American Horror Story

[Jistic]

Re: American Horror Story

I don't know how they'll be able to match the pace of the Halloween episodes. Pt2 was amazing. Also next week we finally learn about the ultrasound!

[CaptainZombie]

Re: American Horror Story

This show is so bizarre and at times I wonder to myself what the hell am I watching, but I am hooked. Things are starting to make sense as of these past 2 weeks with the Halloween episodes. I do agree with whomever said that it would be best if it was a different family in season 2 or a combination of this family as also being spirits with a new family coming in.

[fistofrage]

Re: American Horror Story

Yes, Tate is a ghost, and that's why Constance stuck around.

Yep, my guess is that after Tate pulled a Columbine, he came home, went down to the basement and ended it.

So Constance had to get out of the house because of everything that happened their, but moved next door so she could be next to her son.

I wonder if Hayden is gone for good now because she wasn't back to the house by dawn or if she just automtically goes back.

Looks like Constance's daughter did die on the property, I think that was her ghost raching for Violet's foot like she did in the past.

[soltrain]

Re: American Horror Story

I still think Tate is a ghost. Remember, he decided to go on the date with Violet on Halloween because he knew he could leave the house.

But a few episodes ago didn't the dad meet Tate out in a park somewhere?

[greenegt]

Re: American Horror Story

That was an excellent episode. Lots of tension with Hayden running around the house. So much was happening, I forgot that we never saw who's hand was reaching for Violet. Probably was Addie. I'm loving this show. I, too, hope that they let this story finish as intended and go in a different direction for season 2.

[Burns11]

Re: American Horror Story

I wonder if Hayden is gone for good now because she wasn't back to the house by dawn or if she just automtically goes back.

I would say automatically went back, otherwise all these ghosts, especially the maid, would just stay out during Halloween.

[fistofrage]

Re: American Horror Story

I would say automatically went back, otherwise all these ghosts, especially the maid, would just stay out during Halloween.

Well they showed all the other ghosts coming back, walking back to the house together at the same time like they had no choice.

You are probably right, but Hayden said something along the lines of "What happens now?"

[Brandwin]

Re: American Horror Story

I would say automatically went back, otherwise all these ghosts, especially the maid, would just stay out during Halloween.

Yep and Tate was in no hurry to go back. But if that's the case, why were the High School kids in a hurry to get back then? Hmmm...

I also think it was Addie's hand reaching from under the bed.

I agree with others, Tate has to be a ghost. There's no way he is not.

[Brandwin]

Re: American Horror Story

That was an excellent episode. Lots of tension with Hayden running around the house. So much was happening, I forgot that we never saw who's hand was reaching for Violet. Probably was Addie. I'm loving this show. I, too, hope that they let this story finish as intended and go in a different direction for season 2.

I thought it was so awesome when I thought she had put the dog in the microwave. Hopefully Hayden stays around.

One more thing - If the spirts are free to roam on Halloween, why were they out on November 1st? Why didn't they have to be back by Midnight?

[Pared]

Re: American Horror Story

Looks like Constance's daughter did die on the property, I think that was her ghost raching for Violet's foot like she did in the past.

Damn it - good call. I'm still up in the air about how the spirit is "trapped" if the body is still on the grounds (the maid) or if they were murdered there).

Yep and Tate was in no hurry to go back. But if that's the case, why were the High School kids in a hurry to get back then? Hmmm...

If they're telling the story in the way I think they are, you are stuck where you are killed/die. Hence them needing to go back... to the school.

The pacing on this show is phenomenal. Last night was a top notch ep.

[shugknight]

Re: American Horror Story

So Tate isn't a ghost, we know that for sure? How could he kill people in school and it was about 16 years ago? The girl said she should be 34, let's say she was a senior in HS when/if Tate killed her, that would be 16 years ago. He can't be in his 30's... Can he?

And I think you meant we know Tate is Constance's son. If Tate isnt a ghost, how old is he? If he's Constance's son, she is up there in age, Addy was in her 30's, correct? So did she have him after her husband died with another man?

I'm confused.

The reason why I thought Tate wasn't a ghost is because he wasn't being forced to go back to the house once the sun was rising like the other ghosts did.

My thinking is that the house is evil in 2 ways. It brings the worst out of you and those in the house. The people that get killed stay in the house as ghosts forever, while the people that committed the murder have immortality but have to face these ghosts every day of their lives, making it a living day in hell.

If you notice..

- Constance was never shown killing herself after she killed the maid and husband.

- Tate was never shown to be killed or have any markings like the other ghostly teens had.

