YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • goh
    Banned
    • Aug 2003
    • 20755

    #61
    Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

    Originally posted by ExtremeGamer
    So, what you are saying is any game that is good is overrated. LOL
    But I didn't think they were good,hence being over rated. It has to be rated highly in the first place to be over rated,well in most cases anyway. Also I forgot Dead Space on the over side.

    Originally posted by JohnnytheSkin
    Hey goh, while it seems you have a lot of hate (and underappreciated love), I will agree in large part on a single underrated game...Psychonauts. Sure some of the platforming was very frustrating, but the humor and charm were off the charts.
    I didn't find any of the platforming frustrating untill the very end but yep that for sure deserved to do better than it did.

    Comment

    • jmood88
      Sean Payton: Retribution
      • Jul 2003
      • 34639

      #62
      Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

      Originally posted by goh
      Oh this'll be fun....

      Over:
      Any Mario after 3
      The N64/GC/Wii Zelda games
      Metroid Prime games
      Any Smash Bros.
      Jak & Daxter series
      Rachet & Clank series (before ToD)
      Uncharted
      Fallout 3
      Oblivion/Morrowind
      All the Halo games
      Left 4 Dead
      Half-life
      The entire Orange Box
      Counterstrike
      The DS as a whole
      The Wii as a whole
      Madden 2004
      Bioshock
      Both Forza games
      Gears of War
      Resistance
      Rock Band 2 (*not including any add-ons or DLC)
      Call of Duty 2
      Final Fantasy 9
      Vandal Hearts
      Rainbow's MX games
      Resident Evil 4
      MGS 2 & 3
      Ninja Gaiden
      All the Splinter Cell sequels
      Shadow of the Colossus
      GRID
      Rainbow 6 Vegas/2
      God of War
      Devil May Cry 3/4
      Shenmue
      Knights of the Old Republic II

      Under:
      JSRF
      PGR 4
      PDZ
      Haunting Ground
      Obscure
      Folklore
      F1 CE
      SMT series
      The PS3
      Thrasher Skate & Destroy
      The 3 GTA games before GTA III
      The Longest Journey/Dreamfall
      Grim Fandango
      Disgaea series
      Chrono Cross (Trigger always gets the love!)
      Valkyria Chronicles
      Valkyire Profile 2
      Shadow Hearts series
      Vandal Hearts 2
      Psychonauts
      Okami
      Illbleed
      Fighting Vipers/2/Fighter's Megamix
      Pixel Junk Eden
      Outlaw Golf 2
      Deus Ex
      I have honestly never seen you say that you like anything.
      Originally posted by Blzer
      Let me assure you that I am a huge proponent of size, and it greatly matters. Don't ever let anyone tell you otherwise.

      If I went any bigger, it would not have properly fit with my equipment, so I had to optimize. I'm okay with it, but I also know what I'm missing with those five inches. :)

      Comment

      • Vast
        MVP
        • Sep 2003
        • 4015

        #63
        Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

        Originally posted by goh
        Oh this'll be fun....

        Over:
        Any Mario after 3
        The N64/GC/Wii Zelda games
        Metroid Prime games
        Any Smash Bros.
        Jak & Daxter series
        Rachet & Clank series (before ToD)
        Uncharted
        Fallout 3
        Oblivion/Morrowind
        All the Halo games
        Left 4 Dead
        Half-life
        The entire Orange Box
        Counterstrike
        The DS as a whole
        The Wii as a whole
        Madden 2004
        Bioshock
        Both Forza games
        Gears of War
        Resistance
        Rock Band 2 (*not including any add-ons or DLC)
        Call of Duty 2
        Final Fantasy 9
        Vandal Hearts
        Rainbow's MX games
        Resident Evil 4
        MGS 2 & 3
        Ninja Gaiden
        All the Splinter Cell sequels
        Shadow of the Colossus
        GRID
        Rainbow 6 Vegas/2
        God of War
        Devil May Cry 3/4
        Shenmue
        Knights of the Old Republic II

