I too just saw A Star Is Born. I thought the characters were excellent combated with terrific performances (including in the music, of course). I did think the pacing and story structure was a bit off though, and some moments weren't as emotionally invigorating as I would have hoped for them to be. Some plot points also didn't completely finish their arcs either, but that's okay because the overall film's message was thorough.
Ultimately I really liked it, and want to learn to play at least two of those songs on guitar now. It did however catch me by surprise that this isn't a completely original film.

Comment