- The gimp who also killed his family, but never killed himself (survived the fire I think) has been seen outside before Halloween.

These 3 are all alive. Their punishment for their sins is facing their decisions everyday of their lives as these ghosts haunt them for all eternity.

The one thing I don't get is the "Save the Baby" plot. What happens when the baby is born?

[Brandwin]

Re: American Horror Story

The reason why I thought Tate wasn't a ghost is because he wasn't being forced to go back to the house once the sun was rising like the other ghosts did.

My thinking is that the house is evil in 2 ways. It brings the worst out of you and those in the house. The people that get killed stay in the house as ghosts forever, while the people that committed the murder have immortality but have to face these ghosts every day of their lives, making it a living day in hell.

If you notice..

- Constance was never shown killing herself after she killed the maid and husband.

- Tate was never shown to be killed or have any markings like the other ghostly teens had.

- The gimp who also killed his family, but never killed himself (survived the fire I think) has been seen outside before Halloween.

These 3 are all alive. Their punishment for their sins is facing their decisions everyday of their lives as these ghosts haunt them for all eternity.

The one thing I don't get is the "Save the Baby" plot. What happens when the baby is born?

But Constance never killed herself.. if she did I missed it.


If Tate isn't a ghost, wouldn't he be a lot older? The teenage girl said she should be 34 and have a husband and child, that's at least 16 years ago if she was an 18 year old senior. That would make Tate at least 30 even if he was a Freshman in High School.


I'm more confused after this episode... but that seems to be the reoccurring theme each week, a few questions answered and a lot more questions pop up.


I can't wait to see how this plays out.

[Burns11]

Re: American Horror Story

The reason why I thought Tate wasn't a ghost is because he wasn't being forced to go back to the house once the sun was rising like the other ghosts did.

My thinking is that the house is evil in 2 ways. It brings the worst out of you and those in the house. The people that get killed stay in the house as ghosts forever, while the people that committed the murder have immortality but have to face these ghosts every day of their lives, making it a living day in hell.

If you notice..

- Constance was never shown killing herself after she killed the maid and husband.

- Tate was never shown to be killed or have any markings like the other ghostly teens had.

- The gimp who also killed his family, but never killed himself (survived the fire I think) has been seen outside before Halloween.

These 3 are all alive. Their punishment for their sins is facing their decisions everyday of their lives as these ghosts haunt them for all eternity.

The one thing I don't get is the "Save the Baby" plot. What happens when the baby is born?

Seems kind of far fetched. Cursed with immortality only to be haunted by ghosts that can't leave a house that you can leave? Sign me up!

The guy who killed the nurses is nowhere to be found, Larry was in jail for a while, etc.

Tate we've seen disappear (during the nurse episode, he disappeared from the bathroom). The two gay guys both looked normal but are confirmed to be ghosts.

[Brandwin]

Re: American Horror Story

Why isn't Tate ever communicating with Constance if that's his mother? Only time I remember them being together was at the end of episode 3 (maybe episode 2) they are in the basement with the Maid and they are looking at the dead bodies.

[fistofrage]

Re: American Horror Story

The reason why I thought Tate wasn't a ghost is because he wasn't being forced to go back to the house once the sun was rising like the other ghosts did.

My thinking is that the house is evil in 2 ways. It brings the worst out of you and those in the house. The people that get killed stay in the house as ghosts forever, while the people that committed the murder have immortality but have to face these ghosts every day of their lives, making it a living day in hell.

If you notice..

- Constance was never shown killing herself after she killed the maid and husband.

- Tate was never shown to be killed or have any markings like the other ghostly teens had.

- The gimp who also killed his family, but never killed himself (survived the fire I think) has been seen outside before Halloween.

These 3 are all alive. Their punishment for their sins is facing their decisions everyday of their lives as these ghosts haunt them for all eternity.

The one thing I don't get is the "Save the Baby" plot. What happens when the baby is born?

Interesting theory, but I am not sure about immortality, Constance has definitely aged. Tate could have OD'd, leaving no markings at all but I am sure he's dead because not everyone like the realtor could see him. Apparantly the burned guy is real. At first I thought he may have been some type of Ben's fight club alter ego, but now I think he's really alive and just crazy and is drawn to the house.

Not sure why the maid can be seen differently by different people, she clearly died at the young age, no way to survive what she went through unless somehow, Constance and the ghost of the doctor figured a way to bring her back and inserted the glass eye. So she died, her soul got trapped, but she lived on somehow. Constance referenced something about, Don't make me kill you again.

I think Constance is pulling quite a few strings at the house, not sure how though.