OSFM V1 Corrections Thread

[Cavicchi]

Quote: Originally Posted by shark547

Unfortunately you will get different results on some pitchers from every web site. Even fangraphs and Brooks who appear to use the same info have different pitches listed quite a bit. You really have to pick one and go with it.

Brooks is much more reliable than fangraphs, not even close--and that is my opinion. Recent article with Bumgarner had him mentioning his cutter, which Brooks states is that pitch, not Slider. You might want to look at the website of brooksbaseball.net and read how they go about determining pitch types, and who are the people there.

You show me what source states Reyes has a FB, RFB, and 2-seam fastball and we can discuss this further.

[shark547]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cavicchi

Brooks is much more reliable than fangraphs, not even close--and that is my opinion. Recent article with Bumgarner had him mentioning his cutter, which Brooks states is that pitch, not Slider. You might want to look at the website of brooksbaseball.net and read how they go about determining pitch types, and who are the people there. You show me what source states Reyes has a FB, RFB, and 2-seam fastball and we can discuss this further.

You won't get any argument from me. I just meant that you could drive yourself crazy if you were looking at several different sources.

[BU1B22]

I don't have time to read through all of the submissions, but the Cleveland Indians outfielder Tyler Naquin has a pretty poor rating. I'm not an Indians fan, but I know that Naquin doesn't deserve the rating in the 50s if hes at least an occasional starter in centerfield.

[PhillyPhan11]

78 potential rating for Odubel Herrera definitely seems low to me. Batted .297 as a rookie and now batting .283 with .442 obp. as a 24 year old. I would say he's probably more of 85 or 86 potential player.

[RidinDwnKingsley]

Quote: Originally Posted by PhillyPhan11

78 potential rating for Odubel Herrera definitely seems low to me. Batted .297 as a rookie and now batting .283 with .442 obp. as a 24 year old. I would say he's probably more of 85 or 86 potential player.

Sony rated him sorry

[Side Effect]

Reds released RP Ryan Mattheus.


Angels officially sign SP Kyle Kendrick (He was on their team in V1, but making sure he's still there for V2)

[Dynasty Legend 99]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

This is my motto.

The Season Stats are all correct, so just add those up and it's all correct.


It's not like players have stats from seasons they haven't played.