Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Green Bay Packers and Minnesota Vikings

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by bucky60

I'm not saying Donny's are right or wrong. And I'm not even disputing that guys claim that Quarless is faster. I'm just disputing how much faster he things Quarless is. For some reason, he thinks Quarless gets good separation, and Finley can only out jump people.

So are you disputing that Quarless should be 82 speed and Finley 77 speed?

[bucky60]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

So are you disputing that Quarless should be 82 speed and Finley 77 speed?

Yeah, I would dispute that. I don't think there is much difference between the two, and I really don't know which one has faster full pad game speed.

Why do you ask?

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by bucky60

Yeah, I would dispute that. I don't think there is much difference between the two, and I really don't know which one has faster full pad game speed. Why do you ask?

You said you were disputing "how much" faster he was, and I wasn't sure if you saw what speed he gave each player.

[bucky60]

I think he gave each player this if I read his post correctly:

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

And for those who follow the in-game speeds its: Driver: 82 Quarless: 76 Finley: 75 The Driver to Finley differential is what bugs me the most because EA has Finley ahead of Driver.

Which confuses me on how Finley just be a jump ball guy and Quarless has potential to get good separation.

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

You said you were disputing "how much" faster he was, and I wasn't sure if you saw what speed he gave each player.

I didn't see him rate Quarless at 82 and Finley at 77. I must have missed that. And I would dispute it.

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by bucky60

I think he gave each player this if I read his post correctly: Which confuses me on how Finley just be a jump ball guy and Quarless has potential to get good separation. I didn't see him rate Quarless at 82 and Finley at 77. I must have missed that. And I would dispute it.

He rates every player in the NFL at this site, which is also in his sig: www.fbgratings.com/members

[JJ_Bills9]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

I agree. He does not have elite speed. He is a good leaper though, and is pretty darn agile for a TE.

He's actually a quite awful leaper posting a beastly 27.5 inch vertical at the combine. Guy just isn't all that athletic to be honest. Finley that is.

And don't ever use a pro-day result when talking about 40 times. They are not electronic, therefore they are not accurate. Combine results are the only accurate 40 times.

[suthrnthug]

If you guys don't think Finley is fast, you try covering him. I'm sure Detroit, Chicago, and Minnesota would appreciate the help.

He might not look fast on TV but keep in mind he is 6'5 240+ lbs. I haven't seen one LB/DB lock him down yet. That's my two cents.

Go Pack!

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by genghisfrog

Combine #s? Come on man. These guys aren't all rookies now. People get faster and slower. Should Finley be an 86 speed based on other TEs ratings? No. Is he faster than Quarless, yes. So go research your combine numbers and I'll got by what I see on the field and that is Finley is faster than Quarless.

I even used the in-game 40s. Please provide some more evidence other than what you see on the field. I cannot take it seriously until you give me something to chew on.