Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

[JohnnytheSkin]

I'm itching for an RPG fix but can't quite decide on which title to replay. I've already completed Fallout 3 (but not the DLC), Fable II (minus the DLC), and was halfway through Oblivion before being distracted by other games.

So...vote away and post your pros and cons.

[Cusefan]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

You definatly cannot go wrong with Oblivion, but I would replay Mass Effect, the sequel is coming out sooner.

Did you play all of the Fallout DLC?

[Pokes]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I'd go with Fallout 3 or Mass Effect if you have it.

[JohnnytheSkin]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

You definatly cannot go wrong with Oblivion, but I would replay Mass Effect, the sequel is coming out sooner.

Did you play all of the Fallout DLC?

I'm waiting until the sequel is closer for another run through Mass Effect (have gone through it two times already).

As for the Fallout DLC, I downloaded all of them but have only gone through Anchorage.

[thaima1shu]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I'd go with Fallout 3.

For me, Fable II's ending was weak, so I never got the itch to play it over again. Sold the game right after I finished it, essentially. Oblivion is good, but I could never really get into it for some reason.

[trobinson97]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

From the ones listed, I'd say Oblivion or Fallout 3. They are both great games, aside from the settings are pretty similar. If you haven't played Mass Effect however, PLAY IT!!!

[Cusefan]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

Personally I would play The Pitt and Broken Steel before doing anything else.

[Skyboxer]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I have/had them all and IMO it's Oblivion by far. Fallout IS a great game and would also be worthy but if I had to have just one it would be Oblivion.

[goh]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I voted for Fable II,you can be bad instead of good this time or good instead of bad. Also because I think Fallout 3 is terrible though had decent ideas and Oblivion wasn't so great either.

[Candyman5]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

If you have Oblivion and Fallout 3 already I will have to suggest Star Ocean: The Last Hope(Its Real Time). Very good game IMO. Also Mass Effect if you never played it. Lost Oddysey is good also(Turn Based).

[Skyboxer]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I voted for Fable II,you can be bad instead of good this time or good instead of bad. Also because I think Fallout 3 is terrible though had decent ideas and Oblivion wasn't so great either.

Oblivion wasn't so great? Fallout 3 terrible??
Two of the better games on 360 if you really like RPG's....IMO and yes I know you are entitled to you opinion also. It just shocked me a bit on how you labeled them....

Fable while good was a short game to say the least. I enjoyed it but I wouldn't even recommend it new. Get it cheaper used.

[Behindshadows]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

Since you limited your options. Out of your options, I'd say Fallout.

But if your open to other options, I'd say, Lost Odyssey







or

Blue Dragon - which are both story driven and have great battle scenes and sequences.

[ChubbyBanana]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I enjoy Fallout myself, although I think that Oblivion is a good choice.

I found myself more into the futuristic-post-appocalyptic-nuclear-guns setting in Fallout 3 than Oblivion's Medieval time period.

[Skyboxer]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I enjoy Fallout myself, although I think that Oblivion is a good choice.

I found myself more into the futuristic-post-appocalyptic-nuclear-guns setting in Fallout 3 than Oblivion's Medieval time period.

Good point. That's why I prefer Oblivion as I prefer Medieval stuff...

[Candyman5]

Re: Need help deciding which 360 RPG to replay

I enjoy Fallout myself, although I think that Oblivion is a good choice.

I found myself more into the futuristic-post-appocalyptic-nuclear-guns setting in Fallout 3 than Oblivion's Medieval time period.

Same here, I just liked the Color to Oblivion instead of the dull concrete wasteland. Not knocking any game though, both are good play throughs. BTW, when the hell are you actually on Live...Lol. Keeo sending ya room mate Party Invites.