NBA 2K11: Starting Five Roster Ratings

[jr2424]

Quote: Originally Posted by dropseven

There is no way that Dirk is 7 points less skilled than Tim Duncan. Dirk is currently a top 7-10 player in the league and virtually unguardable. So much disrespect. KD's had one great year and he's a 91...that's fair, KD'sa great player...Dirk has won an MVP and averaged around 25 and 8 for the last 5 seasons...crazy. There should only be 2 players ranked over 93 besides MJ and that's Lebron and Kobe....and they should be 94/95 max.

I agree that Timmy shouldn't be seven points higher but I can see him maybe one or two points higher. Dirk kills him from 3s and the free-throw line. Dirk is a better mid-range shooter too, though I don't think the disparity is as much as it is from deep. But Timmy is a better rebounder, low-post scorer, defender and maybe edges Dirk as a passer (mostly out of the post). But again, I agree Duncan shouldn't be that much better if at all.

And you said there should be only 2 players besides MJ ranked 94-95. So you're also talking about other legends then? If so, then Magic needs to be up there. What about Bird and Dominique? If only talking about current-day players, then I could see that.

[youvalss]

Quote: Originally Posted by jeebs9

I hate quoting myself...But let me get it out of the way.

I totally aree with that quote. I guess we shouldn't take ratings too seriously as we did 5-10 years ago. There's more than that.

[pepp32]

WTF?! Rondo 87 and Rose 85.......lmao......Rose>Rondo

[CallMeDrop]

Quote: Originally Posted by jr2424

I agree that Timmy shouldn't be seven points higher but I can see him maybe one or two points higher. Dirk kills him from 3s and the free-throw line. Dirk is a better mid-range shooter too, though I don't think the disparity is as much as it is from deep. But Timmy is a better rebounder, low-post scorer, defender and maybe edges Dirk as a passer (mostly out of the post). But again, I agree Duncan shouldn't be that much better if at all. And you said there should be only 2 players besides MJ ranked 94-95. So you're also talking about other legends then? If so, then Magic needs to be up there. What about Bird and Dominique? If only talking about current-day players, then I could see that.

My bad homie...I just meant current rosters. I included MJ because he's on the cover. Legends are the Legends...

[Rocboyz101]

Good to see they kept nash at about the same ratings. Everything looks good imo. Nothing jumps out as particularly bad, rondo looks a little high. Thats probably the rebounding thats bumping the rating though.

[glenn16]

gerald wallace should be 85 or 86

[onyx030]

Zach Randolph 80
Antwon Jamison 78
paint power house vs ultrafail ex-starplayer, do i have to understand that ?

joe johnson as an 88 doesn't seem to fit either when guys like wade james and kobe got 97 while mello gets 93( which i cant agree to that either that all 3 got the same rating)

nowitzki 83 and duncen 90, ok this is just BS especially as i see that david lee got an 83,too

john wall 81, goerge hill 76 . afflalo 65 . kevin martin 80
pls explain how a rookie without 1 nba game and a struggling summer league session is higher rated then 3 solid shooting guards

[Greene_Flash03]

I don't care much about these ratings, but IMO Durant should be 97 just like Kobe and LeBron..