        Under:
        JSRF
        PGR 4
        PDZ
        Haunting Ground
        Obscure
        Folklore
        F1 CE
        SMT series
        The PS3
        Thrasher Skate & Destroy
        The 3 GTA games before GTA III
        The Longest Journey/Dreamfall
        Grim Fandango
        Disgaea series
        Chrono Cross (Trigger always gets the love!)
        Valkyria Chronicles
        Valkyire Profile 2
        Shadow Hearts series
        Vandal Hearts 2
        Psychonauts
        Okami
        Illbleed
        Fighting Vipers/2/Fighter's Megamix
        Pixel Junk Eden
        Outlaw Golf 2
        Deus Ex
        Wow dude you're bugging with that over list. I think your definition of overrated is MUCH different than ours.
        "I'm addicted to Video Games, and i chase it with a little OS." -Winston Churchill

        Comment

        • goh
          Banned
          • Aug 2003
          • 20755

          #64
          Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

          Originally posted by jmood88
          I have honestly never seen you say that you like anything.
          I like all the games on the under list.
          I forgot to add God Hand there.

          Originally posted by Vast
          I think your definition of overrated is MUCH different than ours.
          Games that get highly rated or are otherwise loved but are really of mediocre or poor quality. That much different? Wich reminds me I forgot GH 3.

          Comment

          • Hooe
            Hall Of Fame
            • Aug 2002
            • 21554

            #65
            Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

            First game that came to mind as underrated was Twisted Metal 4 for the PSX, particularly as a multiplayer game.

            Overrated? Strike me down with a lightning bolt, but NFL 2K5.

            Comment

            • Uhfan
              Pro
              • Jun 2003
              • 539

              #66
              Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

              Underrated:

              RESIDENT EVIL 1 (greatest game ever)
              Grand Theft Auto 3 (this game had no hype at all, I remember reading EGM and they only had a small little blurb the month before release, I was like how is this game not on everyones radar)
              Final Fantasy Tactics (best final fantasy)
              FInal Fantasy III
              Twisted Metal 2 (PS1)
              Brave Fencer Musashi (PS1)
              Red Faction (PS2)
              Counter Strike
              StarCraft
              Last edited by Uhfan; 01-22-2009, 07:03 AM.

              Comment

              • MC Fatigue
                Banned
                • Feb 2006
                • 4150

                #67
                Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

                Originally posted by Uhfan
                Underrated: StarCraft
                wahhhh?

                For cereals?

                You can't be serious. Starcraft is consistently on top 100, 50, and 20 "best games ever" lists, and is highly regarded as one of the most important games in the history of gaming.

                It's over 10 years old and it's still played across the world and used in video gaming tournaments.

                It's one of the most popular video games ever.
                Last edited by MC Fatigue; 01-22-2009, 10:08 AM.

                Comment

                • Pete1210
                  MVP
                  • Aug 2006
                  • 3277

                  #68
                  Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

                  Originally posted by Uhfan
                  Underrated:

                  RESIDENT EVIL 1 (greatest game ever)
                  Grand Theft Auto 3 (this game had no hype at all, I remember reading EGM and they only had a small little blurb the month before release, I was like how is this game not on everyones radar)
                  Final Fantasy Tactics (best final fantasy)
                  FInal Fantasy III
                  Twisted Metal 2 (PS1)
                  Brave Fencer Musashi (PS1)
                  Red Faction (PS2)
                  Counter Strike
                  StarCraft
                  How are GTA3, Starcraft and Counterstrike underated? Weren't they all very very popular games with good to high review scores?

                  Comment

                  • grunt
                    Banned
                    • Jul 2002
                    • 9527

                    #69
                    Re: YOUR most overrated/underrated game of all-time!

                    Over
                    FPS : Just can't play them for more than one sitting

                    Under

                    Don King: Prize Fighter
                    Zone of Enders 2
                    APF2k8
                    Madden 09

                    Comment

                    Working...