Xbox Series S. Exhibition.
Forward progress doesn't register sometimes, unless these are new, obvious coaches challenge situations--which I don't think is the case because I went in to check the replay without a prompt regarding challenges.
I noticed it in an exhibition game last night and thought it was just a bad spot or a one-off thing but I just had this happen...
3rd and 1, I get the first down by a good yard and a half before being pushed backwards. I return to the playcalling screen and I'm confused as to why the FG option is there. Lo and behold, it's 4th and inches.