MLB '10: The Show - Top 5 Left Fielders

[DanH35]

Bay rated higher than Holliday is laughably bad. Holliday's WAR last 3 years: 8.0, 6.3, 5.7. Bay's: 0.0, 2.9, 3.5.

[skinfan31]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigjake62505

Cant see crawford being 9th and cant see manny being so high, the guy throws like a girl and is so one dimensional. Add that to the 50 game suspension and steadly decling numbers when he came back I just dont see it.

I agree. No way Crawford is that low. Top 5 easy. Manny is so one dimensional, no wheels, arm, or field. He might be marginal top 10 at best.

[klb835]

the most realistic game has the most unrealistic ratings hahaha

first vazquez is rated better than cc sabathia
second jose reyes better then ramirez
third crawford 9th? behind juan rivera? HOLY CRAP I just about passed out. Good job on the realism "sigh" Looks like some editing will need to be done

[BDKiiing]

dang, i was hoping to see Braun's stance in the game, as well as him being alot faster

[EnigmaNemesis]

Why do people keep saying Manny has no arm. Yes he isn't that great of a fielder, but he is more a Guerrero arm than Johnny Damon.

He has 128 career assists in his 17 seasons (impressive for a man with no arm ). Very under-rated in that category due to his sloppy routine play.

Seen him gun guys down at home without a cutoff in left at Fenway, as well as runners not getting back to first in time on outs which thought the same of him and his arm.

[burds13]

Crawford's obviously a very good player... but let's not miss the bowl while urinating, here.

He's certainly not a top five offensive left fielder over the past 3 years. Obviously he is very good defensively and great on the bases, and I agree he should be higher than 9... but not ahead of anyone in the top five.

http://www.fangraphs.com/statss.aspx...01&position=of

[Derek2Jeter]

Where's Brett Gardner?!?!?!? WTF

haha jkjk people im just kidding.

[GEORGE LUZ]

This list is based on overall, not just offense. Overall is a combo of contact, power, fielding, speed, and other. Manny and Bay should both be F's at fielding and speed. Crawford is an A speed and should be an A at defense too. And it's not like Crawford is awful at offense, he is a career .295 hitter. And Manny is 37; these lists should take age into account more.