHobbes
    Banned
    • Jul 2002
    • 2572

    #136
    Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

    Originally posted by odbman
    I hope you understand you can find an attorney to take any case to court in this country.
    Actually...that's not true. There are rules that allow attorneys to be sanctioned for filing frivolous litigation. And we know this case is not frivolous, since it's already passed the motion to dismiss stage and is heading towards trial.

    Comment

    • SoxFan01605
      All Star
      • Jan 2008
      • 7982

      #137
      Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

      Originally posted by odbman
      I hope you understand you can find an attorney to take any case to court in this country.Next point there are courts in this country pro business and others anti business.Even if EA loses it will be appealed chances our this case won't even get to the Supreme Court till about the time EA and the NFL exclusive rights are up.2013.
      Well, there are rules to govern this and, to be fair, this doesn't really apply here anyway. The issues already been reviewed by a judge (a tad more discerning than your average lawyer...lol) and deemed worthy of at least looking onto further. I'm not saying I agree, but that's the call the judge made when looking at both side's claims. Also, hanging something up in court doesn't prove/disprove validity...only the strength of the legal teams involved to a large extent.

      I do agree that it's a case that EA is likely to win, and don't agree with where it focuses on culpability or reasoning, but I also don't agree with the notion that it's completely baseless. It comes down to perspective, who argues their's better, and how the ruling body interprets the applicable laws. It's up for grabs to an extent if the claimant can pursue it to the end. I just don't think he (they) can or will.
      Last edited by SoxFan01605; 09-15-2009, 05:04 PM.

      Comment

      • GTheorenHobbes
        Banned
        • Jul 2002
        • 2572

        #138
        Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

        Originally posted by odbman
        Even if EA loses it will be appealed chances our this case won't even get to the Supreme Court till about the time EA and the NFL exclusive rights are up.2013.
        What happens if EA gets socked with a multi-million dollar judgment? Yes, it would be appealed, but it's doubtful that the exclusive license would continue (adding to plaintiffs' damages) while the matter played out through appeal. That's not even taking into account how the NFL would feel about its name being associated with the antitrust judgment leveled against EA.

        Comment

        • ODogg
          Hall Of Fame
          • Feb 2003
          • 37953

          #139
          Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

          This is baseless. NFL, NCAA, etc can sell their rights to whoever they want. FAIL.
          Streaming PC & PS5 games, join me most nights after 6:00pm ET on TwitchTV https://www.twitch.tv/shaunh20
          or Tiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@shaunh741

          Comment

          • GTheorenHobbes
            Banned
            • Jul 2002
            • 2572

            #140
            Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

            Originally posted by ODogg
            This is baseless. NFL, NCAA, etc can sell their rights to whoever they want. FAIL.
            Ultimately, you may or may not be right. Since you didn't include any analysis, I can't really form an opinion on your logic. Personally, I'm just glad the Pecover judge didn't share your opinion when ruling on EA's motion to dismiss.

            Comment

            • odbman
              Rookie
              • Aug 2003
              • 145

              #141
              Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

              Originally posted by GTheorenHobbes
              What happens if EA gets socked with a multi-million dollar judgment? Yes, it would be appealed, but it's doubtful that the exclusive license would continue (adding to plaintiffs' damages) while the matter played out through appeal. That's not even taking into account how the NFL would feel about its name being associated with the antitrust judgment leveled against EA.
              No payouts till resolved only if they get fined and then they still can appeal that.They can appeal in a more pro friendly state and get a reversal.

              Comment

              • capn_razzamataz
                Rookie
                • Sep 2005
                • 402

                #142
                Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                Originally posted by ODogg
                This is baseless. NFL, NCAA, etc can sell their rights to whoever they want. FAIL.
                They can indeed sell their rights to whoever they want. There's no denying that.

                BUT...

                The question is whether or not EA cornered the football video game market by being the only company to sell a licensed product.
                Last edited by capn_razzamataz; 09-15-2009, 05:17 PM.

                Comment

                • Bump101
                  Rookie
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 183

                  #143
                  Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                  Originally posted by GTheorenHobbes
                  Actually...that's not true. There are rules that allow attorneys to be sanctioned for filing frivolous litigation. And we know this case is not frivolous, since it's already passed the motion to dismiss stage and is heading towards trial.
                  My thoughts exactly.

                  This case could have been stopped before it even got started. But since it's heading towards trial, someone including the judge that let this case move forward think that the plaintiff case should at least be heard.

                  Comment

                  • GTheorenHobbes
                    Banned
                    • Jul 2002
                    • 2572

                    #144
                    Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                    Originally posted by odbman
                    They can appeal in a more pro friendly state and get a reversal.
                    ??? I must've missed how to do this in law school.

                    Comment

                    • odbman
                      Rookie
                      • Aug 2003
                      • 145

                      #145
                      Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                      Originally posted by GTheorenHobbes
                      ??? I must've missed how to do this in law school.
                      you must of Trust Me

                      Comment

                      • capn_razzamataz
                        Rookie
                        • Sep 2005
                        • 402

                        #146
                        Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                        Originally posted by odbman
                        you must of Trust Me
                        ^^^^

                        Yeah. This guy sounds legit.

                        Comment

                        • haze56
                          Banned
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 199

                          #147
                          Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                          I don't understand why people want EA to win...Ok you like madden....So what? If another company could make an NFL game, than EA would step their game up instead of giving us all of these gimmicks that they barely even work on. Why do you think Pro tak sucks? Why do you think every innovation EA brings to madden sucks? They don't care as much. If somebody was on their back taking their money...You know damn well they'd put more effort into things.

                          Comment

                          • All Day CP3
                            Rookie
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 33

                            #148
                            Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                            NFL2k11!!!

                            Comment

                            • budsticky
                              Pro
                              • Aug 2007
                              • 794

                              #149
                              Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                              Originally posted by Bump101
                              How is my point moot, when EA is in court today for everything I pointed out? lmao. Whatever dude. Regardless of what you or me think, it's still up to the courts to decide, which means it's a 50% chance EA wins or lose this case.
                              Wishful thinking. There is about a .00000001% chance that EA loses this case. Being in court today is not relevant. Lots of dumb cases go to court every day. Even if a judge was on crack enough to risk their reputation and actually put this through it would get shot down in appeals in an instant.

                              Comment

                              • odbman
                                Rookie
                                • Aug 2003
                                • 145

                                #150
                                Re: Maddens legal battle starts today 09/14/2009!

                                Originally posted by budsticky
                                Wishful thinking. There is about a .00000001% chance that EA loses this case. Being in court today is not relevant. Lots of dumb cases go to court every day. Even if a judge was on crack enough to risk their reputation and actually put this through it would get shot down in appeals in an instant.
                                I agree with you people don't understand.If by so small chance they pull it out it will be tied up in appeals till the contract expires.

                                Comment

                                Working...